6 ms·
I don't really understand this attitude, or line of reasoning, or whatever you want to call it. Sure, if a company does something that you find reprehensible,
by kelnos 5y ago
I don't really understand this attitude, or line of reasoning, or whatever you want to call it.
Sure, if a company does something that you find reprehensible, not giving them further money (or attention) is certainly a reasonable -- and honorable! -- thing to do.
But if you've already purchased a standalone[0], non-subscription product from that company, and that company doesn't gain any benefit from your further use of that product (or lose anything from you stopping use), I feel like you're only hurting yourself if you stop using it.
I will concede that if the act of playing one of these standalone games makes you think of the bad thing the company did and makes you angry/upset, I guess it makes sense to stop playing them. But unless the bad thing they did is something personally/viscerally important to you, it feels like that's a bit of an odd trigger.
[0] If the game is multiplayer, and connects to a company-run server, I guess you could make the argument that they benefit in some way from their active-users numbers being higher. I personally don't find that argument all that compelling, but everyone can of course decide where the cutoff of benefit is for them.
- XMPPwocky 5y agoI don't think it's entirely unreasonable to feel weird about watching old DVDs of the Cosby Show, for example. With the "benefit" of context, the vibes are sort of irrevocably off.
- Phenomenit 5y agoYet Michael Jacksons music is still played on the radio and in other media contexts.
- afavour 5y agoThe allegations against Jackson surfaced while he was still very famous so you could argue it’s already been “priced in”, for want of a better phrase.
- anoonmoose 5y agoBetter comparison would be R. Kelly who, like Cosby, was actually convicted of what he was accused of, and did end up having a lot of radio stations (and other media contexts) stop using his music. Not all, but a good number.
- waterhouse 5y agoI googled around, and ... has R. Kelly been convicted? Searching https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R._Kelly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R._Kelly for the string "convict" yields only the sentence saying "R. Kelly had not ever actually been convicted of any crime", quoting a news article from 2019. There is mention of a "sentencing trial", but the cited article (from Dec 2020) says he has pled not guilty and that evidence will be presented, which also sounds like it hasn't reached the conviction stage. And recent news results don't mention convictions (other than "If convicted") either. Do you have a citation?
- anoonmoose 5y agoUh, damn, you're right. Honestly, he's been in jail for so long now- 2.5 years and 22 counts against him- that I wrongly assumed/forgot he wasn't/Mandela effected it. At the time of this writing I had 13 upvotes for a mostly wrong take. Still maintain that the jail time puts Kelly closer to Cosby than Jackson.
- yaseer 5y agoAside, but there seems to be a much higher level of collective cognitive dissonance with Michael Jackson, perhaps because of his stature in popular culture. I'm guilty of this myself - my brain sets a higher bar for evidence, perhaps unreasonably.
- Phenomenit 5y agoYeah, his music is so deeply ingrained in my mind that the "new" information doesn't stick. I have to many fond memories associated with his music and art that it always takes a few seconds for my mind to change course.
- steaknsteak 5y agoHe's also dead, so it's not like he is personally benefitting from our enjoyment of his music anyway.
- klyrs 5y agoYeah, same. As a lifelong fan of the genre, I think R. Kelly's work is boring pastiche, almost entirely forgettable (notable exception, "I believe I can fly" does have some nostalgic value). So it's never been a challenge to put his music away...
- tcbawo 5y agoBill Cosby's character was a gynecologist whose office was in his basement (!)
- dnzkw 5y agoIt's called virtue signalling. See how virtuous this guy is, giving up the precious entertainment he already paid for a decade ago for no reason other than internet points - it's not like these girls are going to be ungroped by this guy's actions, if the allegations are to be believed.
- ctrl-j 5y agoIs your comment just anti-virtue signaling then? Sometimes people just want to share their opinions, and they actually feel those feelings. Sometimes those feelings are about ethical issues.
- aaronbrethorst 5y agoClaiming 'virtue signaling' always feels like a presumption of bad faith by the claimant.
- mcguire 5y agoThat's because it is. The question to ask, of any argument, is "so what?": what do you want to do about it. The "so what" for an accusation of "virtue signalling" is to dismiss the original statement without any further consideration.
- sangnoir 5y agoIn recursive irony, those who use the phrase "virtue signaling" are also virtue signaling, and the it is, in itself a shibboleth for people of a certain political persuasion.
- vmarva 5y agoCalling out virtue signalling is useful to make people realize that judging a situation or person without having all the facts is damaging to society all around the world. This contributes a lot to the hipocrisy we see in the west nowadays which influences the entire world because of technology. The outrage generated by all the mass media is not good as far as I'm concerned and it's good to remind people of that.
- donmcronald 5y agoMaybe it’s just a normal thing as you get older, but knowing the company mistreated people sucks the fun out of it for me. I’m not completely against playing the stuff I’ve already paid for, but they won’t get another penny from me. I’d like to have a database that tracks the C-Suite employees. I’d personally boycott any company that hires any of them. Their careers should be over IMO. I wish we could take away Bobby’s money too, but that’ll never happen.
- akudha 5y agoThis app has been around for a while https://www.buycott.com/campaign/browse https://www.buycott.com/campaign/browse I do not know how good it is. We should totally not give our money to shitty companies. But global commerce is so intertwined that it would quickly become very difficult to buy anything if we start closely looking at every company we give money to. I don't know what the solution is. Boycotting is a start.
- cogman10 5y agoYeah, it really sucks and points to problems with our weak UN and world governments. Sure, we may have somewhat high manufacturing standards in the US, but take a step into foreign soil and all the sudden all the rules are out the window. With companies specifically using countries with the weakest safety regs to cut costs. It's why walmart keeps getting busted for using slave/child labor.
- ctrl-j 5y agoOne of the things that companies rely on these days is engagement and playerbase. If you don't find that compelling, that's up to you, but Blizzard invests millions every year into maintaining their playerbase - so at least they find it compelling. Just by being a part of the starcraft community, you are providing support to activision blizzard. If we were talking about offline-only non-community driven content, sure... but this is a company that is almost entirely driven off of multiplayer games.
- lapetitejort 5y agoTo play Starcraft II, one must open Battle.net, potentially exposing themselves to ads for the latest shiny game, and may lead them to break their boycott by buying said game. Having to visit the store to use the product changes the dynamic. If I bought a widget from the widget store, then found out the owner sexually harassed their employees, I would continue to use the widget while boycotting the store because I would never have to visit it. But if I had to occasionally bring in the widget for a free cleaning, I'd stop using it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bakuninsbart 5y agoSome of the best fiction was written by people with absolutely despicable opinions like Francois Céline or Knut Hamsun. You can see it in their art, but their art isn't limited to it, and still holds a lot of value. Friedrich Nietzsche's opinions on women and politics are plain dumb, yet his other thought can be extremely compelling, and he is rightfully one of the most influential thinkers of modern times. Going back further in time will only make you miserable if you hold the work closely accountable to the person. Terrible people can still say really good things, and I don't believe it is different with games or modern entertainment in general. Old Blizzard games are still good, and old Louis CK sets are still funny.
- user-the-name 5y agoTerrible people can say good things, but there are a million good people out there saying good things that you could listen to instead. Why spend the limited time you have in this world on consuming the works of terrible people? There is more out there than you could possibly experience in a lifetime. Why not dedicate that time to people who are not awful?
- manofmanysmiles 5y agoLearning from an “awful” person helps you grow as a person. Also understanding the enemy. Also not all “consuming” of work is for “entertainment”.
- user-the-name 5y agoDoes it, though? Does it do that in a way that's better than just paying attention to people who aren't awful? I'm really not convinced here.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- supercanuck 5y agoIn 2021, your attention is a more valuable currency than you're wallet.
- aeturnum 5y agoI think for many people, but certainly not all, the wider culture of an escapist work is important. Looking at a fanciful image doesn't automagically distract you, there needs to be some amount of collaboration between your mind and the media you're consuming. You need to accept what it offers as an alternative. That can be harder for people when they learn about how things were really made. It would be hard to take a work arguing against slavery seriously, for instance, if it used slavery to produce it. I also think that these kinds of products, because they are indivisible creative works, suffer from rotting from within. Where you might be able to use the "reasonable" parts of Facebook or Google, once you start to think about a core element of a narrative as being in-geunine or compromised, that can undermine the other elements of the story. Especially in this golden age of game development, I think there are many other alternatives to Blizzard's games that allow people to think less and escape more.
- YinLuck- 5y agoThe guy has been playing the same un-updated game for 15 years. He clearly has a mental addiction to it and is using current events as a trigger to finally snap that addiction. It is irrational, but so is a lot of anti-addiction stuff (like surrendering to a higher power in AA). If it works for him, that's all that matters. There's no rational reason to play Diablo 2 in 2021 so quitting Dialo 2 over an irrational reason is still rational
- minusSeven 5y agoYou buy a game not just to play it but also to support developers. If you don't give a shit about this part you can always pirate it. By telling the company you will no longer use their product you are sending a clear cut message about that you a paying customer will no longer use their product.