4 ms·
The answer to the literal question is simple. Other people use your name, not you, so the name belongs to other people. Render unto Caesar, etc. Your name re
by teddyh 5y ago
The answer to the literal question is simple. Other people use your name, not you, so the name belongs to other people. Render unto Caesar, etc.
Your name refers to, not your identity (whatever that is), but the idea of you in the heads of other people.
- ectospheno 5y agoI feel like your answer not only ignores the entire premise of the article but also throws fuel on the power differential fire discussed within.
- tiahura 5y agoHe’s providing the unavoidable answer that the author feels is unfair - your reputation doesn’t belong to you, it belongs to everyone else. She believes it’s unfair because powerful people are able shape hers. I suppose the alternative is to have our reputation determined by unbiased Facebook factcheckers.
- adjkant 5y agoSo are you against all defamation lawsuits? This is more or less just an extension of that train of thought: people deserve to not have their reputation ruined unfairly by powerful structures. There's a big difference between gossip of people you know and a Hollywood movie.
- olah_1 5y agoThis reminds me of identity in Secure-Scuttlebutt. It’s my favorite naming system. Basically you’re just an unpronounceable identity. Other people give you names. Different people call you different things. After all, when you’re born, you’re just given a name.
- cblconfederate 5y agoBy that logic trademarks should not exist
- teddyh 5y agoTrademarks exist to protect against consumer confusion (intentional or not), nothing else. In this case, the name of a person is used to refer to the events which happened to that person and the related media circus. Is this confusing to anybody? No.
- moron4hire 5y agoThe name of this person is being used to refer to a fictional story. The events as depicted did not occur. It's absolutely confusing.
- elric 5y agoAdditionally, trademarked names are made up by the trademark owner (or by people they pay). Your name is made up by your parents/guardians, and you generally have no say in it.
- pjc50 5y agoYour default name is the one you get from your parents, but there are all sorts of personal or professional reasons to change it, and it used to be standard for women to change their names at least once in a lifetime.
- smeyer 5y agoI changed my last name when I got married. Does that mean that I own my last name but not my first name (which has been unchanged since birth)?
- mcguire 5y agoRight. You own it, but your spouse doesn't.
- pjc50 5y agoWhat is Elton John's name and who owns it?
- ghaff 5y agoThis can actually be a somewhat complicated issue when businesses are involved. When a family name is trademarked as part of a business, a different family member can sometimes be prevented from using their family name in a competing business, e.g. https://www.bullyhillvineyards.com/about/heritage https://www.bullyhillvineyards.com/about/heritage
- bahmboo 5y agoReminds me of the artist formerly known as Prince. We need a Prince symbol emoji.