5 ms·
One of the reasons there is so much confusion on this is that there are at least two different valid ways to look at it, but any given person usually only knows
by tzs 5y ago
One of the reasons there is so much confusion on this is that there are at least two different valid ways to look at it, but any given person usually only knows one of them (or rather, a simplified version of a serious misunderstanding of one of them). Different people know a different one of them, and thus argument breaks out whenever the topic comes up.
NASA has a bunch of aerodynamics educational material on their old Glenn Research Center website. Here's a page on these two different ways to look at lift [1].
Very briefly, the gas flow has to simultaneously conserve mass, momentum, and energy.
One approach is to consider conservation of energy. When you work out the implications of that you get different flow velocity over different parts of the wing and different pressure due to those differences. When you integrate the pressure over the whole wing you find that you get lift.
The other approach is to consider conservation of momentum. Working out the implications of that, you get velocity differences in the flow. If you integrate those around the whole wing, you find that there is a net turning of the flow downward. Conservation of momentum requires that the wing gets momentum opposite of that and we have lift.
[1] https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/bernnew.html https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/bernnew.html
- perl4ever 5y agoDoes this all work for symmetric wing cross sections?
- dylan604 5y ago>or rather, a simplified version of a serious misunderstanding of one of them or both?
- jerf 5y agoI think it's a classic case of not understanding equality, hiding behind enough complexity that it's a bit more complicated than usual. Many people have a hard time not reading equalities as an implication... if there's a mass and an acceleration, then there's a force. But the equality says, it's the same. It isn't an if-then, it is that whereever there is a mass that is accelerating, that is force. The force doesn't "cause" the mass to accelerate and the mass accelerating doesn't "cause" the force; they're equal, they're the same thing, trying to wedge in between the two of them is a fatal error, and a very common one in physics education. Both of those approaches are equal. Or, to put it another way, it isn't that the fast moving air and the slow moving air "causing" a pressure differential which then "causes" lift... it's one integrated process. They aren't separable. You can't have different levels of pressure without some effect on air velocity, you can't have forces in the air without some effect on pressure, etc. The whole argument is all "But what causes what?" and the only correct answer is that it's an equality, not an implication. It can only be properly understood as a single whole that can be looked at in several ways.
- ummonk 5y agoThe point is that it's much easier to intuite which way the air gets deflected (and thus change in momentum) than where the air speeds up or slows down. In fact, the easiest way to know where the air speeds up and slows down is indirectly based on where the pressure will be higher and where it will be lower, since the latter is easier to intuit than the former.