2 ms·
I disagree. You can think up "breakthroughs" all you want, it's easy. As any mathematician or software developer can confirm, it's easy for a human to propose
by TeMPOraL 5y ago
I disagree.
You can think up "breakthroughs" all you want, it's easy. As any mathematician or software developer can confirm, it's easy for a human to propose an explanation and immediately convince themselves of its correctness; validating hypotheses is hard work that the brain desperately tries to avoid. And in physics, validating things on paper can only get you so far - you ultimately need experimental confirmation to make solid science.
Here is where technology becomes necessary: in order to favor one hypothesis over the other, you need to find where they give conflicting predictions, and then check what actually happens in reality. That's only possible when you can perform the necessary experiment and observe the results with sufficient precision to discriminate between competing explanations. Technology is what gives you this capacity, expanding the scope of experiments you can run.
As someone else mentioned, you could drop Einstein back a few hundred years and his work would be laughed off - because ultimately there would be no way to tell if he's right or not. The theory may look beautiful (if complex) on paper, but if you can't discriminate between it and alternatives through an experiment, it's meaningless and you may as well use the simplest model that fits all your current observations.