3 ms·
It’s a question of physics not just chemistry. Deuterium for example is similar to hydrogen chemically so while those differences are slightly toxic to us it’s
by Retric 5y ago
It’s a question of physics not just chemistry. Deuterium for example is similar to hydrogen chemically so while those differences are slightly toxic to us it’s easy to assume a planet similar to earth with an abundance of deuterium and a lack of hydrogen would evolve life forms with the opposite preferences.
Except the ratio of hydrogen to deuterium is a function of astronomy and more specifically fusion. No naturally formed planet is going to end up with that imbalance. Which means no natural deuterium based life forms. So while some alien civilization create deuterium life, it’s not going to be part of natural ecosystems.
And so it goes for most possible interesting edge cases. Dependency on rare elements like Neptunium means any competitors without that dependency have huge advantages.
- gambiting 5y agoOf course. But there are planets with abundance of silicon(including ours). There are planets with abundance of methane and even here we have lifeforms which can consume it. I'm just pointing out that as long as silicon based life is possible, then given the near infinite amount of time the universe can spend evolving such life, it will surely exist.
- Retric 5y agoSort of, it depends on how common various forms of proto life are. If their very rare and the first one to happen wins then you might expect silicon life of some form to be out there. On the other hand if proto life is extremely common then silicon proto life might always be out competed by more efficient alternatives. For example the fact Silicon dioxide is a solid where carbon dioxide is a gas is a major advantage or using carbon.
- ncmncm 5y agoThe silicides would meanwhile say that the gaseous nature of CO2 makes carbon useless as a basis for life, and even go so far as to offer a plausible reason.
- rendall 5y agoIt's an interesting point.
- Retric 5y agoSorry, no. CO2 being gaseous is a major availability and energy advantage. For example you can’t get plankton equivalents as dissolved silicon is parts per trillion at the oceans surface. Hybrids are a different story, but I doubt that’s what anyone is talking about by silicon based life forms.
- ncmncm 5y agoCO2 (or SiO2) is only one of the possible outputs, or inputs, of metabolism. Even on Earth its primacy came very, very late. You don't get to constrain alien life to your preconceptions. Even some Earth life secretes SiO2. Using carbon for some things would not invalidate its Si-basedness any more than diatoms have given up carbon-basedness. Silicon's near absence from our favored solvent, like iron's, is a product of toxic levels of biogenic atmospheric oxygen. Our early oceans were saturated with iron products, and are now starved of them. There is no reason to assume oxygen would be their favored oxidant.
- Retric 5y ago> There is no reason to assume oxygen would be their favored oxidant That goes back to astronomy no other option is going to be nearly as plentiful. > You don’t get to constrain alien life with your preconceptions. It’s not a preconception it’s the solubility of silicon and silicon compounds. Yes, CO2 and SiO2 aren’t the only option for respiration, but CO2 was and is a near endless supply of carbon and oxygen. Without that growth simply slows down dramatically. Even with a photosynthetic equivalent you simply don’t get the great oxygen event from silicon lifeforms in even 10 billion years. PS: To be clear I am not saying silicon life would be impossible just that it’s at a huge disadvantage head to head and would have a vastly slower progression to large scale multicellular life.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]