2 ms·
This doomsday crap has to stop. Significant climate change is inevitable, in essence it has already happened and the future increases are already locked in. "l
by colechristensen 5y ago
This doomsday crap has to stop.
Significant climate change is inevitable, in essence it has already happened and the future increases are already locked in. "let's halt carbon emissions in a few months" isn't going to happen. "let's halt carbon emissions in a few years" isn't going to happen. It also wouldn't end up making a terrific amount of difference.
Some places which are nice and habitable are going to be uninhabitable (or underwater) in 100 years. Some places which are uninhabitable are going to become habitable. Some species are going to die out, there will be wars, famines, and suffering... just as there always has been. Life isn't a constant slow march upwards towards prosperity, it is messy. There is change, there always has been change and there always will be.
There might be natural feedback systems that make a big dent in the negative outcomes and there might be ways that humans can promote these (if the ice caps melt and it becomes warm in the polar regions, we might get a carpet of freshwater plants covering the oceans again which is a tremendous carbon sink, likewise we might be able to fertilize barren ocean regions to trigger algal blooms which will sink carbon into ocean depths).
But... it's already done. It probably won't be as good or as bad as some people think, humans will adapt and global ecology will adapt.
The attitude needs to be more "how do we make this best of what's to come?" instead of "the end is near!"
but people get off on doomsday.
- websites2023 5y ago>Life isn't a constant slow march upwards towards prosperity, it is messy. There is change, there always has been change and there always will be. This is really, really hard to understand for people today because the post-cold-war era, in the west, has been one of unprecedented stability and prosperity. That is ending, and what is happening is a reversion to the mean that looks a lot like catastrophe.
- TaylorAlexander 5y ago> But… it’s already done. Actually the emissions and environmental damage are ongoing, and we need to stop doing them or the end result will be much worse. > there will be wars, famines, and suffering Personally I think we should change our behavior that will lead to wars, famines, and suffering.
- colechristensen 5y ago>Actually the emissions and environmental damage are ongoing, and we need to stop doing them or the end result will be much worse. Things already are the way they are and the way things are going to be in the intermediate future is already predictable. >Personally I think we should change our behavior that will lead to wars, famines, and suffering. Oftentimes this is more of a matter of exchanging one cause for another. Global austerity and dramatic changes in energy sourcing and production would also cause... wars, famines, and suffering. And the solution is essentially already here. Solar is among the cheapest energy sources and growing dramatically and battery tech is at the point where it can replace fossil fuels for all sorts of transport and mobile energy/work needs. The best we can do is accelerate the growth of these things a little bit more, but in reality we can only make a small difference, new technologies grow at the rate they grow.
- TazeTSchnitzel 5y agoThe fact a huge amount of horrible things are already locked in does not mean that we shouldn't try to prevent locking in even more things. Especially as things probably become exponentially worse the more emissions are locked in.
- blooalien 5y agoIt completely escapes me why this basic concept is so hard to understand for so many people. "Things are bad, so let's actively fight to make sure things are vastly worse in the future." I fail to grasp how that logic is somehow better and more defensible than your simple and obvious logic; "Things are bad, so let's start making them better, or at least stop making things worse."
- doggodaddo78 5y agoIt's not inevitable, it's momentum energy in the system that can be relaxed with bio CCS and other net negative emissions approaches. It depends on the effectivenesses of counter GHG plans.
- smartmic 5y agoThe author argues in two directions that you either fail to recognize or ignore. First, it is still possible to change something for the better, it is not yet "inevitable". Second, should this not happen, then it is not about "some places" and "some species" but about the quality of all biological live, including all of us humans. And then it is no longer done with a bit of adaptation as Darwin suggested, but really all (except maybe a few billionaires who prefer to be shot in a rocket to the moon) will have an existential problem. So, do not think how can we make the best of what's to come, but try everything to minimize the damage as long as we still have a hint of control. I plead that this is what makes us rational beings.
- jzellis 5y agoSo one assumes you're super cool if wherever it is you live or come from is the place that becomes uninhabitable, then. If it's your family that has to abandon their home and become refugees. That's just the way things work. Or do you have enough money that this isn't a problem you're terribly worried about? Can you just up stakes and move to another place and obtain residency and live off of savings or remote work until you can legally work in your new habitable home, confident that all of this is very normal and easy to adjust to? Sometimes, reading the comments on this site, I wonder how the tech industry has a reputation for attracting the brightest people on earth.
- colechristensen 5y agoMore or less everybody had ancestors that uprooted and moved to vastly different locations in search of better opportunities, most Americans are the descendants or were themselves rather poor immigrants. The tech scene is especially full of people who are first or second generation. The world changes and it baffles me that some people have this huge sense of entitlement to constancy. Whether you're very poor or very rich you don't have to live paycheck to paycheck, but it usually means making choices that people don't like. Being prepared for an uncertain future is virtuous and there isn't a level of wealth that demarks whether or not this is possible. If you're living today, maybe buying real estate near sea level is a particularly bad idea, maybe buying real estate in areas threatened by severe drought and wildfires is a bad idea, maybe if you're in these situations already it's worth doing so while there's not a rush. People on this site tend to be problem-solvers. If your location is to become uninhabitable it isn't going to happen overnight. Whatever happens in your life, there are probably going to be some big bad things for everybody. Do your best with what you have, spend less time fantasizing about changing the inevitable or judging people who assume future problems have solutions that aren't just trying to make change not happen.
- Joeboy 5y agoI think people are missing the point that (I think) you are making. "The end is nigh" is not a mentality that is conducive to productive action. "The end is not nigh" doesn't necessarily mean "don't worry about it", it means "the future is going to involve living with the consequences of today's (and yesterday's) actions".