4 ms·
I'd happily go back to working in the office. If I had an actual office, not a 4-foot wide folding table that's part of a line of eight of them in 12 rows in a
by cratermoon 5y ago
I'd happily go back to working in the office. If I had an actual office, not a 4-foot wide folding table that's part of a line of eight of them in 12 rows in a room the size of a basketball court.
I haven't had an "office" to go to work in since 2000. I've shared spaces with anywhere from three to all of my co-workers. "Recent research shows that such offices result in 73 per cent less face-to-face interaction, and a 67 per cent increase in email interaction" https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/325959 https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/325959
- trunnell 5y ago"Private offices with doors that close" - that's the standard at Fog Creek Software, the company behind Stack Overflow, Trello, and other great products. Microsoft also provides offices (or at least used to). These companies might be on to something. https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2008/12/29/the-new-fog-creek-office/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2008/12/29/the-new-fog-creek-... An opposing perspective: note that the cost for private offices is very high vs. cubes. Assuming Class A space in a premium location is around $85/sq.ft. per month [1]: 6' x 6' cube: 36 sq.ft. * $85 = $3,060/mo 8' x 10' office: 80 sq.ft. * $85 = $6,800/mo 10' x 12' office: 120 sq.ft. * $85 = $10,200/mo What would most people choose: upgrade from cube to desk, or add $3,500/mo to their paycheck? [1]: rental rate chart at https://www.squarefoot.com/office-space/ca/san-francisco https://www.squarefoot.com/office-space/ca/san-francisco
- mattkrause 5y agoYour employer might get some, all, or even more than the $3,500 differential back through increased productivity, less churn, etc.
- triceratops 5y agoWhy are you assuming employees are currently getting the cost savings from cubicles?
- 3gg 5y agoThanks for the link, but I'm not sure about the conclusion. Why do you think the company would reimburse you for $3500/mo for freeing up office space or using less of it? A company basically pays you for your cost of living. That's why pay is high in the Bay Area or NY, and why you take a massive pay cut when you move out. If you choose to work remotely or sign up for shitty work conditions, they are not going to reimburse any of the costs you just saved them.
- trunnell 5y agoIt's just a thought experiment. It's one thing to say offices are good. It's another to say their benefit outweighs the cost. I think the added cost may be worth it, but I'd be surprised to find majority agreement. > A company basically pays you for your cost of living I'd argue that companies generally pay market rates for employees, which in a well-functioning market will be well above the cost of living.
- 3gg 5y agoFor what it's worth, I had the luck of working in an actual office, with walls and doors that close (it honestly sounds quite absurd to describe it this way; how low have we sunk?) and I prefer it very much that way for the same reasons described in your link. And agree on the last statement, I had over-simplified that, though I did add the word "basically".
- cratermoon 5y ago> A company basically pays you for your cost of living. That's why pay is high in the Bay Area or NY, and why you take a massive pay cut when you move out. That's the essence of another issue companies are forcing with remote work. It puts the lie to any claim that compensation is based on business value. Do I not provide the same value to the business if I live in Omaha, Nebraska rather than San Jose, California? But, the company has offices in Menlo Park, you're more valuable because you're closer to them, you say? But the company also has offices in Omaha, and a dozens other places around the world. This isn't theoretical: companies have already said that pay scales for remote work will be tied to location, regardless of the contribution a person makes to the company. Employers are going to have to reckon with the fact that if I can chose to live more comfortably, I can also choose to expect to compensated for my contributions rather than my postal code. Am I worth a six-figure salary or not?
- cratermoon 5y agoI fondly remember days in my last office. It was ground-level in a small building, with a window that faced a small tree-lined space behind the building. I could sit at my desk and think while watching the birds and squirrels, and on a wintry day the snow would hang on the leaves.
- bradlys 5y agoI think those are rates per year - not per month. So maybe make that contribution to your paycheck per year - not per month. (Kinda surprised no one here knows that and hasn’t mentioned it yet) Source in case you don’t believe me: https://www.squarefoot.com/leasopedia/dollars-cents-much-cost-rent-office-space/ https://www.squarefoot.com/leasopedia/dollars-cents-much-cos...
- trunnell 5y agoYou're right! My bad.
- bradlys 5y agoKinda changes your whole point. $10k/yr for a $400k/yr engineer is really not much at all. $10k/month is but $10k/yr is definitely not. Rounding error, basically. And - personally - I might even take the $10k/yr pre-tax deduction for a nice private office. Certainly much cheaper than trying to do it at my own place.
- cratermoon 5y ago> upgrade from cube to desk Wait, you get cubes? That would be an upgrade compared to the open offices I am talking about. I mean open-plan offices, where each worker gets a flat surface, a rolling filing cabinet, and a power outlet. I'd almost go back to one job where I had a cube, because the cubes there were maybe 8' (2-1/2m) square, high-walled, enough desk space to spread out, and even a personal coat closet/locker with a door. Make it another foot or two high, put on a cover and a door that closes and I wouldn't care that it was made out of cheap fiberboard covered in ugly carpet.
- dilyevsky 5y agoThese are annual prices. Before covid you could get a private office in sfba for ~$10-12k/y in a coworking space. Cheaper if you get 2-3 person spaces
- sokoloff 5y agoCommercial property when quoted as “$X/sq ft” means an annual rental charge, not monthly.
- trunnell 5y agoOops, those costs should be per month, not per year... but now I can't edit the post.
- thefunnyman 5y agoMicrosoft used to provide offices but has been slowly doing away with them in favor of open office spaces. From what I understand, any new buildings they construct are designed around open offices.
- geodel 5y agoWhile I totally agree with what you just said. "Recent research" part is dangerous and somehow works in favor employers overall. It is for very simple reason that employers can sponsor vastly more research that can save business a penny while making employees' life miserable along the way.
- cratermoon 5y ago> works in favor employers overall Knowledge is power. Research has certainly been turned to socially questionable ends. See, for example, the iffy research churned out by the tobacco companies to counter the overwhelming evidence that smoking causes cancer, heart disease, and a host of other issues.