7 ms·
I'm always amazed that these kind of devices don't just make the crack in the cliff wider and fail... A climber falling, even on an elasticated rope, might bri
by londons_explore 5y ago
I'm always amazed that these kind of devices don't just make the crack in the cliff wider and fail...
A climber falling, even on an elasticated rope, might briefly put 800kg into the cam. The cam itself is effectively a 10:1 lever, so exerts 8000kg in each direction on the rock.
I'm just surprised that something that is already a crack (ie. Has already moved in the past) doesn't sometimes move when 8000kg is applied to it... And if it moves, the climber likely dies.
- morsch 5y agoIsn't it common to use multiple anchors? Kind of happens automatically in the process of climbing in a team of two. That's not to say that an anchor failing is a pleasant experience...
- amitport 5y agoThe anchors are often far apart, especially in trad climbing. If the first one failed the next one will have to absorb a bigger hit... so, it can be more than unpleasant... The common advice when you don't trust your anchor is don't fall ;)
- pcthrowaway 5y agoI think 800KG is exceedingly rare, and also the upper limit of what a climber can tolerate even if their protection (the camming device) holds. It does happen with massive lead falls, especially when not much rope has been paid out. 1000 KG is likely to cause injury. And of course, the cams are typically rated from 600KG to 1600KG of force, depending on manufacturer, size, and material. But it's rare for them to experience these loads. Even with smaller falls though, say 200-300 KG of force, they do occasionally break the rock they're set in, or cause the rock to 'flex', causing it to come out (this is more common with a type of feature called a 'flake', which is a semi-detached piece of rock, rather than a typical crack which is unlikely to move). Ideally, you have more protection beneath the one you placed. Then if one piece blows, you'll fall a little bit further to the next one, which is hopefully placed in better rock.
- japhyr 5y agoThat is an important thing to keep in mind, but keep in mind that many of these climbs follow cracks in the middle of large cliffs. I can't imagine the force it would take to move a cliff like the own shown in the link below. As others have said, you do need to assess how solid a feature like a flake is. I live in a part of southeast Alaska that has almost no rock climbing because most of our mountains are uplifted accretion formations, so a fall on a cam likely would move the pieces of the mountain and lead to a nasty fall, with pieces of the mountain falling on you as well. https://www.reddit.com/r/climbing/comments/9d995a/not_a_send_of_dreamcatcher_but_still_a_squamish/ https://www.reddit.com/r/climbing/comments/9d995a/not_a_send...