2 ms·
Gravitons are the kookiest theoretical particle I have ever heard of. I had an intuition that they were kooky and contrived when I first heard of them as a chil
by hammock 15y ago
Gravitons are the kookiest theoretical particle I have ever heard of. I had an intuition that they were kooky and contrived when I first heard of them as a child, and now that I know more about them and gravity, I have even more disbelief in them. Why people still believe in them I will never know.
Here's the latest thing I have seen, btw:
http://arxiv.org/abs/1001.0785 http://arxiv.org/abs/1001.0785
Pop science interpretation of it:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/13/science/13gravity.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/13/science/13gravity.html
- starwed 15y agoYou know what I'll never know? Why people think they know better than the scientific community after reading a few pop science articles. If you have a single issue with gravitons that can be expressed mathematically, show us.
- hammock 15y agoI didn't say I knew better than "the scientific community" (whomever they are, since there is not a huge amount of consensus around gravitons), I just said I have a lot of doubts. I could be wrong.
- neutronicus 15y agoHow are they different from photons? Or gluons? Anyways, I saw a Freeman Dyson talk once where he explained that if you were to set up a detector with the cross-sectional area of the Earth, and point it at the sun for the age of the Earth, you would be expected to detect 4(!) gravitons, due to their weak interactions with matter. He was convinced we would run into our inability to continue to test predictions long before we hammered out a decent unification theory.