47 ms·
Top German court strikes down Facebook rules on hate speech
- hef19898 5y agoThat affected two accounts Facebook suspended in 2018. Facebook still can delete comments and suspend accounts, as long as users get a chance to explain themselves and are informed about deletion and suspension. Back in 2018 that was not the case, so Facebook was ordered to reinstate the accounts and comments. Both accounts were suspended for 30 and 3 days respectively. The headline is kind of exaggerating here.
- SheinhardtWigCo 5y agoThe ruling is more nuanced than the headline implies: > This, it added, is because Facebook does not undertake to inform the user about the removal of an offensive post at least retrospectively, to advise that it is blocking an account, to give a reason for doing so, or to offer the right of appeal. Fair enough. Facebook is often criticized around here for handling policy violations in an opaque manner. The court simply says that principles of due process should apply when users are banned or censored.
- corty 5y agoWhat the article is also missing and what will be a major problem for FB: FB will have to give the user the opportunity of a statement _before_ blocking their account and give reasons for blocking and why the statement was not acceptable. https://www.heise.de/news/BGH-Facebook-muss-geloeschte-Hassrede-wieder-freischalten-6150978.html https://www.heise.de/news/BGH-Facebook-muss-geloeschte-Hassr...
- hef19898 5y agoI don't see a big problem there. Have a bot alerting the user, giving him e.g. three days to respond. Get the response, block the user anyway. Wait for the next law suite.
- corty 5y agoCanned responses from a bot and answers without weighing the arguments given will loose them the following lawsuits. And Germany is a looser-pays country, so given a lost lawsuit after each deleted post or blocked account, they'll be out of a lot of money. And Germany's equivalent of ambulance chasers ("Abmahnanwaelte") are certainly cooling the champagne already.
- hef19898 5y agoNot sure, the ruling affected two accounts temporarily suspended in 2018. One auch law suite every couple of years, why not? Also, it would be up to the compliant to proof the arguments against suspension were not properly evaluated. I have a hard time a German court would go to ruling on Facebook internal procedures around community rule enforcement. They didn't neither in thay ruling, they just said Facebook needs some kind of process in place, not what kind of process.
- corty 5y agoThe above article isn't very elaborate on that, but the heise one[0] cites the judges: 'Es bedürfe "einer umfassenden Würdigung und Abwägung der wechselseitigen Interessen", insbesondere der "kollidierenden Grundrechte", betonen die Richter: "Auf Seiten der Nutzer die Meinungsäußerungsfreiheit, auf Seiten der Beklagten vor allem die Berufsausübungsfreiheit."' roughly: 'One needs "a comprehensive judgement and weighing of mutual interest", especially of the "colliding basic rights", as the judges emphasize: "on the users' side freedom of expression, on the side of the defendant [FB] freedom of trade and profession". This is a high standard that needs quite some text and elaboration to fulfil, not at all doable by form letter. 'Im Sinne des Interessenausgleichs müsste sich Facebook aber verpflichten, den Nutzer "über die Entfernung eines Beitrags zumindest nachträglich und über eine beabsichtigte Sperrung seines Nutzerkontos vorab zu informieren, ihm den Grund dafür mitzuteilen und eine Möglichkeit zur Gegenäußerung einzuräumen, an die sich eine Neubescheidung anschließt".' roughly: 'However, in the way of balancing interests, Facebook has to pledge to "inform [the user] about removal of a post at least after the fact and about planned blocking of an account before the fact, to name the reason thereof and offer an opportunity to issue an opposing statement, which is followed by a subsequent further decision and information.".' So they are relatively explicit in how Facebook must do things and that they cannot just file the opposing statement to the recycle bin. Facebook's lawyer called this "completely impractical" (but of course he would...) because of the hundreds of daily cases. [0] https://www.heise.de/news/BGH-Facebook-muss-geloeschte-Hassrede-wieder-freischalten-6150978.html https://www.heise.de/news/BGH-Facebook-muss-geloeschte-Hassr... Oh, and btw., the court that decided this is the highest regular court in Germany, setting a binding precedent for all other German courts. There are many more cases than just those two, all the others you just don't read about because everyone knows that lower courts' decisions aren't that important and frequently overturned. So even if it was just about 2 posts, this decision is important and will shape all future cases.
- axiosgunnar 5y ago> “Rich white males can murder and rape here and nobody cares! It’s about time the Office for the Protection of the Constitution sorted this out,” the post adds. Imagine the post said that. Nobody would have been blocked, and no lawsuit would need to be filed. You know I am right, since about every other post on Twitter is like that, without any ban of course. The question is, if censoring certain political views (albeit expressed a bit harshly of course) is the way our society should go.
- pjc50 5y agoReminder that the German constitution also includes a ban on certain kinds of political views for obvious historical reasons.
- formerly_proven 5y agoReminder that the German constitution contains no such thing.
- djbebs 5y agoIt absolutely does.
- formerly_proven 5y agoIt's not that long and written in pretty simple language, can you please point out where it bans certain kinds of political views?
- DisplayedPublic 5y agoArtikel 18 > Wer die Freiheit der Meinungsäußerung, insbesondere die Pressefreiheit (Artikel 5 Abs. 1), die Lehrfreiheit (Artikel 5 Abs. 3), die Versammlungsfreiheit (Artikel 8), die Vereinigungsfreiheit (Artikel 9), das Brief-, Post- und Fernmeldegeheimnis (Artikel 10), das Eigentum (Artikel 14) oder das Asylrecht (Artikel 16a) zum Kampfe gegen die freiheitliche demokratische Grundordnung mißbraucht, verwirkt diese Grundrechte. Die Verwirkung und ihr Ausmaß werden durch das Bundesverfassungsgericht ausgesprochen. Try to use your rights to abolish the democratic order and you lose them. That's indeed pretty simple language.
- FeepingCreature 5y agoOfficial press announcement of judgment (German): https://www.bundesgerichtshof.de/SharedDocs/Pressemitteilungen/DE/2021/2021149.html https://www.bundesgerichtshof.de/SharedDocs/Pressemitteilung... Core point: Terms and Conditions must be balanced against the rights of the user per the "good faith" principle, especially when there is a conflict with the basic right of free speech. I think the specific way in which the court has tried to enforce this is maybe a bit toothless, but to me the important aspect isn't the judgment itself but what its reasoning implies: that the terms of agreement with Facebook do conflict with freedom of speech meaningfully, at least in Germany, and while the terms do win out, they don't do so unconditionally but have to remain proportional and account for the interests of the user in good faith.
- erfgh 5y agoWhy do courts have the power to tell me what I will publish on my website?
- Tepix 5y agoIt says so in the ruling: § 307 Abs. 1 Satz 1 BGB The published terms of service were invalid because they unreasonably disadvantage the users of the network contrary to the requirements of good faith.
- FeepingCreature 5y agoBecause you live in a society
- vixen99 5y agoSo do the citizens of Byelorussia and North Korea. They also have to obey the rules. So 'because you live in a society' doesn't take us any further does it?
- lm28469 5y agoI know you're arguing in bad faith but Germany is closer to a democracy than """Byelorussia""" and NK.
- Tepix 5y agoIt makes clear that you have to follow the rules in whatever country you live in.
- SiempreViernes 5y agoThe question was about why courts had power over FB and "you live in a society" explains that. Your (bad faith) attack completely fails at questioning that reasoning, because the reason is true regardless of your feeling about the particular courts that exist in a given society.
- playguardin 5y agoAnd the society is garbage.
- vivekd 5y agoSeems like a catch 22 for Facebook - if they don't remove the material they get criticized for facilitating hate speech, if they do remove they get criticized for censorship, acting arbitarily and not providing adequate reasons. I'm not sure what they're supposed to do in this situatuion.
- newsyyswen 5y agoIt is a problem of their own making. If they cannot manage unmoderated posting without hurting a lot of people, why should they be allowed to run a business based on unmoderated posting? Would you say it is a catch-22 for a factory if a government ordered them to stop production or stop polluting nearby waterways with their toxic runoff? Perhaps for the factory, but the nearby communities would say it's a clear-cut case.
- joejerryronnie 5y agoMy telecom company is not responsible for moderating all speech that occurs over their cellular service. How is this different from FB?
- newsyyswen 5y agoYour telecom actually is responsible for moderating your usage - try consistently pirating media without a good blocklist in the US and see how long you keep your service. Most providers will cut you off after a half-dozen or so nastygrams, and that's just for the light offense of copyright infringement. Your telecom also uses tax money to fund its infrastructure deployments, and it is regulated as more than an ordinary private company.
- tynpeddler 5y ago> If they cannot manage unmoderated posting without hurting a lot of people, why should they be allowed to run a business based on unmoderated posting? This is nonsense. They are trying to moderate content and they're being told that it's not permitted. It's qualitatively akin to requiring the New York Times to publish all letters to the editor. Or more specific to the posted article, require that the NYT write a personalized response for each letter that they don't publish and give the letter's author an opportunity to edit it for content.
- rossdavidh 5y agoI suspect that the fundamental issue here is not even about hate speech, really, it's about labor. The court wants a human to write a message to the user saying "we took down your message/banned your account because [reasons]". Facebook doesn't want to have a human in the loop, because they have billions of users and would have to hire tens of thousands more people to monitor that. I suspect that European governments will continue to badger FB (and Twitter, and Google, and etc.) on this until they up their headcount to deal with it using humans-in-the-loop. The question is whether or not social networks are actually profitable if you have human moderation. I suspect they are not.
- frockington1 5y agoDoes this also apply to German companies (I'm ignorant on this matter)? If not, all this regulation does is build a massive moat around US Tech companies
- frankfrankfrank 5y agoI get your perspective, but I don't think even a European/German court would be that cynical. Although I would agree that the court is actually just demanding a reason be provided for the removal of speech and expression, not even that really that a human must do it. My expectation is that Facebook will increase efforts to automate more granular and broad surveillance on users and content in order to provide automated reasons for removing content. The crux, after all is not that the content was removed, but rather that no reason was given. Maybe the short term solution is simply an overwhelmingly broad legalese that covers broader reasons for censorship. I don't see the Germany polity desiring the increase in humans doing such rote and banal work. We have seen the damage it does to people to essentially be enforcers of human rights violations. It is psychologically and emotionally damaging to abuse people. No, this will be a move towards more automation of the control, surveillance, and censorship that the ruling class demands. You may agree with it since it's the censorship of "racism", but don't be surprised when what you believe or say is all the sudden "racism" too or that your lèse-majesté will be included in the list of forbidden speech and thought next. If allowed to manifest … and we are racing towards this end … things will soon look like right out of 1984 where you don't even have the chance to disseminate anything the regime dislikes. Instead, you will instead you will be whisked away or have your life ruined if you say anything the regime will intentionally arbitrarily deem "hate speech" or whatever other rationalization they come up with. It will be anyone's guess what it is that the regime may not like at any given time and therefore no one will dare say anything. It is what others have called anarcho-tyranny, but I simply see as rather fundamental abusiveness 101 that any abused spouse can describe and you can read about the the most basic psychology textbooks.
- throwawaysea 5y agoI hope this is the start of global regulatory changes to remove the opaque processes that govern management of information on social media or other digital public town squares. I know the word "propaganda" is loaded and means different things to different people, but to me an opaque, sometimes politically-biased process that divulges little about how society-wide information is being shaped, feels like propaganda. The fact that it is done by a Silicon Valley tech company doesn't suddenly make it less dystopian or benevolent.