4 ms·
BTW: I purchased and read the book banned by the American Booksellers Association a couple of weeks ago: The bestseller that they apologized for sending out in
by fortran77 5y ago
BTW: I purchased and read the book banned by the American Booksellers Association a couple of weeks ago: The bestseller that they apologized for sending out in their sample box, saying that sending this well-reviewed book was an "act of violence." I enjoyed it. But then again, I also liked "Chaos Monkeys" which I also read when it first came out, having been well reviewed in The New York Times.
The author of this essay is correct. These content warnings aren't meant to help anyone--they're simply virtue signaling.
> But an article about the fastest-selling books in history? What the hell could trigger even the most skittish soul in a piece like that?
The "trigger" terminology was developed when treating people who survived battlefield traumas. It's offensive to me that it's been culturally-appropriated to apply to overly sensitive college students and other too-fragile people.
- jjj123 5y agoDo you disagree that someone who’s gone through something traumatic _off_ the battlefield (sexual abuse for example) could develop PTSD?
- blitz_skull 5y agoI don’t think there’s a realistic situation where reading the name “J.K. Rowling” should ever cause someone to lose their shit a lá PTSD.
- AlexandrB 5y agoNo one ever said it could! The article the medium post complains about called it a "content warning" not a "trigger warning". The "trigger" terminology was used by the medium post's author, setting up a bit of a straw man. However GP was arguing that any use of "trigger" outside of military trauma is appropriation, which is what your parent was arguing against.
- KarlKemp 5y agoSo they are picking the weakest examples to make a point they are applying to the whole category. By that logic, guinea pigs are terribly dangerous because, one time, someone stepped on one, fell, and hit their head.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe "trigger" terminology was developed when treating people who survived battlefield traumas. Could you cite a source or sources on this? Is the origin of a term or practice at all relevant to a broader or more evolved understanding of its applicability? Or a reason to specifically deny it to other domains? Your're aware that TFA discusses content rather than trigger warnings?
- fortran77 5y ago> Could you cite a source or sources on this? Sure. It was developed by psychiatrists treating people during the Vietnam War era. See: https://books.google.com/books?id=EL8eMEkxzkYC&pg=PT411#v=twopage&q&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=EL8eMEkxzkYC&pg=PT411#v=tw... for example
- dredmorbius 5y agoAnd your citation is from a chapter on child psychiatric truama. That rather flies in the face of your statement "It's offensive to me that it's been culturally-appropriated to apply to overly sensitive college students and other too-fragile people." Perhaps your moral sense of offence is a poor scientific guide?
- kcplate 5y ago…but it totally applies though. I suspect that book and that chapter probably demonstrates how severe trauma can have a similar psychological impact to children as battlefield PTSD does to soldiers. It’s not so much appropriation, but describing a similar impact, appropriately. I don’t think a fragile individual could effectively demonstrate how merely encountering a paragraph accidentally about an author or book they don’t like would have any psychological impact equivalence to a soldier with battlefield PTSD or a child that has experienced severe psychological trauma. So in a sense they are appropriating the concept, inappropriately. Perhaps if a parent or teacher beat them about the head senseless with “The Order of the Phoenix”…