4 ms·

I know this is completely random, but I just love how HN posters rarely communicate with each other past one or two comments.

mfgs 5y ago
It probably has something to do with not getting notified when someone replies to your post.
- mastrsushi 5y ago
  I think it's more to do with lack of social engagement. It's not difficult to figure out how to refresh your accounts comment page.
  - dillondoyle 5y ago
    Maybe selfishly some clout at play too? I don't think sub comments add to profile upvote scores.
    - zamadatix 5y ago
      I think they count, never really checked specifically though and the karma system isn't exactly spelled out in detail anywhere. I'm pretty sure your downvotes to the parent and children of a comment you make don't count though - or at least I read that a few times while looking into the site initially. I bumped your comment up, if you want to find out I should be able to un-up it once you check your current number... if I remember to refresh my comment history ;).
      - dillondoyle 5y ago
        It's probably a good thing points aren't the main thing. HA that's exactly the main reason I keep an eye on it up top to know if I should check my comments to respond to someone. I'm at 1631 right now but also a couple other recent comments in the mix. Though also with that lately I've noticed more random downvotes for what I don't see any reason for.
sbuttgereit 5y ago
I can only speak for myself, but typically I'll make a single post and very rarely maybe a single followup to a later commenter. If there is an "on topic" discussion, the back-and-forth can actually be very engaging and worthwhile. Some of these exchanges are really golden and is why I keep coming back to HN. However, these high value interactions tend to be rare. Unfortunately, many discussions here tend to be fairly low value. Especially those topics that are prone to draw emotional responses from people that are arguably no more qualified to comment other than they feel strongly about the topic (and, yes, guilty as charged). In these cases, back and forth between the already committed serves little purpose and just adds stress to life. I think by simply stating your position and maybe why you think it, anyone really interested will know by that single expression that 1) there are contrary points of view, and 2) it might inspire the undecided to look into matters and draw their own conclusions... and do so with better information than is available from comments here.

mfgs 5y ago

It probably has something to do with not getting notified when someone replies to your post.

mastrsushi 5y ago
I think it's more to do with lack of social engagement. It's not difficult to figure out how to refresh your accounts comment page.
- dillondoyle 5y ago
  Maybe selfishly some clout at play too? I don't think sub comments add to profile upvote scores.
  - zamadatix 5y ago
    I think they count, never really checked specifically though and the karma system isn't exactly spelled out in detail anywhere. I'm pretty sure your downvotes to the parent and children of a comment you make don't count though - or at least I read that a few times while looking into the site initially. I bumped your comment up, if you want to find out I should be able to un-up it once you check your current number... if I remember to refresh my comment history ;).
    - dillondoyle 5y ago
      It's probably a good thing points aren't the main thing. HA that's exactly the main reason I keep an eye on it up top to know if I should check my comments to respond to someone. I'm at 1631 right now but also a couple other recent comments in the mix. Though also with that lately I've noticed more random downvotes for what I don't see any reason for.

sbuttgereit 5y ago

I can only speak for myself, but typically I'll make a single post and very rarely maybe a single followup to a later commenter. If there is an "on topic" discussion, the back-and-forth can actually be very engaging and worthwhile. Some of these exchanges are really golden and is why I keep coming back to HN. However, these high value interactions tend to be rare. Unfortunately, many discussions here tend to be fairly low value. Especially those topics that are prone to draw emotional responses from people that are arguably no more qualified to comment other than they feel strongly about the topic (and, yes, guilty as charged). In these cases, back and forth between the already committed serves little purpose and just adds stress to life. I think by simply stating your position and maybe why you think it, anyone really interested will know by that single expression that 1) there are contrary points of view, and 2) it might inspire the undecided to look into matters and draw their own conclusions... and do so with better information than is available from comments here.