4 ms·
>I genuinely do not know who I am supposed to have identified or which phrases I published are said to have identified them, in combination with [details] in th
by pydry 5y ago
>I genuinely do not know who I am supposed to have identified or which phrases I published are said to have identified them, in combination with [details] in the public domain.
>How I genuinely do not know who I am supposed to have identified or which phrases I published are said to have identified them, in combination with [details] in the public domain.
How on earth is that open and shut?
Open and shut would be if he published the names, which nobody claims that he did.
Conveniently it is also impossible to verify if the crime was actually committed without naming the individuals. All that is required to convict is one judge's say so.
If you were to pick a convenient politically motivated prosecution this ranks up there with navalny skipping bail by dint of being in a coma.
- tablespoon 5y ago>> I genuinely do not know who I am supposed to have identified or which phrases I published are said to have identified them, in combination with [details] in the public domain. >> How I genuinely do not know who I am supposed to have identified or which phrases I published are said to have identified them, in combination with [details] in the public domain. > How on earth is that open and shut? I don't see how those statements have any bearing on whether the case is "open and shut" or not. You're quoting the defendant, who's almost certainly going to come up with some argument for their own innocence no matter how strong the case is.
- soperj 5y agoPeople plead guilty all the time.
- tablespoon 5y agoI am aware of that, which is why I said "almost certainly." He also chose to fight this case, so if he didn't want to undermine it, his only option besides arguing for his innocence was silence.
- pydry 5y agoIf indeed the case were open and shut the argument would be trivially refutable. I haven't even seen a coherent rebuttal yet. I'm not sure it's even possible, given that the evidence in this trial would, conveniently, have to be kept secret - automatically ensuring by default it couldnt be open and shut. Far from being open and shut it actually stinks to high heaven.
- tablespoon 5y ago> I haven't even seen a coherent rebuttal yet. I'm not sure it's even possible, given that the evidence in this trial would, conveniently, have to be kept secret. This guy claims he read the original posts and was able to identify one of the complainants from the information there: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28009316 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28009316 But my point was mainly the Murray is so obviously biased that his statements need to be read with that in mind. Plus denials like "I do not know" and "I don't recall" are some of the vaguest and least credible (since they're almost impossible to prove or disprove).
- Brian_K_White 5y agoWait, so vagueness is a bad thing after all? Or only whe he does it?
- littlecosmic 5y agoI clicked through the link and I think that the commenter felt that there was enough information to identify someone, not that they had identified someone.
- CRConrad 5y agoWell, maybe the actual argument, about whether he did it or not, is "open and shut". What he's presenting here, though, is irrefutable -- in the sense of "not falsifiable" -- so should also be inadmissible: His "[How] I genuinely do not know..." goes to his own state of mind, which nobody else can know or be responsible for. I mean, it could for instance be the case that he obviously and incontrovertibly did it, but is just too utterly stupid to realise it -- then "I genuinely do not know" would still be true. But just as ignorance of the law is no defense, I don't think stupidity is either. "But your Honour, I didn't know she'd die if I cut off her head, so I can't be guilty of murder!" Too fucking bad, you should have known that.
- croes 5y agoSure he is quoting Murray because there is nothing you can quote from the judge how Murray has identified someone.
- user-the-name 5y agoWhy are you taking his words at face value here?
- dahfizz 5y ago> If you were to pick a convenient politically motivated prosecution this ranks up there with navalny skipping bail by dint of being in a coma. I would agree with you, except his prison sentence is only 8 months. If this was some corrupt hit job, they could have easily put him in prison for decades.
- jonathlee 5y ago"Only 8 months" tells you nothing of the conditions or prison population within which he will be placed. 8 months in solitary or in a maximum-security prison (where hard-core, repeat-offender murderers and rapists are) is much harsher than years in a minimum-security prison. Julian Assange, who hasn't even been convicted AFAIK, has been kept in solitary in a maximum-security prison while only being accused, falsely it turns out, of non-violent crimes. The reasonableness of the entire punishment must be taken into account, not just the duration.
- dahfizz 5y ago> The reasonableness of the entire punishment must be taken into account, not just the duration. I agree, and I am not arguing that the treatment of Craig Murray has been reasonable. I am arguing that, if this was a larger conspiracy against him, his prison sentence would be much longer.
- pydry 5y ago>I am arguing that, if this was a larger conspiracy against him, his prison sentence would be much longer. I doubt it's possible to put somebody away for 20 years for what he supposedly did.
- orra 5y agoCraig Murray was warned multiple times that his blog posts were in contempt of court. He should have taken down the blog posts, but instead doubled down. Hard to see whence your outrage originates.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MikeUt 5y ago"He should have shut-up when told to." I believe the outrage originates from believing that he should not have been told to shut-up in the first place.
- orra 5y ago> believing that he should not have been told to shut-up in the first place The rape and sexual assault complainers had their anonymity protected by court order. That's completely normal (in the UK anyway). Craig Murray's not a martyr. He's an eejit.
- pydry 5y agoYes that's why he didnt publish their names. Supposedly their claims were also without basis, so he was sentenced to prison for maybe possibly according to one judge maybe revealing the identities of somebody making a false claim of rape in a case that was itself likely politically motivated. So, nothing fishy about any of that then.