2 ms·
I do not see any proof that the Malthusian predictions were wrong, on the contrary. There has been indeed as you say "an explosive expansion of wealth". While
by adrian_b 5y ago
I do not see any proof that the Malthusian predictions were wrong, on the contrary.
There has been indeed as you say "an explosive expansion of wealth".
While so much wealth would have been enough so that a much smaller population could have lived much better, the increase of wealth has been used so that a larger population lives about as well as before.
While modern technology provides a number of devices that allow me to spend much less time with chores than my ancestors, e.g. microwave oven, refrigerator, automatic washing machine, computer, mobile phone, there are a lot of things that I cannot hope to ever be able to buy, even if I am supposed to be a well paid professional, which my grandparents were able to buy from their salaries, e.g. large houses and land.
Moreover I am not even able to buy food of a quality comparable to that of my grandparents. While food is very cheap now, food of a quality similar to what they had can no longer be found anywhere that I am aware of.
I have never seen any evidence supporting this dream of "people working together who can actually create greater abundance long term".
People working together or single will continue to discover more efficient ways to make everything that we need, but no matter what they do, they cannot create an extra piece of land for me to have a house, or an extra forest like those in which I was happy to wander as a child, but which now do not exist any more, having been replaced by cultures or buildings or just wasteland.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIn A Farewell to Alms, UC Davis professor of economics Gregory Clark makes the cogent point that both the richest and poorest people who have ever lived, are alive today. Modern technology makes possible great wealth. It also makes absolutely crushing poverty ... survivable. Though not especially enjoyable. https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691141282/a-farewell-to-alms https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691141282/a-...