3 ms·
I think she became a public figure (through no fault of her own, as far as I can tell) and thus would unfortunately likely not be afforded the libel protections
by gumby 5y ago
I think she became a public figure (through no fault of her own, as far as I can tell) and thus would unfortunately likely not be afforded the libel protections of a private citizen.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y agoIt’s horrible that you can’t choose not to become a public figure. You have rights which someone else can get rid of by giving you enough attention.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoIt's a balance with freedom of press/speech and like most things there are casualties.
- rootusrootus 5y agoIt seems like it shouldn't be so hard to solve, either. Someone should not become a public figure without demonstrating some kind of intent. If they are not pushing a narrative, trying to influence public opinion, etc, then they do not lose protection. We cannot let the defamers be the ones controlling the definition.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kortilla 5y agoSo when some CEO decides they don’t want to be a public figure?
- ghaff 5y agoAs I understand it, a CEO would generally be a public figure within the scope of what he does as a CEO. Note, though, that in the US, most of what being a public figure affects is the standard for libel (NYT v. Sullivan). Even if you're not a public figure, there's mostly nothing preventing me from writing about you if I want to and truth is pretty much a defense against libel.
- mitchellst 5y agoNot a lawyer, but from my understanding of libel law, the "public figure" thing isn't the problem. Merely being famous (and famous for being falsely accused!) won't necessarily make you a public figure for libel purposes. But there's another part of the standard: a defendant must knowingly say things that are substantially false. Referring to Ms. Knox as a "convicted murderer" in a news article, for example, is deceptive in context but it is technically correct. She was convicted. And then on the movie side, it's explicitly fiction, and the character does not share her name. So they can claim the defense that any "false" claim is about their invented character, not about her... and by the way, they have lots of first amendment juice for artistic expression. In the end, you're right. It's a sad story, but she doesn't appear to have legal protection from libel law. The filmmakers should probably be ashamed of themselves, but you don't make a Matt Damon movie without a go-ahead from some high-priced lawyers who know they're in the clear from a liability standpoint. Though, ethics perhaps weren't considered...