4 ms·
> A blind acquaintance of mine once lost his job because of a newly added requirement that he use an inaccessible application. I find it hard to believe this h
by sokoloff 5y ago
> A blind acquaintance of mine once lost his job because of a newly added requirement that he use an inaccessible application.
I find it hard to believe this happened as stated in the US, where any number of lawyers would be eager to take such an open-and-shut ADA violation case.
- WORMS_EAT_WORMS 5y agoNo doubt it could happen but I agree with you. This entire post is very odd and makes absolutely no sense at all.
- mwcampbell 5y agoCan you be more specific about what doesn't make sense? I'm willing to clarify anything I wrote.
- WORMS_EAT_WORMS 5y agoTo my understanding their browser isolation text just renders to canvas on their edge servers (don’t quote me on this). Does canvas provide any accessibility at all and is actually a bigger problem with the creation of that standard / element in HTML5 with text generation? It’s essentially an image block that allows text generation with almost no accessibility in mind? That’s not really Cloudflare’s fault if so. I agree accessibility needs to be of higher priority. It’s a shame it’s seems to be almost always a secondary priority to everything in tech. But this post feels like an open letter to some bigger issue when it seems like it’s a very niche and non-common security tool. I mean no disrespect in this.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mwcampbell 5y ago> To my understanding their browser isolation text just renders to canvas on their edge servers (don’t quote me on this). Does canvas provide any accessibility at all and is actually a bigger problem with the creation of that standard / element in HTML5 with text generation? It’s an image block that allows text generation with almost no accessibility in mind? That’s not really Cloudflare’s fault to be honest. The standard workaround is to create a parallel DOM that's invisible, e.g. covered up by the canvas. To be clear, this parallel DOM should be based on the accessibility tree of the remote browser, not based on the original DOM, as that would undermine the whole point of the exercise. This work-around may not be perfect, but Cloudflare hasn't implemented even this. > But this post feels like an open letter to some bigger issue when it seems like it’s a very niche and non-common security tool. It seems to me, from Cloudflare's original pre-announcement of this technology [1], that they intend for it to be widely adopted. Here's the money quote: > Operating costs translate directly to customer costs. The S2 system was designed to make deployment to an entire enterprise and not just targeted users (aka: vaccinating half the class) both feasible and attractive for customers. [1]: https://blog.cloudflare.com/cloudflare-and-remote-browser-isolation/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/cloudflare-and-remote-browser-is...
- x0x0 5y agoHow does building a parallel dom help, given the point of this is to not execute code on the endpoint? nm, see (your answer) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28028892 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28028892
- WORMS_EAT_WORMS 5y ago> This work-around may not be perfect, but Cloudflare hasn't implemented even this. What would be perfect then?
- mwcampbell 5y agoIMO, the best possible solution right now would be a native desktop client for their remote browser, as opposed to a browser-based client. But it would probably be better in the long term to fill in the appropriate gaps in web standards so the browser-based client can be fully usable with a screen reader.
- wffurr 5y agoIt’s absolutely Cloudflare’s fault to build their cloud-based browser on inaccessible tech. There are alternatives.
- mwcampbell 5y agoThe pre-announcement [1] lays out at least some of those alternatives. I understand why they chose the approach they did, but they needed to do the work to make it accessible, as I advised them when that post came out. [1]; https://blog.cloudflare.com/cloudflare-and-remote-browser-isolation/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/cloudflare-and-remote-browser-is...
- true_religion 5y agoAre screen readers capable of reading interfaces generated with QT or other desktop UI toolkits? A cursory look at QT's documentation seems to indicate that they are aware of screen readers, but I didn't dig deeply enough to find out if they were compatible by default. I know VoiceOver on OSX can at least read out the interfaces on the included apps, but I also don't know if that's true for every app---or if it actually extends to the browser and canvas/plugin rendered (flash, java, etc.) interfaces. As an addendum, I'm pretty hopeful that in this decade we'll get AI vision enabled screen readers so anything that's displayable to a sighted person can also be immediately used with some caveats by someone reliant on screen reader.
- mwcampbell 5y ago> Are screen readers capable of reading interfaces generated with QT or other desktop UI toolkits? Qt is one of the very few UI toolkits that is more or less accessible. And even Qt's accessibility implementation isn't great. My advice for someone implementing a cross-platform desktop app would be to go with something based on the web platform. That doesn't have to be Electron; Tauri [1] looks promising, though I haven't tested it lately. > As an addendum, I'm pretty hopeful that in this decade we'll get AI vision enabled screen readers so anything that's displayable to a sighted person can also be immediately used with some caveats by someone reliant on screen reader. Sadly, that might be what it takes to get access to applications using the long tail of UI toolkits. [1]: https://tauri.studio/en/ https://tauri.studio/en/
- arp242 5y ago> Does canvas provide any accessibility at all and is actually a bigger problem with the creation of that standard / element in HTML5 with text generation? It’s essentially an image block that allows text generation with almost no accessibility in mind? That’s not really Cloudflare’s fault if so. Not everything needs to be accessible; there are plenty of non-accessible reasonable use cases for canvas. For example, I made a small game with canvas some years ago. This isn't accessible for blind users, and that's okay. There is no real way to make this accessible as it's fundamentally a graphical game. It's called a disability for a reason: there are some things you just won't be able to do. The problem isn't with the non-accessible technologies, but when people use this in ways that make every-day stuff required for basic participation inaccessible. That's basically the issue with Cloudflare's product.
- junon 5y agoYes, canvas is able to be made accessible.
- mwcampbell 5y agoHere are the two (edit: three) public blog posts I could find from this guy. I'll let you decide whether I misrepresented what happened. https://blindaccessjournal.com/2006/02/the-cold-equations/ https://blindaccessjournal.com/2006/02/the-cold-equations/ https://blindaccessjournal.com/2006/02/torn-from-the-collective/ https://blindaccessjournal.com/2006/02/torn-from-the-collect... Edit: Found the original announcement: https://blindaccessjournal.com/2006/02/my-job-lost-due-to-inaccessible-technology-live-at-11/ https://blindaccessjournal.com/2006/02/my-job-lost-due-to-in... And yes, it was in 2006. And as it happens, his employer rehired him shortly after, but only because they found something else for him to do. I believe my point still stands; for a short time, he lost his job, without knowing what happened next, and he went through the emotions associated with that.
- brudgers 5y agoADA is Federal Law. It provides no damages. No attorney fees. The USDOJ is the plaintiff. Fines are imposed. California Law is different in that it is like other civil laws with damages and attorney fees. Consequently, cases from California make attention commanding headlines. Elsewhere in the US, citizens must beseech the USDOJ to act on their behalf…it usually doesn’t.
- vmception 5y agoMan, California sounds so great until you get here.
- bladegash 5y agoThat is not entirely accurate. While ADA is federal law and awards no damages, situations like what was described would be more appropriate as an EEOC matter. An award of damages is a potential remedy when discrimination (e.g., not providing a reasonable accommodation) is found to have taken place. It is also a perfectly acceptable offering during alternative dispute resolution or as a settlement. Lastly, civil litigation involving the ADA does not require support from the DoJ. The DoJ, as with other matters brought before courts on behalf of the government, CAN bring about suit and are generally responsible for enforcement. People with disabilities sue private companies all the time for alleged/actual discrimination without the DoJ.
- kolanos 5y agoAny U.S. resident can file an ADA complaint with the DOJ. You don't need to be disabled, you just need to be aware of an ADA violation. You can also file on someone else's behalf. [0] [0]: https://www.ada.gov/filing_complaint.htm https://www.ada.gov/filing_complaint.htm
- brudgers 5y agoYou file a complaint with the DOJ. The DOJ is part of the Executive Branch. It is not part of the Federal Courts.
- hobs 5y agoThere are constant and flagrant ADA violations - while the lobbying group is not weak the war of attrition is definitely with the employers not the ADA; I have seen so many violations it makes my head spin.
- jnovek 5y agoI have been fired because an employer was unwilling to negotiate reasonable accommodation per the ADA. Tech is insular. I chose to make zero noise for the sake of the future of my career and I wouldn't be surprised if most do the same.
- exikyut 5y agoJust from the perspective of shedding light on where the brokenness was/is distributed, was this specifically about vision-related accommodation, or something else? Just idly curious.
- kwdc 5y agoPeople leave jobs for all kinds of abuse and never take legal action. Other people create legal but unethical workplaces. Still others create just plain nasty work environments. The legal system isn’t that great for sorting these messes out and plenty of poeple know it.