6 ms·
The state of New South Wales, Australia, has an independent "Law Enforcement Conduct Commission" whose explicit job is to investigate law enforcement misconduct
by skissane 5y ago
The state of New South Wales, Australia, has an independent "Law Enforcement Conduct Commission" whose explicit job is to investigate law enforcement misconduct (across all major state law enforcement agencies), and to refer cases to prosecutors. Some other Australian states have similar agencies. There is also a federal equivalent, the "Australian Commission for Law Enforcement Integrity", although it does not appear to have been as effective as its state-based equivalents in uncovering law enforcement misconduct.
Maybe the US could copy the idea?
- flatline-84 5y agoNSW also employed the Fixated Persons Unit (a terrorist task force) to arrest a journalist who was critical of John "Pork" Barilaro. So far, there's been no word from the "Law Enforcement Conduct Commission" on whether the arrest was lawful (hint: it wasn't) and nobody has been punished for it (yet - there is the defamation case on-going but the terrorist task force isn't involved in it)
- RileyJames 5y agoFor those interested, they captured footage of the arrest itself. This is obviously only one side, but here it is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXtq4a8829g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXtq4a8829g
- skissane 5y ago> NSW also employed the Fixated Persons Unit (a terrorist task force) to arrest a journalist who was critical of John "Pork" Barilaro A guy who worked for a YouTube comedian as a producer, and who allegedly was following a politician to public events and harassing him there, was arrested and charged with stalking. The "Fixated Persons Unit" has a broader mandate than purely terrorism offences, its mandate also extends to stalking and harassment of a "public office holder or internationally protected person, or other person/s nominated by the commissioner of police" > So far, there's been no word from the "Law Enforcement Conduct Commission" on whether the arrest was lawful (hint: it wasn't) LECC is unlikely to investigate an arrest while there is a pending criminal prosecution. For them to do so might be seen as interfering with the Court process. I don't know if the arrest was legal or not. But the police unit which carried out the arrest is irrelevant to the question of its legality.
- throwawayboise 5y agoBut whose job is it to investigate misconduct by these Comissions?
- skissane 5y agoIn the case of the NSW Law Enforcement Conduct Commission (LECC), its conduct is inspected by a separate agency known as the Office of the Inspector of the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission (OILECC). And OILECC's conduct, in turn, is reviewable by the NSW Ombudsman. And all three (LECC, OILECC and the Ombudsman) are overseen by a parliamentary committee.
- SOMA_BOFH 5y agoand how's that working out for these unfortunate folks?
- skissane 5y agoWho are "these unfortunate folks"? Kristo Langker? As I said above, LECC isn't going to investigate the arrest of Langker while Langker's criminal prosecution is pending. In the event that Langker is acquitted or the prosecution otherwise discontinued, it is possible then that LECC will investigate. We can't judge LECC based on this episode because legally it is too early for it to be involved.
- SOMA_BOFH 5y agono, you said it was "unlikely" all this aside, how about some sympathy for innocents caught up in this unconstitutional dragnet? does the 4th amendment even exist anymore once the feds get involved?
- skissane 5y agoWhat are we talking about here? The article about the FBI seizing $900K from a safe deposit box? Or Australian police arresting the producer of a YouTube comedian? I said, with respect to the second, that LECC was unlikely to investigate while the criminal case was still pending. That has absolutely nothing to do with "the 4th amendment" – the US constitution does not apply in Australia.
- justinclift 5y agoHeh. Victoria has the IBAC: https://www.ibac.vic.gov.au https://www.ibac.vic.gov.au They don't allow anonymous whistleblowing though, and all Tor traffic is blocked too. It's all pretty much in line with "We say we're fighting corruption, but in reality Hell No... we have things in place to ensure it can't be stopped".
- skissane 5y ago> They don't allow anonymous whistleblowing though Their website [0] says: "Complaints can be anonymous", "You can provide information anonymously" > and all Tor traffic is blocked too They also accept complaints by email, snail mail, and fax. One could use an anonymous emailer to contact them (Mixmaster, Mixminion, etc) over email. > It's all pretty much in line with "We say we're fighting corruption, but in reality Hell No... we have things in place to ensure it can't be stopped". I think it is more likely that the blocking Tor is most likely caused by the thoughtless cookie-cutter implementation of government cybersecurity "best practices", combined with a generous helping of technological cluelessness, as opposed to any nefarious motive. Hanlon's razor is apposite. [0] https://www.ibac.vic.gov.au/reporting-corruption/report https://www.ibac.vic.gov.au/reporting-corruption/report
- justinclift 5y ago> Their website [0] says: "Complaints can be anonymous", "You can provide information anonymously" They say this, but the actual anonymity is based on them actually knowing who you are (after some back and forth)... then not disclosing it. That's not really being anonymous, just a make believe fantasy version. Good luck with that!
- skissane 5y agoLook at their PDF complaint form [0] – saying who you are is optional. First question is whether you want to be anonymous, and if you answer "Yes", it tells you to skip all the questions about who you are. Their complaint form doesn't support your claims about them. [0] https://www.ibac.vic.gov.au/docs/default-source/complaint-forms/ibac-complaint-form.pdf https://www.ibac.vic.gov.au/docs/default-source/complaint-fo...