3 ms·
If wind speeds a vehicle to some speed, and the vehicle has inertia, and the wind slows down somewhat, how is it surprising that the vehicle would go faster in
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
If wind speeds a vehicle to some speed, and the vehicle has inertia, and the wind slows down somewhat, how is it surprising that the vehicle would go faster in the wind?
Or, does this vehicle, after acceleration has completed, purport to continuously travel faster than the wind at an indefinite steady state?
- jdmoreira 5y ago> Or, does this vehicle, after acceleration has completed, purport to continuously travel faster than the wind at an indefinite steady state? That would break the laws of physics wouldn't it? Which is exactly why the professor took the bait.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoBut then it seems obvious that it could temporarily go faster than the wind due to inertia?
- xaedes 5y ago> Or, does this vehicle, after acceleration has completed, purport to continuously travel faster than the wind at an indefinite steady state? Yes. The vehicle can go faster than the wind in steady state condition. Depending on efficiencies 'any' velocity is possible. It creates thrust by leveraging the different speeds of two media (air and ground). Also works as a boat with two propellers.
- alecst 5y agoOh man! Definitely watch the videos because this is addressed multiple times. And while it sounds plausible (it bit Kusenko) it's not the explanation! Here's one reason why: On the craft is a ribbon, it's dangling from the front of the craft. This is called a "telltale" because it tells the direction of the wind from the perspective of the craft. If the craft is at rest, then the telltale points downwind. And if the craft is moving faster than the wind the telltale points the opposite direction -- backwards, if the craft is moving downwind. What you can see from the runs is that while the telltale is pointing backwards (so, the craft is moving faster than the wind) the craft actually continues to accelerate! In fact while the landspeed record was set as 2.8x the ambient windspeed, the craft was still accelerating, and would have gone faster had they not had to brake. The videos have a lot more to say and I found them really fascinating and counterintuitive, I wanna really emphasize that you should watch them if you find the idea banal or trivial.