6 ms·
Unless the fire and explosion was deliberate to cover up the fact it had mostly all been stolen... And maybe the explosion turned out much larger than the th
by londons_explore 5y ago
Unless the fire and explosion was deliberate to cover up the fact it had mostly all been stolen... And maybe the explosion turned out much larger than the thieves expected...
- eloff 5y agoThat's plausible. Never underestimate greed and the desire to avoid being caught for a crime.
- bogomipz 5y agoNo. While it is "possible" it is certainly not "plausible." Please explain why if you were trying to divert attention away from a stolen good such as fertilizer you would engage in a criminal act on such a scale as to get the world to focus on the very thing you would like to draw attention away from?
- eloff 5y agoIf you felt your theft would be discovered, you could very easily expect the explosion would destroy all traces of the theft and nobody would know any better. Many people, especially uneducated people, would not have expected that the theft would be detectable by the size of the explosion. I'm pretty smart and well educated, but I'm not even sure such a thing would have occurred to me, and even if it did I might have preferred my odds taking my chances on that anyway. To be very clear though, I wouldn't have done something so heinous in the first place. Given the sequence events, with the welding going on etc, I don't think this happened. But not for the reasoning you gave.
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoI see your point and i almost want to give it to you, but there's a nuance you didnt catch. The people trafficking on this were most likely terrorists. They use this stuff all the time. We are not terorrists so we may not be versed on blowing up such incriminating evidence. They however, presumably used it all the time. They would have known better than you or me on this topic
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- krisoft 5y agoLook I don't believe in this theory. But the part you are missing is the "And maybe the explosion turned out much larger than the thieves expected..." You look at the explosion see how big it was and say "nobody would be willingly cause that big of a problem to hide a smaller crime." But when you think that you are thinking backwards. You know how big the explosion was, therefore you conclude whoever did it must have known how big the explosion will be. That's not really correct. They might have underestimated for technical reasons, they might have underestimated because they are incompetent. It is kind of like asking "who would burn down 22,744 acres for a gender reveal party?" Nobody intentionally, that's for sure. But the Earth is full of stupid and/or incompetent people.
- perl4ever 5y ago>It is kind of like asking "who would burn down 22,744 acres for a gender reveal party?" There seems to be a massive fire in Turkey, said to have been started by children "burning books". https://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/two-children-accused-of-marmaris-fire-say-they-were-burning-books-166704 https://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/two-children-accused-of-ma...
- DevKoala 5y agoThis is also what I see as a possible explanation. Also, why would you get downvoted?
- ashtonkem 5y agoBecause it’s a conspiracy theory without any evidence, and isn’t even plausible. They blew up their own port to distract from the explosives/fertilizer they were stealing? Hanlon’s razor applies here.
- addingnumbers 5y agoIf you use Hanlon's Razor in criminal investigations, most criminals are going to walk. Most thieves don't hold equity or title to the structures they're stealing from. It's dubious to imply the people working in that warehouse have a greater interest in keeping the dock standing than in staying out of prison.
- ashtonkem 5y agoI have no idea what point you’re trying to make.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DevKoala 5y agoDude relax. Not everybody keeps up with every worldwide event. I didn’t realize there was an investigation and a conclusion with 100% confidence of what happened, thus denying this possibility. Just replying with a link saying “the investigation claims this is what happened, here is the link…” would have been enough.
- ashtonkem 5y agoPointing out why a theory is implausible and lacks evidence is a “dude relax” moment? What?
- system2 5y agoThis will feed conspiracy theorists for decades to come.
- spuz 5y agoThe difference between a conspiracy theorist and a healthy sceptic is that the more implausible the theory the more convinced the conspiracy theorist will be and the less convinced the sceptic will be. Since real conspiracies and cover ups do happen, it should be possible to speculate about conspiracy theories without falling into the trap of conspiracy theorist thinking by applying a healthy dose of Occam's razor.
- latchkey 5y agoHey @spuz... great response. Just wanted to let you know that the link in your profile goes to a junk website. Looks like a domain squatter got it.
- Raineer 5y agoThis is very well stated. A healthy reminder of how logical thinking should be applied, especially in 2021.
- perl4ever 5y agoIf a conspiracy theory is popular, then rejecting it kind of means you have to believe in a conspiracy to promote the conspiracy theory.
- herendin2 5y agoBut the (video documented by multiple sources) sequence of events on the day fits the scenario of an accidental detonation very well: repair work involving hot welding the door, a slowly growing fire, then successively larger explosions capped by an enormous blast after an hour. It all took so long that the fire department had arrived If one has access and just wants to destroy the evidence in a big boom, there's no need for so much complication and the uncertain results of it. Just pour gas on the pile, light a long fuse and run, fast.
- ashtonkem 5y agoAlso, blowing up the fertilizer (and the port) to hide the fact that you were stealing fertilizer isn’t exactly a plausible story. People can be dumb, but come on.
- addingnumbers 5y agoAre you suggesting it's unthinkable that someone would burn down a crime scene? It happens a lot. Crime concealment consistently places among the top 6 motives in studies of arson. I'm not saying it's a very likely cause, but it would be hasty to rule it out
- throwanem 5y agoAre you suggesting that someone trucked away two thousand tons of ammonium nitrate without anyone noticing, presumably for the purpose of recycling it into explosives and thus in full knowledge of its explosive properties, and then capped this incredible achievement in stealthy theft by setting off the rest of it as an improvised bomb that drew every eye in the world? Because I'm not sure how that isn't what this claim of yours really adds up to, and I'm not going to call it impossible, but I am going to say it needs more substantiation than you have as yet seen fit to give it.
- addingnumbers 5y agoI'm saying it would be premature to discount the possibility. A low-level dock supervisor could have been peddling this stuff for years, got spooked, and decided to cover his tracks, perhaps underestimating the size of the explosion, and assuming that the blame for an explosion would be spread too thin for his own liability to outweigh his personal, severe liability for his previous crimes. The comment I was replying to seems to assume this scenario is ridiculous without giving it due consideration. Again, I'm not saying this is a likely hypothesis, just that it's a credible possibility and didn't deserve the knee-jerk ridicule it was given.