3 ms·
The "prebate" is supposed to compensate for that, so that the burden doesn't fall on poor people. But it still means that the middle class and wealthy are payi
by jfengel 5y ago
The "prebate" is supposed to compensate for that, so that the burden doesn't fall on poor people.
But it still means that the middle class and wealthy are paying the same flat rate, rather than the current progressive system. So the effect is to shift the tax burden from the wealthy to the middle class.
That's before taking into account the fact that the very wealthy don't spend a majority of their wealth on consumables, so are unlikely to be taxed. That makes it even more regressive.
It's a terrible plan that sounds good if you don't think about it too much. It would be equally trivial to have a flat income tax, and only trivially more complicated to have a progressive income tax. It's not progressiveness that makes the tax system complicated. The complications come from the many different things that can constitute "income" and all of the things we want to exempt as beneficial "expenses".
None of that goes away when you shift the numbers to the consumption side. You want sales taxes on stocks? Houses? Carried interest? What makes those transfers of money for goods and services different from sales at stores? You'll end up with an equally thick book of rules.
It's the kind of plan you come up with when you have no idea why the current system is the way it is, so you just wipe it out and leave others to re-invent all of the complexities that don't show up in a system that has never faced the real world. And it gets promoted by the kind of people who are well aware that it shifts the burden to the middle class and away from the wealthy.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The "prebate" is supposed to compensate for that, so that the burden doesn't fall on poor people. The prebate for a family of four is about the same as the Child Tax Credit for a family with two children., so at zero income they’d have about the same net taxes with “fairtax” giving a effectiv marginal rate on additional work income (given near unity marginal spending) greater than status quo payroll taxes (they would face 0 or negative net income taxes under the status quo because of standard/dependent exemptions and EITC.) So, the burden still falls on the poor, particularly the working poor. > So the effect is to shift the tax burden from the wealthy to the middle class. No, it shifts it from the middle class (or, rather, high-income wage earners) who pay the highest rates under the current system (not capital income recipients, which is the dominant income mode of the truly wealthy) to the poor, who pay taxes at lower income levels and higher marginal rates without significantly greater initial refundable credits. That's even before considering that marginal propensity to consume drops with income (and is near 100% for the poor), and effective marginal rate under fairtax is the nominal rate times marginal propensity to consume. The “fairtax” is “fair” to people who see the poor as “lucky duckies” [0] successfully executing a devious tax avoidance strategy. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucky_duckies https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucky_duckies