3 ms·
Graveyard of Empires: Why Afghanistan Is Impossible to Conquer
- phendrenad2 5y agoIt's easy if you question all of the presuppositions in that question. Did anyone really try to conquer Afghanistan? What does it even mean to "conquer" the frontier? Do we consider the Australian outback the "graveyard of empires" too?
- nabla9 5y agoInstead of commenting the generic title (inaccurate, Mongols did it. Hazras are genetic descendant of Mongols) lets comment the content. It's good analysis. Afghanistan is unnatural country. Just like in Africa, arbitrary colonial borders create perceptual conflict. No Afghan government nor Pashtuns have recognized the border between Pakistan and Afghanistan. It's dividing the largest ethnic group in Afghanistan roughly at the middle. Explains also why "Afghan government" cant defend itself. Nobody in Afghan government thinks in the terms of Afghanistan. They belong Pashto tribe, Hazra, Tajik, .... And of course. Afghanistan is not worth to conquer if there is even little resistance. Any great river delta with significant population like in Pakistan or India was conquered by Brits because it had agricultural resources.