4 ms·
Note that it's always sub-1million subscriber channels that get hit with this kind of "oopsie" (or deliberate ad revenue theft by copyright trolls). YouTube som
by phendrenad2 5y ago
Note that it's always sub-1million subscriber channels that get hit with this kind of "oopsie" (or deliberate ad revenue theft by copyright trolls). YouTube somehow shields the larger channels from this, because they know that all it takes is a few Linus Tech Tips or PewDiePies getting copyright trolled for them to create a new platform to compete with Google. Actually, a few have, but they're always just for one creator. If enough creators were affected, they would band together and make their own YouTube clone.
- ramtatatam 5y agoAnd then google or other Moloch acquires it :)
- dredmorbius 5y agoSimple distribution laws are going to ensure that the bulk of claims go against smaller channels, and that those channels will have little recourse but than public outcry and outrage to seek redress. But larger channels have been hit, notably Adam Neely, at 1.38m subscribers, by Warner Chappel, over his defence of Katy Perry's copyright in a Warner recording, for a segment of the video illustrating the source of the claim against Perry, and not the Perry piece Warner claimed infringement of by Neely. https://www.dailydot.com/upstream/adam-neely-youtube-copyright-claim-katy-perry/ https://www.dailydot.com/upstream/adam-neely-youtube-copyrig... https://youtube.com/user/havic5 https://youtube.com/user/havic5 https://youtube.com/watch?v=KM6X2MEl7R8 https://youtube.com/watch?v=KM6X2MEl7R8
- gurchik 5y agoThank you for the Adam Neely example, I forgot about that. To summarize, Warner was being sued over Katy Perry's Dark Horse, claiming that the melody violated the copyright of Flame's Joyful Noise. After Neely published a video at no expense or request from Warner defending Katy Perry, Warner rewarded him by copyright claiming him. It gets even more absurd. That lawsuit against Warner? It was found that Katy Perry's melody infringed on Joyful Noise, but when Warner issued the DMCA claim to Neely, they said Neely infringed on the melody of Katy Perry. In other words, they issued a claim on something that a judge literally just ruled that they do not have copyright on. If it couldn't get any absurd, there's one last thing I remember. In the DMCA claim Warner has to select a time period of Neely's video where the Katy Perry's melody was being infringed, and the time period they chose was actually when Neely was demonstrating the melody of Joyful Noise. So perhaps even Warner's lawyers can't tell the difference.
- dredmorbius 5y agoGood summary, yes, it was simply insane. Two additional elements: - Warner manually reviewed the work, so this wasn't just a case of algorithms gone wild. - Warner's claim was that the infringement was against the primary melody of "Dark Horse", when it was in fact a background melody. Neely makes a big point of this, I'm not sure it's hugely salient, but ... well, it just adds that much more flavour to the manure sandwich.
- gurchik 5y agoIt does happen fairly frequently to large YouTubers, we just don't hear it because the large channels have connections to real humans at Google who can resolve the situation quietly. BitWit is a channel with over 2 million subscribers who was copyright striked by The Verge after uploading a parody/reaction video to their PC Build video. I know this isn't exactly the same since those were DMCA complaints filed by The Verge legal team while TFA is about automatic ContentID claims made by Google itself. You mentioned Linus Tech Tips; interestingly, I know of one recent ContentID claim affecting them, but it was in reverse: someone else made a video about LTT and Google flagged it automatically. Linus said at the time that there is honestly not much they can do when that happens. Imagine feeling so powerless about your own content that Google insists is being infringed.
- Y_Y 5y agohttps://nebula.app/ https://nebula.app/ is such a platform, for example. It's owned by the "youtubers" and really a pretty good example of what a cooperative creator-streamer type platform can be. I don't even mind paying the ten bucks a year.