4 ms·
If You Need a Content Warning, Maybe It’s Time for You to Quit Reading
- tlackemann 5y agoWe've reached a point where you can't scroll through Twitter without "CW: Food" popping up on the feed, as if posting your lunch is now offensive to people. Speaking out against this absurdity is treated as "fatphobic" It's both baffling and sad.
- AlexandrB 5y agoHonest question: Why does it bother you that some (or even many) people put "CW: Food" on their posts? You can just ignore it.
- tlackemann 5y agoIt doesn't bother me. It's just sad.
- happytoexplain 5y agoLet me reword the parent's question to avoid semantic dancing: Why are you using those adjectives to describe something that seems to have virtually no impact on you (ignoring whatever name calling results from arguments about it, rather than from the fact of it)? Maybe you think the inclusion of the label is unnecessary, maybe silly. I could see that opinion pretty easily. But sad? Baffling? Absurd? Briefly: Where is this intense negativity coming from?
- andreskytt 5y agoFor me, there is nothing intense about the emotions. I feel sad, that real care for the well-being of people has been replaced by the ability to slap a CW onto things. I also feel sad about there apparently being people intensly hurt by reading a name on a screen. How did we get there? Maybe because these folks have been led down a path of sheltering for so long any discomfort is unbearable? This must be a really horrible existence. I feel sorry for them but at the same time do think CWs are counter-productive.
- BrianOnHN 5y agoWhilst I get the author's point, I think he's addressing something as it is a fact when rather it's more like "clever" (maybe not the right adjective) copywriting. For example, with startups, "our service is not for people who hate making money" would exist for the same purpose. Ps- I get angry after eating like shit on Saturday, too. Try running for 30mins Sunday morning. You might just find yourself doing something better with that extra energy.
- AlexandrB 5y agoWhile the author does have a point about the silliness of putting a content warning RE a controversial author's name and work being mentioned, I don't think this is quite right: > At its core, the content warning is nothing more than a form of censorship. Who is the censor in this case? The only person who can "censor" the work after reading a content warning is the reader themselves. You could call such a decision overly sensitive on the part of the reader but I don't think it meets the definition of censorship.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoI think the cor of the issue is the -phobic suffix. We instictively feel that 'transphobic' is the same kind of insult as 'homophobic', and there is no place for homophobic people in our society. It immediately tells the reader that Rowling hates or is somehow against trans people while in fact it is something very different: she wants to protect women from men who pretend they are women, and who abuse new laws created in good faith for trans people.
- happytoexplain 5y agoNo idea where Rowling lands on what I'm about to say (haven't followed it), but it reminds me: Sometimes I think when people are arguing their opinion X, and that opinion has any overlap, actual or perceptual, meaningful or incidental, with a demonized opinion Y, rather than distinguish X from Y, they will apparently purposefully either leave it ominously unmentioned, or even implicitly lean into the comparison, even if Y is demonized for a good reason and they ostensibly agree with the demonization. I think they do the former sometimes because they obstinately think, "of course I disagree with Y, I shouldn't have to say it", and yes, audiences frequently make unfair comparisons, but many times a comparison is so obvious that it's misleading to say nothing. As for the latter, I think that is a result of either self-destructive frustration (they've given up on arguing and are just provoking), or evidence that they do agree with Y, but don't want to say it out loud. In any case, 100% of the time, it's all unnecessarily provocative and it's destructive to understanding and therefore to the conversation. The one Rowling Tweet I know about off the top of my head falls squarely into this dynamic: The one where she said something sarcastic about how women menstruate. Sarcasm and willfully ignoring colloquial semantics to fall back on "objective facts" devoid of context are very common components of the behavior described above (well, they're common to bad-faith arguments in general).
- fortran77 5y agoBTW: I purchased and read the book banned by the American Booksellers Association a couple of weeks ago: The bestseller that they apologized for sending out in their sample box, saying that sending this well-reviewed book was an "act of violence." I enjoyed it. But then again, I also liked "Chaos Monkeys" which I also read when it first came out, having been well reviewed in The New York Times. The author of this essay is correct. These content warnings aren't meant to help anyone--they're simply virtue signaling. > But an article about the fastest-selling books in history? What the hell could trigger even the most skittish soul in a piece like that? The "trigger" terminology was developed when treating people who survived battlefield traumas. It's offensive to me that it's been culturally-appropriated to apply to overly sensitive college students and other too-fragile people.
- jjj123 5y agoDo you disagree that someone who’s gone through something traumatic _off_ the battlefield (sexual abuse for example) could develop PTSD?
- blitz_skull 5y agoI don’t think there’s a realistic situation where reading the name “J.K. Rowling” should ever cause someone to lose their shit a lá PTSD.
- AlexandrB 5y agoNo one ever said it could! The article the medium post complains about called it a "content warning" not a "trigger warning". The "trigger" terminology was used by the medium post's author, setting up a bit of a straw man. However GP was arguing that any use of "trigger" outside of military trauma is appropriation, which is what your parent was arguing against.
- KarlKemp 5y agoSo they are picking the weakest examples to make a point they are applying to the whole category. By that logic, guinea pigs are terribly dangerous because, one time, someone stepped on one, fell, and hit their head.
- wheaties 5y agoI remember going to college eager to learn and explore ideas that were _different_ than mine. I grew up at the poverty line, in one of the top 10 wealthiest towns in America. Naturally they were very white and also any taint from anything immoral was covered up. If I hadn't had such an open mind, I'd still be living in that bubble. I don't think I'd have the same experience today nor would I have been set up to open my mind to issues because "warnings."
- AlexandrB 5y agoThis seems self-contradictory. If you were eager to learn and explore different ideas, surely you would have just ignored the warnings? As is, I think most people ignore them.
- IAmEveryone 5y agoIs it retro week? That particular battle of the culture wars seems to have passed years ago. Among other things, it's called a "content note" far more often these days. Also: nobody cares. But, to just quickly make the argument the author would have thought to mention if they had spend five minutes on Google and were intellectually honest: CNs aren't intended to allow you stop reading, although that may be an option for people that really want to. Their primary mechanism is different: it's a quick, easy, and, for those who don't care, totally trivial signal to the readers that the writer or speaker is aware that the content may trigger strong emotions, but that it isn't their intention to inflict any harm. It's a tiny gesture that, for those where it matters, makes a whole lot difference. If you can't quite follow along, just imagine how different it feels if someone intentionally punches you compared to inflicting the same amount of physical harm inadvertently. If anyone is being overly emotional, it's those who are somehow incensed by others' attempts to avoid harming people. I'm not especially harmed by reading about violent rape, but I can easily understand how someone might be. How its possible to deny that, but get all enraged about a single line of italics at the top of a five-page story is, unfortunately, beyond my abilities. Neither, by the way, is it censorship. It's the opposite, a mechanism allowing people to make informed choices, thereby expanding the universe of possible content that can be used for any given purpose without fear of offending or harming anyone. If you somehow managed to abolish the MPAA rating system, you wouldn't get more of the movies that were previously rated R. You'd get none.
- andreskytt 5y agoGetting similar emotions to having been punched from reading a name sounds very scary. And, if such people exist, how can I tell, what other things can trigger others? People having been involved in bad car crashes might plausibly be triggered by mention of traffic. So the question becomes, why do we afford the safety to certain groups but not others? The simple fact is that any and all text, spoken or written, can do harm by triggering emotions or introducing ideas contrary to one’s beliefs causing discomfort. So how do we choose what to warn people about?
- happytoexplain 5y ago
- jordemort 5y agoThe "real world" is not a safe space. It never will be. I used to have the same kind of knee-jerk reaction to content warnings; you might say I was triggered by them. "The world isn't safe," I thought, "so you should just toughen up." Now that I am a geriatric millennial, I find my views have softened. For people with marginalized identities, it can be particularly unsafe; depending on where they live, they might face discrimination in their communities. The local government might want to kill them. Their own families might reject them. They might feel unsafe in their own home, with no realistic hope of getting out any time soon. For people that have been victims of traumatic events, "toughen up/get over it" isn't really an option. Again, the world is not a safe space; it might be littered with reminders of what happened to them, which may be perfectly innocuous to other people. For people who feel unsafe in their homes, communities, or the world at large, going online can be a very important means of escaping their situation. It may actually be their only means of escape; it's very possible that the only communities that they are able to access where they can feel safe are online. Sometimes signaling is just signaling. Not all signaling is for you. I've seen lots of CWs that I don't understand, or that I privately think are somewhat absurd, which is really just the same thing as not understanding them. I don't think the people who used those were trying to signal how woke they were to me, though; I assume those signals were meant for somebody else. The "real world" is not a safe space, but the virtual worlds that we are building are not subject to the same limitations. People should be able to tailor the spaces they create to be as safe as they want them to be, for the people they want them to be safe for. Do not assume that a signal that wasn't intended for you was made in bad faith.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 5y agoYes, thank you... The argument is also contradictory: if the warnings risk "coddling" people too much, they must have the intended effect. But, at the same time, it's claimed that they are useless/absurd/etc. Both can't be true at the same time. And if one accepts that they protect people who had traumatic experiences of violence, it's really quite something to tell them to "get over it" without having any similar experience. Besides, if people truly believe that emotional suffering is a requirement for a well-rounded character, would they argue in favour of subjecting everyone to trauma? Not dude ranch a-night-alone-in-the-woods, but actual harm? Maybe they would themselves really profit from some more real-world experience of struggle? Maybe donating all their belongings and starting a new life in a randomly chosen country or something like that.