3 ms·
Competing private Ministries of Truth will be fun; once they start to disagree. Who won that election, again?
by h2odragon 5y ago
Competing private Ministries of Truth will be fun; once they start to disagree. Who won that election, again?
- anigbrowl 5y agoReasonable people can tolerate and sometimes quantify uncertainty. Unreasonable people tend to be very insistent. There's a case like this going on now in arizona where the vote in last November's in Maricopa is being audited at the request of the state Senate. This is a subject of some controversy; how would you approach a situation like that?
- h2odragon 5y agoI'm unreasonably insistent that free speech should not be abridged. People have a right to be wrong and a duty to decide what is right for themselves. I approach it as an amused observer; I wonder how long it's been since there was a straight election in the state of AZ.
- Spivak 5y agoI feel like the two sides of this issue talk past one another constantly with this. There’s a difference between censoring ideas you disagree with and modding purposefully malicious hate and disinformation campaigns. But whenever it comes up there’s no nuance allowed. People seem to understand market failures and the role of regulators in weeding out malicious actors like scammers, thieves, misleading advertising, market manipulation, and insider trading. But there’s no room apparently to admit that the marketplace of ideas is subject to the same forces because not everyone is coming to the marketplace in good faith. It’s easy to argue that there should be light touch regulation on such things and err on allowing speech that is “on the fence” when you’re not the one being harmed by it.
- CharlesW 5y ago> I'm unreasonably insistent that free speech should not be abridged. You seem to be equating "free speech should not be abridged" with "we shouldn't fight disinformation", which is a strangely weak and fatalistic stance.
- anigbrowl 5y agoBut nobody is talking about abridging free speech. This effort is aimed at providing supplementary context. Your 'amused observer' position sounds like trolling to be honest. You could just look at the available public data for historical elections and offer a conjecture about the baseline reliability of results. I don't see the significance of declaring yourself to be 'amused' other than pre-emptive face saving in case you say something foolish.