5 ms·
> Will USBs, home routers, and printers that I buy on amazon require my KYC/AML? Of course not. Those are products not services. Let's break down the statemen
by jcranmer 5y ago
> Will USBs, home routers, and printers that I buy on amazon require my KYC/AML?
Of course not. Those are products not services.
Let's break down the statement in detail:
> digital assets
This is something I'd expect to be defined in the definitions section of the act. Even if it's not, the most reasonable interpretation is going to be something along the lines of any digital product whose ownership can be traded for material value gain, which would include cryptocurrencies, NFTs, and possibly MMO virtual currencies. There's definitely a lot of gray area in defining digital assets, but pretending that word documents and the like are digital assets is intentionally misreading the law.
> effectuating transfers
The plain definition of "effectuate" is "to bring about" or some other variation that specifically implies a causal link. To effectuate something requires that the agent itself is causing it to happen. Mere incidental participation wouldn't be sufficient. If I tell someone to take $1000 out of my ATM in cash and send it to somebody else in the mail, the person who is following my instructions is effectuating the transaction; the post office is not.
> providing any service
As mentioned above, we are specifically restricting this only to entities that are providing services, not products. So people whose roles are limited to providing products (such as software developers) are not affected by this rule.
> responsible for and regularly providing
And said services have to be provided on more than a one-off basis. So even the example I gave earlier of ordering someone to move money around wouldn't qualify; the person basically has to be willing to do this on an ongoing purpose, essentially as their business model, for this provision to kick in.
In other words, the people who are affected by this are going to be those who are offering banking-like services for digital assets (e.g., cryptocurrencies, NFTs, WoW gold). Pedestrian things like routers and USBs are completely unaffected. The assertion of a sibling comment that software developers are potentially at risk is equally asinine. The people who are affected are the cryptocurrency exchanges, probably services like cryptocurrency tumblers, possibly miners or companies that operate MMOs.
- dogman144 5y agoIt sounds like you have a much better handle on the law’s terminology in application than the industry groups and legal /regulatory teams do, which is good.
- donmcronald 5y agoThings like ENS/HNS domains will be some of that grey area for assets IMO. Right now I think a normal domain is a bit of a grey area (asset vs expense), but at least there’s no reporting requirement for them. Will my (hypothetical) .eth domain be considered a digital asset?
- nybble41 5y ago> So people whose roles are limited to providing products (such as software developers) are not affected by this rule. If you can classify software development as providing a product and not a service then miners can certainly make the same argument regarding the data they produce. More easily, in fact, since they have no particular business relationship with the entities blindly submitting transactions to the network. Software developers are routinely involved in maintenance and support contracts, or producing new software to spec, which is more of a service than a product. The exchanges will be covered, of course, but they're so buried in onerous KYC/AML requirements already that they may not notice any difference.