9 ms·
Who's your SSH buddy?
- rb2k_ 15y ago> someone I could call and give credentials to so they could log in and shutdown the machine. I'm not going to be able to read out my private key over the phone. I guess this is only for password based authentication.
- JoachimSchipper 15y agoAn alternative: give out a public key, but restrict it to run e.g. reboot only. Put something like the following in your ~/.ssh/authorized_keys: command="/sbin/reboot",no-agent-forwarding,no-port-forwarding,no-pty,no-user-rc,no-X11-forwarding ssh-rsa AAAAB3Nza...LiPk== user@example.net See sshd(8) "AUTHORIZED_KEYS FILE FORMAT" for details.
- bostonvaulter2 15y agoI think you mean give out a private key.
- ars 15y agoNo, he actually means get a public key. You should never be giving out private keys, people need to generate those themself!
- buro9 15y agoWhy not just pastebin your private key, shortURL it and when the time comes you only have to give the shortURL. A key alone, with no idea what it will unlock, is going to be a useless thing for anyone else. Obviously I'm aware how crazy a public store of private keys sounds, but keys are really only useful if you know what lock they fit.
- Auguste 15y agoJust for the record, Pastebin is not completely secure. Even private pastes can still be accessed if you know the URL - they aren't password protected like your account may be. But like you said, if you posted the key alone anonymously, it will be hard to guess what lock it fits.
- vog 15y ago> Just for the record, Pastebin is not completely secure. Note that it already happens that people put their private keys into pastebin, by accident or probably by sheer incompetence. > if you posted the key alone anonymously, it will be hard to guess what lock it fits. As an attacker, I would simply collect as many of those "published" private keys as I can get. Then, when attacking a bunch of systems, I'd simply try one key after another on each system. The important difference to the "real world" is that an attacker can try lots of "locks" at once (i.e. can connect to multiple target systems at once).
- jrockway 15y agoWhen attacking a bunch of systems, I'd simply try one key after another on each system. This was a good idea in 1990. But now you get IP-banned after three bad login attempts, so you have to be smarter.
- vog 15y agoGood point. However, that's what botnets are for. Why "wasting" those for distributed denial of service if you could break in instead?
- emilsedgh 15y agoSharing your private key for 'more security'? I will never share my private key with anything or anyone (pastebin or my ssh buddy).
- bhousel 15y agoWell, ideally you'd work all this out with your friend before the emergency...
- omh 15y agoAnd this means you can add their public key as well, meaning you can control (i.e. revoke) their access easily and don't have to give them any root passwords.
- markbao 15y agoMaybe a play off of In case of emergency, break glass with hammer and copy private key: a one-time-only retrieval of a private key at some URL, so when your buddy retrieves it, it triggers an email that goes out to you.
- joelhaasnoot 15y agoI think I need that for myself: still scared I'll forget a password or passkey somewhere, or forget what that one really long password is for.
- darklajid 15y agoI recently began trusting KeyPass with my credentials. It uses two mechanisms to protect my details: - a secret key file (backed up on an usb stick and on dropbox). If you steal my keypass db you need this file as well - a ridiculously long sentence that I can never forget for various reasons as a passphrase. It's plain text, so probably everything in there is in a dictionary, but - good luck trying to figure this out. With this set up I'm relaxing now. I know that I ~cannot~ lose access or forget my passwords :)
- markbao 15y agoMe too. But if it has a password on it, you'll be protecting your password with another password. If it's just an obfuscated, unprotected URL, then you're going to have to store the obfuscated URL somewhere safe. I think this only works if you want to give credentials once to someone while still knowing when those credentials are being given, unfortunately :(
- LeafStorm 15y agoPrivnote (https://privnote.com/ https://privnote.com/) can do exactly that. For added bonus, the message is stored encrypted on their servers and decrypted with a key in the URL's fragment.
- mtogo 15y ago"We store the notes encrypted in a way that only the sender and receiver know how to decrypt, which means we cannot read the notes sent through Privnote." Sigh.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- koushikn 15y agoNo ssh client still on iphones?
- jgrahamc 15y agoI should have had one installed. Now I do. But I still need an SSH buddy because I might not have data access (for example, if I am abroad).
- corin_ 15y agoHook it up so that a few preset operations can be called via SMS, e.g. shutting down the server?
- kondro 15y agoYou know that SMSes are pretty insecure right?
- corin_ 15y agoI don't think it really needs to be secure for this purpose. It's easy enough to fake the number you're sending from, and probably (I've no idea) easier enough to listen in on SMS messages sent (assuming it is for the sake of worst-case). Have the server set up to require a.) sent from correct number and b.) correct password following the "shutdown" command. This isn't a system set up to be regularly used, it's about killing the server until you can get to a computer, when you're under attack. So have the server only accept the password once then disable the system - once he's back and made sure the server is fine, that code can be changed, so it doesn't matter who was listening in on the original message, after it was sent that code stops being useful.
- kondro 15y agoIt's also easy enough to have access to secure Internet to pretty much everywhere in the world.
- espo 15y agoMy SSH buddy is iSSH from the App Store. Always available when I need him.
- ceejayoz 15y agoAssuming you've got a data connection, that is.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- corin_ 15y agoIf you read it properly you'll see that he wasn't notified because of the intrusion attempts, but because he screwed up some code which was scanning the log files. It's not like every time someone port scans him it sends an SMS.
- bahman2000 15y agocan you not ssh from your phone?
- thehodge 15y agoIsn't there a service where you can SMS something like shutdown, restart or other commands for the box to respond to, that would help in that instance where net access is poor
- keyle 15y agoAny idea of what he uses to send SMS from his box?
- troels 15y agoIf you don't want/can afford an sms-gateway, you might want to look at notifo [1] [1] http://notifo.com/ http://notifo.com/
- kevin_morrill 15y agoTwilio would work. http://www.twilio.com/docs/api/rest/sending-sms http://www.twilio.com/docs/api/rest/sending-sms
- ramidarigaz 15y agoI dunno about jgc, but I just send an email to myphonenumber@txt.att.net Works like a charm!
- ErrantX 15y agoMy custom monitoring program (probably not as advanced, it only does some light monitoring) accepts a text message back to shutdown the machine. Not perfect but can work well as a line of defence.
- markbao 15y agoThat's cool. How does it work? Is the text message just via email, and the server can accept an email back with a specific command?
- ErrantX 15y agoServers are with Gandi - which has a hosting API. So... SMS gateway via some shared hosting I have had for ages. This calls a script which figures out which server I mean and uses the API to shut it down. I did used to use Twilio until they dropped international text messaging etc.
- wrl 15y agoWhat are you using instead of Twilio now?
- ErrantX 15y agoA shared hosting account which has a free (5 credits a month) SMS gateway included - I think it is reselling txtlocal.co.uk (who look quite good, but I haven't gotten round to trying them out directly yet). It was kinda thrown together in a few minutes after Twilio flaked :)
- ma2rten 15y agoI'm not an expert in this things, but can't sms messages be spoofed quite easily?
- ErrantX 15y agoI presumed they can be :) so my systems needs a text like this: <machine nickname> <passcode> It is on my todo list to improve this at some point - but not had chance yet.
- kondro 15y agoUmm... my iPhone, iPad and MacBook are my SSH buddies?
- urbanjunkie 15y agoBefore you get into half-arsed solutions like having an ssh buddy, disable root login and password authentication.
- troels 15y agoI assume that he already did this. That the alert comes when someone assumes root. But maybe I'm being naïve.
- jgrahamc 15y agoI don't understand what's 'half-arsed' about deciding up front who I can trust to have login credentials for my personal machines.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Zakuzaa 15y agoPrevention is better than cure.
- jimktrains2 15y agoPreparation is better than being unprepared. (Not that I'm arguing your point. Just taking all steps that you can think of to prevent something, doesn't mean you'll actually prevent it. Being prepared for a worst case is always a good idea.)
- kahawe 15y agoIdeally you should not have to circumvent the default PermitRootLogin settings; it is there for a reason. And no need to give out root passwords, if you are so security conscious. Our polo-necked messiah has given us iPhones that can even run an SSH client so how sort-of pointless to talk about "ssh buddies" and showing iPhone screenshots in the very same article? Since you were getting IDS alarms on your iPhone anyway, why didn't you SSH in and shutdown the machine yourself? And on the root login bit: you would only need a sort-of dummy account for you logging in or for your "ssh buddy", if you love that idea. And all they need to be able to run is "sudo shutdown".
- moe 15y agoI think that guy needs to work on his paranoia.
- kahawe 15y ago...or at least work on the security in a more well-thought way!
- dmoney 15y agoWhy not have the IDS shut down the machine itself?
- modokode 15y agoWouldn't a OTP scheme like OPIE be able to do this decently? My own computers do not permit root login via ssh, but still it'd be more or less a trivial matter to set up a local account for your "SSH buddy", and then over the phone give him the next OTP in sequence for the root account or so for a successful su - -c halt.
- skrebbel 15y agoi don't get this. is it about a personal site? if so, how paranoid can you be? or is it about a professional site? if so, who not try calling a colleague?
- hardy263 15y agoThough the main problem if someone breaks into your system, the first person you'd suspect is your SSH buddy, because there is a possibility of them using a public machine to log in. Who would want to carry the burden of being your first suspect?
- forgotusername 15y agoThis is a pretty pointless idea. If someone has root on your machine for even 500ms that's already too late to trust any of its state without a complete reinstall (and even this is not enough for an advanced attacker). Inevitably, if you have such a buddy, all they can really say is "yup, I'm not the only user here", and you're back at square one. A better investment of the time would be systematizing your configurations, so in this situation you can just rebuild a new machine and kill the old one (ideally, after figuring out how the password was compromised in the first place).
- davidw 15y agoPresumably the point is not "have someone that can fix your machine if it actually gets rooted", but "have someone you can call in case of an emergency who is competent". Seems like for a business, this would be a great service to have available from the likes of Linode, which pays people to be there in any event, rather than your 'buddy', who might go on vacation when you do.
- ceejayoz 15y ago> This is a pretty pointless idea. If someone has root on your machine for even 500ms that's already too late to trust any of its state without a complete reinstall (and even this is not enough for an advanced attacker). As the article says, he just wanted it shut down. Fixing it can come later, but stopping it from sitting on your network sending out millions of spam e-mails is still useful.
- lv_ 15y agoi just use the puTTY client on my symbian phone.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- nodata 15y agoThis is a perfect example of what not to do: the guy has ignored the lessons of denyhosts (etc.) and came up with his own regular expression that doesn't do the right thing. Code re-use please!
- ars 15y agoOr: apt-get install fail2ban Works out of the box to prevent brute force attacks against ssh, and can also be configured for other services, like web authentication, POP, IMAP, etc.
- xolox 15y agoJust a friendly tip: Try to verify whether Fail2ban actually works and keep monitoring your log files (Logwatch). I once found some dumb ass trying to brute force his way into my Postfix server, unfortunately Fail2ban didn't catch it and I only noticed when Logwatch showed me the authentication failures (several hours and thousands of attempts later).
- nodata 15y agoOuch. Did you tell upstream so that they could fix this for everyone?
- tete 15y agoAlso why would you allow either password based and root login when you are "pretty careful with machine security"? I had to smirk when I clicked on complex password scheme.
- kahawe 15y agoI found that password scheme pretty OCD and not very secure considering once you have that paper, you have a pretty good chance of very quickly brute-forcing your way in.
- scott_s 15y agoIf someone breaks into your house or office to get that piece of paper, your problems are bigger than a compromised server.
- kahawe 15y agoBut a piece of paper is easier to snatch than having your passwords written down nowhere - without stealing a whole wallet or breaking into houses.
- modokode 15y agoIf having your password on a note is good enough for Schneier ( http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2005/06/write_down_your.html http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2005/06/write_down_you... ), it's good enough for me. For pretty much the same reason. If you're going to even use a password, it should be a good one. And if it's a good one, you aren't very likely to be able to memorize it.
- kahawe 15y agoWith upper and lower case and "1337" speak thrown in between and a few other characters replaced, it should not be that hard to come up with a decent enough password that you can even remember. And why not a password manager instead of paper? Would be even better if it was one that reads your fingerprint or so.
- Kwpolska 15y agoI have a `poweroff' account on my machine with sudo poweroff as a shell with possibility to use the command without a password.
- yock 15y ago> But it made me realize that I need to tighten up my SSH buddy plans for the next time. I'm going to ask a really audacious question: Why? His systems all worked as expected. Injection attacks were thwarted and login attempts failed. He received (as it turns out, erroneous) notification about the login attempts and knows he needs to do something about it for the future. Why is that something the sharing of credentials? Why is it that people still allow for remote root login? Why do people still allow user SSH access via password? There's a better way, and it leaves you a damn sight better prepared for intrusion attempts than receiving SMS messages that, as he so perfectly demonstrated, were not actionable. Limit logons to PKI-only. Live happier. Sleep easier.
- gcb 15y agonow that your friend logged as root, you did have a breach.
- jarofgreen 15y agoIsn't the real problem that he only has 1 sys-admin for his servers (as far as I can tell)? I mean he can have as many SSH Buddies as he wants but if the alert comes in when he is asleep or drunk or whatever it's pointless. Maybe the alert goes to multiple buddies who have the tech skills to handle it ... maybe he could be their SSH Buddy in return? In other words, rather than a SSH-Buddy, have a pool of server sysadmin friends for emergencies. ps. If the original poster is reading this, I would have posted this on your blog but I didn't have other account passwords to hand ... if your moderating all comments anyway, why not allow anonymous comments?
- AccordionGuy 15y agoSSH buddy? I don't even have a porn buddy! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mgnDHbeVGG4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mgnDHbeVGG4
- jerf 15y agoAt the risk of talking about the actual topic at hand instead of diving off into minutia about putting SSH on your phone, I'm not sure what this gets you, from a paranoia point of view. Assuming the idea is that you want 100% coverage of your server, this might marginally increase your odds, but not really all that much. Times when you aren't available to administer your server are likely to correlate highly with the times when your buddy isn't available. And what if you'd never gotten the SMS in the first place because you were entirely out of service? One person simply can't cover a server 100%, adding a "buddy" doesn't help much. Either you need a full-on netops operation, or you need to be able to deal with not having 100%.
- davidandgoliath 15y agoSomething to sincerely rethink is the idea of shutting the system down in the first place. Call the network provider & have them unplug the ethernet. Turning the system off could potentially reduce your ability to audit where they originally got in. Anywhom. SSH keys :)
- naner 15y agoUltimately this turned out to be a false alarm. Although the machine was under attack (on many levels: there was activity hitting the packet filter, trying all sorts of injection at the Apache level and having a go at SSH) the actual alert (based on looking in auth.log) was a false alarm based on a bad regexp. Any particular reason you didn't want to use Snort or Bro?
- tingletech 15y agoThe unix on call operator in my data center is my ssh buddy
- peterwwillis 15y agoAlternative Solution, with iptables and perl below. You send the magic string to any tcp port and it'll instantly kill all SSH logins and disable the root shell. Send the string again and the process is reversed. Caveat: if your syslog contains trigger entries more than a year old this will blow up. I also recommend you disable root logins and password authentication, but if you insist on enabling them, this may work for you. Modify as necessary. iptables -t raw -A PREROUTING -p tcp -m string --algo bm --string "_-()ThisIsAReallyLongAndComplicatedRandomStringToMatchOn()-_" --from 0 --to lengthofthelongstring -j LOG --log-prefix "29CharacterMaxTriggerString " #!/usr/bin/perl # sentinel - disable root based on a syslog trigger # Copyright (C) 2011 Peter Willis <peterwwillis@yahoo.com> use strict; use POSIX qw(mktime); my $LOG = "/var/log/syslog"; my $LOCKED = 0; my $TRIGGER = "29CharacterMaxTriggerString"; my %M = ( "jan"=>0, "feb"=>1, "mar"=>2, "apr"=>3, "may"=>4, "jun"=>5, "jul"=>6, "aug"=>7, "sep"=>8, "oct"=>9, "nov"=>10, "dec"=>11 ); for ( ;; ) { sleep(1); open(F, "<$LOG") || die "Error: $!"; for ( ;; ) { sleep(1); while ( <F> ) { select(undef, undef, undef, 0.001); #print STDERR "Reading \"$_\"\n"; if ( /^(\w+) (\d+) (\d+):(\d+):(\d+) \w+ kernel: $TRIGGER / ) { my $time = time(); my $stamp = mktime($5, $4, $3, $2, $M{lc $1}, (localtime($time))[5]); if ( $stamp > $^T ) { #print STDERR "Found Trigger\n"; trigger(); } else { #print STDERR "Error: found trigger but timestamp $stamp is before script begin time $^T\n"; } } } } close(F); } sub trigger { if ( $LOCKED ) { system("/usr/bin/chsh -s /bin/bash root"); $LOCKED=0; } else { my @procs = map { @_=split(/\s+/,$_); $_[1] } grep(/^root\s+.*sshd:/, `ps -aux 2>/dev/null`); #print STDERR "Killing processes: @procs\n"; kill(15, @procs); kill(9, @procs); system("/usr/bin/chsh -s /bin/false root"); $LOCKED=1; } }
- antics 15y agoI can't believe no one has suggested this yet: this is the PERFECT argument for two-factor authentication. He's even already sending texts to himself. For every new connector, send some sort of code to your phone, and require it to be inputted back into the computer before any access is given whatsoever. Summarily disregard every single connection and command given without this code re-input. You're even most of the way there: if you're sending messages to yourself, you might as well implement this behavior with it.
- sixtofour 15y agoMany messages here like "why not do X?" or "why in the world are you doing Y?" All good suggestions, but sometimes X or Y may not be good enough, or you may have implemented them incorrectly (like the author's errant regex), or the completely unexpected Z might happen; no one expects Z. I don't see anything wrong with having a human backup. Heck, what if you die and things need to be wound down?
- peterwwillis 15y agoDying is outside the scope of application. Please contact nearest heavenly body for ticket submission process.
- nhooey 15y agoI've had an "ssh buddy" for years, but for a variety of things such as asking for a "download on how to hotwire a motorcycle". I have an agreement with many friends to be an operator so they can look something up on the web, or anything else requiring some efficient technical prowess. We just call up each other and say "operator", and if you're near a computer, you help out with whatever it is.