13 ms·
You can see that in the comment from a prosecutor quoted in the piece that refers to "options". If you really wanted to ban some kind of behavior, the ideal out
by _delirium 15y ago
You can see that in the comment from a prosecutor quoted in the piece that refers to "options". If you really wanted to ban some kind of behavior, the ideal outcome would be that everyone who does it is arrested, and nobody who doesn't. But from law-enforcement's perspective what they often want are "options" for prosecution--- so that when they find someone who they're pretty sure deserves to be arrested, they can dig up a statute that justifies the arrest. In that setting you actually want them as broad as possible, so you always have something in your back pocket to get someone with. Of course you don't prosecute everyone who uses a web browser... but if you find someone doing something "bad" but in a way that isn't specifically criminalized, it's always nice to have that "did a bad thing while using a webbrowser" charging option, eh?
I can sort of see the motivation; nobody likes to see someone who you're 95% sure is guilty manage to beat any charges because you technically couldn't get anything solid. But it's more dangerous a cure than the disease, I think.