8 ms·
First Nokia, Now RIM: The Mighty Are Falling
- RexRollman 15y agoTo me, they are both victims of a paradigm shift. The only thing that saddens me is that their employees will pay the price for their lack of vision.
- VladRussian 15y agoas a former multi-year employee of a formerly glorious company that fell victim of its self-denial to recognize a paradigm shift i can say that employees can blame only themselves.
- aculver 15y agoYeah, I agree. The parent post makes it sound like there is some other force in a company that can be blamed other than the employees. I suppose someone might say "management", but to me it's all the same.
- RexRollman 15y agoFrom what I've seen, many companies do not listen to their employees, especially as they get larger. RIM in particular strikes me as a company where its employees have no voice.
- nkassis 15y agoI'm a little sad for RIM and would like to support a Canadian company but in the end they just aren't able to adapt. I don't think they ever will unless there is a management change. Seriously a tablet that can't receive email Nativity? That's what they were know for yet they can't use there strength right. QNX is a decent system, open it up, let others use it, in the end they won't be able to stop the tsunami of apple and android without help, other manufacturers using their QNX platform could help.
- michaelcampbell 15y agoI don't have the deisre to support a Canadian company simply because they're Canadian, but I'm with you on the rest of it. When I heard RIM bought QNX I was ready for a game changer from them, but alas... too little too late. Perhaps it never could have worked; maybe Google with buy the QNX part of RIM and do something with it with respect to Android. I'd like to see it shine someday.
- Luyt 15y agoesr also keeps a close eye on the developments in the mobile phone market. His latest blog post on this is at http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=3493 http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=3493 , a short quote: "Nokia’s strategy, insofar as it’s actually had one since the tie-up with Microsoft, has been to hang in there on volume sales of dumbphones until it could deliver world-beating WP7 handsets. The major risk here, other than the wild unlikelihood of WP7 ever becoming anything consumers actually want, was that the Chinese electronics industry would undercut them on price-performance. I predicted this would happen, it is happening, and Nokia’s disastrous July earnings call is the result."
- othermaciej 15y agoI think esr lost a lot of credibility with his claim that the iPhone was facing imminent collapse, followed by Apple's record quarter. He seems more interested in finding any evidence whatsoever for the proposition that Android will dominate the market, than in doing thoughtful analysis. The post you linked is a case in point. He's also cherry-picking his past predictions to highlight only the ones that turned out to be right.
- sedev 15y agoWhile "keeps a close eye on" is certainly an accurate description of what he does, "makes accurate and/or well-founded predictions" is not, and that's more important. Someone who wanted to be well-informed about mobile would do far better by reading Horace Dediu, for example.
- programminggeek 15y agoI don't think I've ever seen a company cut employees en masse like this truly help a company come from behind to regain their former status. It sends so many wrong messages. If those 10% of your company aren't worthwhile, why were they hired and employed in the first place? If management can afford to cut staff by 10%, the C and VP level management should be fired. Start by cutting at the top, not at the bottom. Cutting that deep means that management was fine with spending money like drunken sailors. Nothing RIM or Nokia has announced in the last few months in terms of changes has shown that they are going to do anything other than wither and die on the vine.
- dsmithn 15y agoI can't disagree with the first two paragraphs, but for the last, what about shutting down entire divisions? If a company invested in a failed product that requires a number of specialized employees, does it imply they were spending money like drunken sailors when they have to let them go?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- cpeterso 15y agoI'm reminded of Steve Job's advice to Nike: "Nike makes some of the best products in the world. Products that you lust after. But you also make a lot of crap. Just get rid of the crappy stuff and focus on the good stuff."
- izend 15y ago"I don't think I've ever seen a company cut employees en masse like this truly help a company come from behind to regain their former status." Apple?
- kenjackson 15y agohttp://articles.sfgate.com/1997-03-15/business/17744320_1_apple-s-cupertino-apple-workers-drake-beam-morin http://articles.sfgate.com/1997-03-15/business/17744320_1_ap... Apple laid off 4000 in 1997. I've heard things went pretty well afterwards.
- wmeredith 15y agoTheir problem is they make phones and no one wants phones, they want computers.
- Geee 15y agoThat was exactly Nokia's problem, they tried to cram whole computer in a phone. They even called their smartphones 'multimedia computers' and primarily targeted them for geeks. They never had a real idea why smartphones are useful. That strategy led them to huge amounts of code bloat and features without usability and made the development of updates horribly slow.
- digikata 15y agoI think that Nokia's problem was they tried to redesign their software stack 3-4 times, never waiting long enough to get a mature enough product with real feedback before ripping things up and starting again. The worst case was the latest switch to WP7, especially after looking at the first (and maybe last) Meego phone release. It's like trying to build a house, getting the framing and walls up and right after you paint it you decide to go to a completely different foundation.
- phuff 15y agoI am not fully versed in the notion of innovative disruption, but it seems pretty obvious that a Clay Christensen-esque Innovator's Dilemma disruption is what's going on here: somebody had a decent product, is first to market, but doesn't have a clear enough vision to see how to stay on top and stay innovative and gets blindsided by unexpected (read Apple + Android) competitors. I wonder how closely the non-cliff notes version of RIM's fall matches the innovator's dilemma model.
- cpeterso 15y agoI think RIM and Nokia both had "Cash Cow Disease". The Blackberry and Symbian had been successes for so long that short-term profits/losses and internal politics prevent the companies from investing in new (and seemingly "inferior") technologies that would cannabilize their own successful products. For example, Nokia had touchscreen phones that didn't sell well, so they thought the touchscreen iPhone was a "toy".
- mbesto 15y agoRIM in particular continues to have strong financial numbers. But the outlook is bad as the trends are showing decline rather than growth. The innovator's dilemma really takes a toll on company's who main source of revenue is being disrupted and at the same time have to report to shareholders.
- IsaacL 15y agoThe term is 'disruptive innovation'. It's an often misunderstood concept - the key point is that not all innovation is disruptive. The defining feature of disruptive innovations is that they are initially worse than the technology they displace, but as they are significantly cheaper they allow the tech to reach new markets. Since the iPhone was a high-end product, it can't be called disruptive.
- MikeCapone 15y ago"Since the iPhone was a high-end product, it can't be called disruptive." Do you have a suggestion of what it should be called, then? Sounds disruptive to me.
- ForrestN 15y agoI would be really interested to read an informed analysis of these two cases in the context of public company shareholder dynamics. I think it's an understated advantage of Steve Job's ultra-centrality at Apple that shareholders tend to defer to him in a way that I expect they might not with other companies (obviously this might become a disadvantage when he leaves). Has pressure from shareholders meaningfully affected the decision-making of companies like Nokia and RIM? Are short-term incentives defeating long-term incentives because of such pressure? I don't know, but I'd love to hear from someone who does.
- thematt 15y agoI'm not sure if it's related to their troubles, but their corporate structure has always seemed odd to me. Starting with the whole "co-CEO" role, which seems like an experiment that hasn't quite panned out.
- MikeCapone 15y agoTechnically, Google has almost had that for a while with Larry and Sergey, and then the Trifecta with Eric. Not quite the same, though, obviously...
- Silhouette 15y agoWasn't there an open letter from a senior staffer at RIM just a few days ago, which spelt out the problems on the ground and what needed to be done about them in brutally honest fashion, which was promptly brushed under the carpet (or not) by RIM PR? It seems like the rank and file staff at RIM get it, but the top level management don't, which is a sufficient condition to know how the story ends. Edit: Yes, here it is: http://www.bgr.com/2011/06/30/open-letter-to-blackberry-bosses-senior-rim-exec-tells-all-as-company-crumbles-around-him/ http://www.bgr.com/2011/06/30/open-letter-to-blackberry-boss...
- eric-hu 15y agoI was thinking of the same thing when I read this. To be fair, one of the letter's suggestions was that they hold people accountable for failed products. Excerpt: "Just because someone may have been a loyal RIM employee for 7 years, it doesn’t mean they are the best Manager / Director / VP for that role" ...although maybe they're doing the reverse...
- ruslan 15y agoQNX ? What for ? I think RIM should learn from Nokia's mistake and switch to Android soon as possible. This is the only way to survive for them.
- hello_moto 15y agoWow, CEO of the year for you sir. If things would be as easy as that, flip to Android and compete with the rest... to the bottom. How would you differentiate yourself vs HTC, Motorola, etc? What if the Chinese android handsets comes up with cheap mobile phones similar to BB hardware interface (the golden keyboard, you know that BB users love BB because of the keyboard). Switching to Android makes RIM an average company like everybody else.
- cfgvjkljhgfb 15y agoSo by the same logic, Porsche and Ferrari should stop making gasoline powered cars with 4wheels in a race to the bottom with kia/hyundai - and switch to 6 wheel cars powered by waterwheels?
- bergie 15y agoPorche and Ferrari cars (well, most of them, not of the racing variety) can run on the same gasoline and the same roads as the KIAs and Hyundais. This is very similar, actually, to having better hardware and nicer UX layer on top of a common platform where all devices can run the same apps.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoIt's a perfectly viable strategy. Combine your peanut butter (hardware design, workflow, bb messaging, etc) with proven chocolate (android smartphone technology) and try to make something that preserves the unique qualities your company is known for while keeping pace with the competition on other features (high quality mibile browsers, games, etc.) I know several people who still use blackberries because they are fundamentally superior for certain business needs. But that's just an extreme corner of the market, ultimately people will make due with other options that are "good enough" in order to take advantage of other benefits. As far as the lowest common denominator problem, if you think htc, samsung, and motorola are in a race to the bottom then maybe you haven't been paying attention.
- doctoboggan 15y agoNokia has been a company since 1865, so it might take more than this to stop them http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia
- bergie 15y agoAnd they've done a lot of amazing turnarounds, from paper mills to rubber boots to cables to TVs to mobile phones. But this is the first time they surrender the decision making power of the company to a third party, Microsoft. That may make adapting to changing situations harder.
- Zachhack 15y agoIn tech, there is no such thing as 'too big to fail'
- MikeCapone 15y agoWell, that's what a functioning market where there is competition does. Allow people to pick what they want, and it so happens that what people now want aren't BlackBerries. Both Apple and Google should remember that -- their positions aren't set in stone and to maintain them in the long term they need to avoid resting on their laurels.
- brudgers 15y agoWhile in the short term, Android and iOS are having an impact, RIM's longterm fate is affected by Windows Phone 7 because that is the easiest Mobile OS upon which Enterprise can standardize comfortably - iOS is just too consumer centric [e.g. three year obsolescence] and has a history of sloppy security practices [e.g. lying to Exchange], and Android is somewhat fragmented due to diversity of device capabilities and does not give a high priority to integration with the Microsoft stack. All the things RIM does well for enterprise, Windows Phone is likely to do better over the long term. And with Nokia getting set to leverage their existing reputation for quality on top of WP7, it is hard to see what RIM can bring to the table when it comes time to convince IT. [http://www.cio.com/article/501815/iPhone_3.1_Breaking_Exchange_E_Mail_for_Enterprise_iPhone_3G_Users_ http://www.cio.com/article/501815/iPhone_3.1_Breaking_Exchan...]
- wmil 15y agoTo be fair, every mobile device that Microsoft released was supposed to destroy RIM. I'm still not convinced that Microsoft can pull of a decent phone with full Exchange integration.