4 ms·
There could be other interpretations to that, besides "we are less free!" Could one not argue that an increase in prison inmates is the unavoidable consequence
by sliverstorm 15y ago
There could be other interpretations to that, besides "we are less free!"
Could one not argue that an increase in prison inmates is the unavoidable consequence of increasing freedoms? It seems counter intuitive, but perhaps the more freedoms one has, the more readily one encroaches on freedoms one does not have?
- vacri 15y agoPeople aren't all that different, and generally want the same things. Besides, the US isn't that much freer than its first-world contemporaries. For example, although we in Australia don't have constitutionally-protected freedom of speech, the Press Freedom Index puts us as having more freedom of public speech than in the US, and both of us are well below most of the northern European states. http://en.rsf.org/press-freedom-index-2010,1034.html http://en.rsf.org/press-freedom-index-2010,1034.html The word "freedom" occurs much more frequently in American political discourse, but that does not mean that Americans are automatically freer than anywhere else. I find it hard to believe that those extra freedoms that Americans do have (which most don't seem to exercise in day-to-day life) is sufficient to cause a fivefold increase in per capita prison population.
- sliverstorm 15y agoAnother possible explanation that occurs to me today: the punishments in America are greater. The guy who bombed Oslo and killed 80-some kids in Norway is allegedly facing a max of something like 25 years. He'd get multiple life sentences in America.
- arethuza 15y agoAccording to BBC radio this morning it is 21 years although I believe this can be extended for 5 years at a time if they believe he still faces a danger to society.