3 ms·
Can we get a law that forbids (or taxes enormously) class action settlements that result in less than $10 per class member?
by colechristensen 5y ago
Can we get a law that forbids (or taxes enormously) class action settlements that result in less than $10 per class member?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Can we get a law that forbids (or taxes enormously) class action settlements that result in less than $10 per class member? Maybe we can, but that would be stupid. You are always free to opt out of a class action if you'd prefer what you think you can recover directly.
- colechristensen 5y ago>Maybe we can, but that would be stupid. What value to society do small per-user judgements bring? They tend to be a negligible percentage of revenue, involve the company denying wrongdoing, and giving an amount valuing a gumball and a mcdonalds meal to people. Really what is the point?
- d110af5ccf 5y ago> negligible percentage of revenue But what percentage of profit? And far more importantly, are they large enough to serve as a disincentive for others to do the same thing in the future? I'd suggest that the popularity of binding arbitration clauses is evidence that the fines are noticeable. (Note that I refer to class actions in general, not Zoom specifically.)
- oblio 5y ago> And far more importantly, are they large enough to serve as a disincentive for others to do the same thing in the future? Considering that 100% of the popular social networks were built on these practices, no. They risk fines of hundreds of millions, maaaaybe billions at most, and they make tens of billions.
- d110af5ccf 5y agoSure, there are exceptions. But in general it would appear that class actions are an effective deterrent to a wide variety of undesirable behavior. That they fail in a few highly visible edge cases means they are imperfect - not useless.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> What value to society do small per-user judgements bring? They impose some cost on unlawful behavior where the alternative, were they prohibited, would usually be no cost; plaintiff’s attorneys would seek more if the EV of going to trial was enough greater to compensate for the risks, so if you ban the low $/user settlements z you aren't getting bigger settlements, you are get fewer class actions filed even with meritorious claims. Class actions largely exist for diffuse harms where low per-class-member damages make it not worth individual direct action lawsuits, so banning small per-member awards is effectively eliminating recovery in most of the space class actions exist to serve, outside of suicide-bomber litigants (that is, litigants who are willing to take a negative EV to make sure that a wrongdoer pays.)