4 ms·
What is with Australia and it’s authoritarian bend? First soldiers are enforcing their covid curfew and now this? And nothing but support. Seems like some of
by refurb 5y ago
What is with Australia and it’s authoritarian bend? First soldiers are enforcing their covid curfew and now this?
And nothing but support. Seems like some of the authoritarian culture of SE Asia (Singapore, Indonesia, etc) has rubbed off on them? The UK is far more anti-authoritarian.
No doubt any video about a lab source of Covid would have been banned too.
- iratic0 5y agoLying to the public to maintain power, keeps their hands on the government purse. Loss of trust in institutions. Loss of sense of prestige in the traditional tracks, they make up for it by becoming authoritarian to maintain sense of utility.
- refurb 5y agoThis has been apparent in the US. Our govt tells us small lies for the greater good - early in the pandemic masks weren’t needed - better to tell them they didn’t work so there were enough for healthcare workers. Works great until the situation changes and you need people to wear masks. Not only do people question why things have changed, they start to ask what else you’re lying about for “the greater good”.
- tvphan 5y agoYouTube is an American company.
- refurb 5y agoYou don’t think they had any discussion with the AUS govt
- nineteen999 5y agoThe current Australian Federal Government is a right wing conservative coalition, and the Murdoch media has traditionally been their mouthpiece here.
- refurb 5y agoBut current federal govt supports the lockdowns right?
- nineteen999 5y agoSort of - in this case they have no choice. They previously held up New South Wales as the "gold standard" in contract tracing and halting the spread of the virus; so if the NSW Government says they have to lock down, the Federal Government pretty much has to go along with it. But you can be sure that as soon as NSW's case numbers come down enough, the Federal Government will pressure them to start lifting restrictions, as they did towards the end of Victoria's 4 month lockdown last year.
- tomhoward 5y agoThe federal government is very reluctantly accepting of these lockdowns, having been strongly opposed to lockdowns previously in states governed by the opposing party. They are not so supportive that they would conspire with YouTube to censor Sky News, which is their most friendly media outlet in the country.
- thinkingemote 5y agoI'm not sure. I'm not sure it is authoritarian, but there is support for this action. It might be something to do with its general classless style of politics or it could be due to a very recent coronavirus scare in the major city after months of peace. I also suspect that culturally users there don't have the same history of freedom of expression as other places. I'm guessing but it's interesting. I hope a disinterested and calm australian user can see through what's going on and educate the rest of us.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoAustralians, for whatever reason, don't have the same concern for civil liberties that Americans have. I can't explain why, but as a citizen it's a little troubling.
- scottmcdot 5y agoCould be because our (the Australian) government looks after us a bit better than the American government looks after their people? I mean a good, free healthcare system, university fees aren't through the roof, reasonable minimum wages, comfortable standard of living.
- refurb 5y agoYeah, but seems Europe gets that without the loss of liberty?
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoThat might be right, but do they need to be mutually exclusive? The policy on healthcare, education and minimum wages could be made while maintaining strong civil liberties (I think?). An interesting difference to highlight - the statement "government looks after us" is something many folks in the US would find strange. The US views government more "of the people, by the people, for the people" - ie the government is us governing ourselves.
- shephardjhon 5y agoDoes your "civil liberties" concerns include far left or even Islamist content? No? And before you downvote "I'm just asking questions" as probably your favourite broadcaster says.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoYes, it does. I'm not sure who my favorite broadcaster is supposed to be, I don't live in Australia. Maybe Alan Jones? He seems controversial but I've never listened to him.
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoThere are no soldiers nor even police enforcing my COVID curfew. And YouTube hasn't blocked me access to videos theorising about the lab source.
- TMWNN 5y agoThat's the case now. There was a block for a full year.
- aryonoco 5y agoIf being authoritarian means being horrified at US school shootings and making sure we have sane gun laws so that doesn't happen here, or being horrified at the costs of the US health care system so making sure we have an effective insurance system that covers everyone for free, then yes, as an Australian, I'm quite proud of being authoritarian.
- refurb 5y agoI think you replied to the wrong thread?
- tomhoward 5y agoThis long Twitter thread from yesterday by Gray Connolly (who is quite libertarian/conservative himself) addresses this question directly: https://twitter.com/GrayConnolly/status/1421461574389145600 https://twitter.com/GrayConnolly/status/1421461574389145600
- tomhoward 5y agoAlso, "soldiers are enforcing their covid curfew" is not an accurate characterisation of what's going on here. (I'm not in Sydney where the major outbreaks/restrictions are happening now but I'm in Melbourne where they were last year, and the military involvement then was the same). For a start, there's no "curfew". There is a stay-at-home order, but people are still allowed go out where necessary for shopping, exercise, education and work. The main restriction is on visiting other people's homes. Military personnel have been deployed to provide logistical support and additional bodies to help police, medical and welfare services. They're helping set up and staff covid testing facilities, and doing checks on infected people quarantining, both for compliance and welfare. And yep there's also some walking around the streets with police, but there's basically no hostile engagement with citizens or anything remotely like martial law. Mostly it's polite reminders to people of what they need to do - i.e., just wear masks and avoid gathering in big groups. Most people are accepting of it as Australians are not accustomed to or comfortable with a serious disease just tearing through the community causing significant numbers of deaths, so they're accepting of measures to prevent that from happening. > No doubt any video about a lab source of Covid would have been banned too. Nothing remotely like this has happened. I've watched plenty of videos about this, as well as many about vaccine concerns, ivermectin, etc. Australia isn't restricting any content like this at all. The only blocking of content is being done by YouTube in the USA.
- rstuart4133 5y agoI'm Australian, and one thing I've noticed is when people from other countries describe working with us, they say we are some of the loudest biggest wingers on the planet. Perhaps that gets the nuance slightly wrong, but the general complaint is if an Australian thinks something is wrong, he will tell you long and loudly, and most importantly he will do so regardless of his relative rank to you. I gather other cultures are taken by surprise when a Australian worker tells his boss to his face exactly what he is doing wrong. I suspect he fundamental difference between US citizens is while both cultures aren't authoritarian, unlike the USA Australian's don't hold authority in disdain either. They aren't scared it - they are happy to delegate responsibility and decisions to a central authority where that makes sense. I suspect that is precisely because they are confident in questioning it, and confident they can overturn it if it isn't working out. The lock down's were far more controversial at the start, when nobody had an idea what the cost of them where compared to the alternative. There were vigorous discussions in the media and elsewhere about the right approach, to the extent that different states took very different approaches, one literally shutting it's borders to all other states. A lot of water has passed under the bridge since then. It is now clear what the right approach both economically and health wise - and that is to stop the disease dead in it's tracks so you can re-open the economy a soon as possible. That's obviously is the best approach health wise, and it turns out it's also the best approach economically. We know that because the state that locked down hardest and returned to growth before everyone else, and Australia is now growing economically faster than it has in years, and this happened before just about every other country on the planet. Lock down's are highly intrusive on personal liberties of course. You have to stay at home unless you have a reason, you have to wear masks, you have to "check in" at every shop you visit by scanning a bar code. The rules are policed. It is with a light touch you will get several warnings and you will be given a mask if you don't have one, but if you continue refuse to comply the law you will be prosecuted. Still, it's acknowledged by everyone except nutters it works exceptionally well (and in fact it appears to be the only thing that does work short of full vaccination), and the governments are very careful to lift the restrictions as soon as the threat passes. And as I said, Australian's aren't afraid of authority. It's just a tool - you deploy it when it works.