8 ms·
Again: Relevant Si compounds don't exist here, because there is no Si-based life here. Our favorite carbon compounds would identically not exist in a Si-based
by ncmncm 5y ago
Again: Relevant Si compounds don't exist here, because there is no Si-based life here. Our favorite carbon compounds would identically not exist in a Si-based ecosystem. That the useful compounds would not be simple substitutions of Si for C is of no importance. As I noted, some liquid-analog is likely involved in any spontaneously evolved ecology, but it does not need to be water, or even, technically, liquid-as-such.
Nature is not constrained to the limits of your imagination. I am frankly surprised to find you continuing to insist it is.
- Retric 5y agoThe tangible existence is irrelevant, computational chemistry is more than capable of exploring this territory. The issue isn’t simply finding giant complex molecules that would make up such hypothetical lifeforms it’s looking for the basic building blocks. In the end all of chemistry comes down to quantum mechanics it really is quite constrained. Put another way you can list our every possible 2-9 atom molecule containing Silicon plus common elements and look at how the behave.
- ncmncm 5y agoAnd, you claim to have not just made such a list, but also explored all of their possible interactions with one another and with what could be common non-Si compounds in their vicinity? You and what ten thousand universities? You are just making things up. Who do you imagine believes you? Why do you want them to believe you?
- Retric 5y agoNo, can is not did. My point was it’s a finite space. People have explored some of this space and found nothing.