2 ms·
Something that might move hundreds of percentage points in either direction in a given year seems like a poor hedge against inflation to me.
by asdff 5y ago
Something that might move hundreds of percentage points in either direction in a given year seems like a poor hedge against inflation to me.
- orthros 5y agoI'll be the pedant to point out it can't move more than 100% on the downside. Which since it has risen more than 100% in less than a year seems like a decent deal although fraught with risk to be sure.
- yaa_minu 5y agoYes, in the short term, neither gold nor even gold is a good hedge. Cash will always be superior in the short term unless we're in a hyperinflationary situation. However, on a long enough time scale, gold and bitcoin can function as great inflation hedges. I say this with a little bit of caution especially for bitcoin because it's only a few years old but we know for this short 12 year period that no one has lost money by holding bitcoin for more than 4 years.
- candiodari 5y agoI think I'm against this argument, and instead present of Warren Buffet's. If you think gold is a good hedge against inflation, a consumer staple with a safe position (ie. Coca-Cola) is a better inflation hedge. The same argument would apply to a whole lot of companies in the "necessities" department. They provide every bit of inflation hedge value Gold provides, but also provide dividend and stock appreciation.
- cwkoss 5y agoI would be very surprised if Bitcoin moved more than 100 percentage points downwards :-P But on a more serious note, this bet is based on the idea that if/as USD hegemony collapses (in ~decade time scale), inflation will accelerate and there is an increased chance that Bitcoin becomes world reserve currency. I believe Bitcoin volatility will decrease as price grows (it already has to an extent), and once it has about one more ~10x increase (reaching roughly market cap of total earth gold supply) the bubble/bust pattern will break and it'll become more stable. But who knows. I recommend keeping 1-5% of net asset value in cryptocurrency (BTC, ETH, maybe ADA if you like risk, roughly weighted by market cap and ignoring long tail of unproven coins), but it is certainly a very risky investment and securing them has unique technical challenges that make them less suitable for non-technicals.
- Geee 5y agoThere are just two years in Bitcoin's history when it had a negative return: https://stats.buybitcoinworldwide.com/yearly-candles/ https://stats.buybitcoinworldwide.com/yearly-candles/
- pxue 5y agoThat's what Ponzi scheme sales person would proclaim, until not true.
- cwkoss 5y agoDiscussing historical performance is ubiquitous among all asset classes. If you're going to try to argue that Bitcoin is a Ponzi scheme, at least put some effort into the argument. This is just lazy and simplistic.