6 ms·
I'm a huge fan of being able to use my phone for everything whenever possible -- no wallet, no keys, no cards. So this is awesome on the part of Apple, but wha
by crazygringo 5y ago
I'm a huge fan of being able to use my phone for everything whenever possible -- no wallet, no keys, no cards.
So this is awesome on the part of Apple, but what about Android? Are student ID's on Android already a thing? Are they being developed?
Or are there unique aspects of Apple controlling the hardware that inherently make cards like these more secure on Apple, that Android can't match (but maybe Pixel can)?
- tssva 5y agoStudent IDs are already available on Android including some of the schools mentioned.
- secabeen 5y agoYeah, this is an Apple article, so it's silent on Android support. No college with any form of public remit would roll out a student ID system that required an apple device; it would run into all sorts of equity issues.
- wlesieutre 5y agoLooks like yes: https://support.google.com/pay/answer/9867059?hl=en https://support.google.com/pay/answer/9867059?hl=en > You can add your campus ID card to your Android phone to securely access your residence hall. You can also use your campus ID with Google Pay to pay for things on campus such as dining, laundry, vending, books, and more.
- kyrra 5y ago(googler, opinions are my own). I really wish we would have stayed with the Google Wallet moniker. Seeing that you can add student IDs, Walgreens Card[0], Vaccine status/card[1], various metro cards (like Japan's Suica[2]), it is more like a wallet than a pay app at this point. [0] https://www.walgreens.com/topic/promotion/google-pay.jsp https://www.walgreens.com/topic/promotion/google-pay.jsp [1] https://support.google.com/googlepay/answer/10890261?visit_id=637636016262375930-2587230079&rd=1 https://support.google.com/googlepay/answer/10890261?visit_i... [2] https://blog.google/products/google-pay/add-suica-and-waon-google-pay-japan/ https://blog.google/products/google-pay/add-suica-and-waon-g...
- Causality1 5y ago"The only way to justify my job is to convince people things need to be changed" is a cancer in Google. It's why they renamed the Android Market the "Play Store" as if that name wasn't fucking ridiculous.
- wlesieutre 5y agoI assume the Play Store rename was motivated by wanting to have it under proprietary branding, instead of being a generic store name that's also available to de-Googled competitors who don't ship Google Play services.
- wlesieutre 5y agoYeah as a non-Android user I was confused by this page. You have to add your card to Google Pay to be able to use it for dorm entry? That's very Google of them, like needing to enable "Web & App Activity" tracking to be able to get home/work directions in Maps. But then I wasn't sure if they just branded "any NFC pass you can put in your phone" as "Google Pay" which would be stupid but believable. Thanks for confirming.
- FractalParadigm 5y agoNow that it's (clearly) catching on, I can see Google and/or Samsung re-branding their Pay apps to something else (maybe Google goes back to Wallet?) and including ID capabilities. Personally while I like the idea of digital ID, never losing your cards, almost-impossible to get stolen, I don't like the idea that if someone (i.e. a LEO) needs to see my information, I might need to hand them my device, and in a some jurisdictions could be considered granting consent to a search. I also don't like the idea of what happens if your phone is damaged or the battery dies and it contains your only identification.
- xrendan 5y agoIn my province (Alberta) I'm allowed to carry digital proof of insurance for my car instead of the standard pink sheet. The app has a mode that displays the insurance info on the lockscreen while locking the rest of the phone to the police (or whoever else needs to see it). So there are technical solutions to the first issue. The second issue, I completely agree, I would rather the system be an addition to existing IDs rather than a replacement to them.
- throwawayboise 5y agoSo much complexity, so many third parties you have to rely upon to not make any mistakes (or be abusive), for the convenience of not carrying a slip of paper in the glove box of your car....
- meowkit 5y agoStrawman, Mr. Luddite. I don’t want cash, a wallet, plastic cards, metal keys, or tons of slips of paper from receipts and all other kinds of bullshit. Putting it on the phone as a native app is hardly complex. Use QR codes, an officer won’t need to look at your phone
- lintroller 5y agoWhile I am not a security expert, it seems like a security risk for an officer to scan a QR code with their device.
- fsflover 5y ago> So this is awesome on the part of Apple, but what about Android? But what if I have neither iOS, nor Android? Why must the government/universities support the duopoly?
- JohnWhigham 5y agoWhen I was still a kid, I was completely looking forward to where a mobile phone could be an all-in-one solution for carrying stuff. I didn't know how it was going to look, but I wanted it. Now looking at how maliciously neglectful big tech companies have been with data over the past decade, I don't want these companies handling anything regarding official documents.
- throwawayboise 5y agoMy take would be, if my employer requires some kind of credential on a mobile device in order for me to be able to work, they can provide me with the mobile device (which I will use only and exclusively for work purposes).
- pomian 5y agoYes. This. A different device. Only for this. Only turn it on when needed. Keep, turned off, in lead box otherwise. How else? But then what? One device for the bank. One device for your passport. One device for school. Etc.
- eptcyka 5y agoWhat if I have Android but not Google services?
- secabeen 5y agoApple PR is being really careful with their language: "This fall, the University of Alabama will be the first school to exclusively issue mobile student IDs to their 38,000 students with eligible devices." The UofA action card office will continue to produce physical cards for students, no mobile device required: https://actcard.ua.edu/faq/ https://actcard.ua.edu/faq/
- motohagiography 5y agoAs I understand it, the Apple devices have a secure element with initialization keys written at time of manufacture, which are then personalized to the user with a new/unique set as part of a registration, but verifiable as having being provisioned, so there is a cryptgraphic chain of trust going back to the manufacture of the secure element. Android is an operating system for a bunch of OEMs who don't have secure elements in their devices, and even ones who do still exist in a fragmented ecosystem where their verification doesn't include ones outside their models. Modern chips have a similar feature, but the key management between manufacturers is an unsolved business problem. There are technical ways to solve it, but higher level interoperability beyond enforced standards has never a high priority for OEMs. The economics haven't been there. You could make an inferior one for Android devices, but it likely wouldn't be sufficiently secure to handle payments, credit, taxation, fines, social compliance scores, and other use cases for identity. Identity security needs to be strong enough to be used as a stick, and the only carrots it offers are those whose scarcity is artificially managed. Realistically, if you are attending a university, the cost of an Apple device can just be priced into your loan, and strategically, making university student products consolidate Apple's dominance of the middle class market and up, and as a status symbol of societal membership, sort of how Facebook started in the college system. I'm skeptical of digital identity companies (as distinct from authentication services) because to me their entire business model reduces to Hollerith machines as a service, so YMMV on this view.
- echelon 5y agoIt sounds like you're advocating for an Apple monopoly here. I'm also laughing that you say Android isn't secure enough to handle payments. Millions of people use it to do so every day.
- motohagiography 5y agoIt's been a few years since I looked at it, but I'd be interested to see the workaround the EMV partners finally used to do tokenization. Last I saw it some years ago, they were persisting what should have been single use keys (SUKs) for multiple transactions (calling them limited LUKs) so that they could handle an offline payment mode. Apple didn't have that problem because of their SE. I'm sure there are lots of Android pay solutions, but the risk profile is very different, the solutions for it are limited, and keys in software has a catastrophic failure mode. What's very likely is Android payment solutions are taking a fraud management approach with some kind of government backstop, as from a technical security perspective, software has hard limits. It's not a monopoly if it's only for university educated people who get access to exclusive services. You can start your own managerialist economy.
- ok123456 5y agoWhat if you get pulled over and can't show proof of insurance because your phone battery is dead? What if the cop drops your phone walking back to their car to take down your information? What if the cop creeps through your messages while he has your phone? Personally, I'd rather just have a piece of paper ready.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoYou should not even have to show proof of insurance. There should be a database the cop’s license plate scanner can look into and show the cop everything they need to know. I assume there already is, and the paper requirements are just something for people to trip over and trigger other suspicions. The cop actually does not even need to know about insurance at all. The state charges everyone a yearly tax anyway (“vehicle registration”), they could easily just not let people renew this registration if they don’t have insurance.
- basch 5y agoIMHO, Apple would be wise to be more like Microsoft, Facebook, and Google and release some Android apps. Apple Wallet should be one of the first. Nobody is buying Apple devices for Apple Pay alone. They already realize the benefit having Apple Music be cross platform.