4 ms·
I have family members that ARE landlords, and your description is totally correct: 1. Family members aren't "rich" by conventional standards, they worked for t
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I have family members that ARE landlords, and your description is totally correct:
1. Family members aren't "rich" by conventional standards, they worked for the government in mid-level jobs their whole lives and are retired.
2. They bought a house they planned to retire to, but then moved when they had issues with it. They planned to sell the house but due to timing issues (construction in the neighborhood) they wanted to wait, so temporarily rented it out.
3. They had bad timing: rented in early 2020, the renter paid 1 month of rent, and never after that. And I looked this guy up, he is a total freeloader, part of the blame is on my family for not better vetting him.
4. But the takeaway for small landlords is the government can basically appropriate your property whenever they want. So we're just left with giant landlords who can manage this risk, and which again leads to less available affordable housing and a further concentration of wealth.
- lettergram 5y agoThey aren’t supposed to be able to appropriate your property. We literally have an amendment against that 3rd, 4th and 9th amendments The Supreme Court refused to weigh in because “it was soon to expire”
- mrfusion 5y ago10th amendment too?
- vmception 5y ago5th amendment bars expropriation except without compensation I never considered the 3rd amendment to be a protection against that but I can see how soldiers randomly living in your home could be seen as government appropriation
- aksss 5y ago"[Recent 6th circuit decision against moratorium] deepens the circuit split with the badly flawed DC Circuit decision in favor of the moratorium, and thereby increases the likelihood that the issue will eventually reach the Supreme Court, if the moratorium is extended beyond its current July 31 expiration date. He is also right that the Supreme Court recently signaled that at least five of nine justices believe the moratorium is illegal, even as a narrow 5-4 majority also—for now—refused to block enforcement of the moratorium." https://reason.com/volokh/2021/07/23/thoughts-on-the-sixth-circuit-ruling-against-the-cdc-eviction-moratorium/ https://reason.com/volokh/2021/07/23/thoughts-on-the-sixth-c...
- aksss 5y ago> We literally have an amendment Feel the pain of 2A advocates. Or 14A (P&I) advocates. Or 10A advocates. Or.. The nature of government/authority is they will always creatively push the boundaries of what they can permissibly do. There are amendments that are considered "second-class" and even worse. If nobody defends it, it will not enforce itself.
- qqqwerty 5y agoThe government also allowed for penalty free mortgage forbearance and has allotted significant amounts of money for rental assistance. They may even allow landlords to apply for that assistance on the behalf of their tenants. For the above reasons. I struggle to be sympathetic to landlords. They were taken care of. And quite frankly, I think they are the least deserving of the assistance. Rent seekers and speculators should be last in line for help. When you buy an expensive house or a hot stock, things like pandemics, wars, and financial shocks are part of the risk profile.
- lettergram 5y agoMy friends parents had a house they fixed up, lived in, then moved. They then rented the house out and at the start of the pandemic gave the tenant a few months without having to pay (after she lost her job). After 6 months she agreed she was going to start paying (September 2020). She had a job, she had stimulus and she was buying nice TVs and stuff. She never started paying again. The “government said she didn’t need to”. My friends parents owe taxes, had to make repairs, have to pay insurance. They are out at least ten thousand dollars. At the same time, they are out of work. What are they supposed to do? Sell to black rock, who are getting free funds from the FED (ie their taxes)? https://strangesounds.org/2021/07/blackrock-is-buying-up-us-homes-like-no-tomorrow-real-estate-market-housing.html https://strangesounds.org/2021/07/blackrock-is-buying-up-us-... Landowners are typically nice, small time people who are renting out an old home. They take care of everything the renter doesn’t want to and in return receive a fee. The landlord takes all the risk. You’re basically saying “bankrupt the grandma and grandpa, because young people would rather buy meme stocks or TVs than pay rent” that’s not all cases, but the government did give out thousands in free money for the unemployed. The dominos by me in a rural community is offering $25/hr + tips and can’t find people to work. There are job openings everywhere and I think people can make it work. There’s not a great solution, but saying the landlord is on the hook when the government is supposed to represent everyone is not reasonable.
- qqqwerty 5y agoThe housing market is BOOMING!!! They are probably sitting on a ton of equity. If they don't want to deal with the tenant, they can sell and put a nice chunk of cash in their pocket. And the eviction moratorium does not remove the financial responsibility for past due rent. They can use threat of eviction after the the moratorium expires to force the tenant to pay past due rent. And if that doesn't work they can take the tenant to court. And as mentioned in my original comment, there will likely be financial assistance. And to reiterate, I have zero sympathy for landlords who are essentially engaging in rent seeking and speculation (whether they realize it or not). If grandma and grandpa loose all of their money speculating on bitcoin, I will have zero sympathy for them. It is no different if they loose it all speculating on real estate. If they can't handle they downsides they should have put their money in a safer investment.
- ryandrake 5y agoI'm sympathetic to the bad timing, but that's just part of business. If I decided to do a start-up in 2001, right when the market crashed and funding dried up, well, bad timing--that's unfortunately how it goes. Your family members started a business, and running a business comes with risk. COVID (and the resulting rent moratoriums) was a black-swan event as far as risks go, but black-swan events exist. I'm very risk-averse, which is why I don't hang my shingle out there and start a business. I was once a landlord too, and got kind of screwed so I definitely will steer clear of that risky business in the future.
- throwaway98211 5y agoBlack-swan events aren't just 'part of business' - they are generational events that upend the established norms of a market. What happened here is that the government changed the rules (i.e. risk / reward profile) of a well-established market overnight with very little recourse for the players involved. It would be like the government removing FDIC insurance on savings accounts during a bank crisis. Maybe necessary, but hard to argue it was fair.
- hansvm 5y agoThis seems to be countering the grandparent comment ("yes, but ..."), but I'm not seeing where you address the core point --- real estate has a known risk profile which the government has shown a willingness to upend without any stopgaps to help struggling landlords, and a natural consequence of that increased risk is that smaller landlords will be priced out.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> Your family members started a business, and running a business comes with risk. My whole point is the government changed the rules in the middle of the game. Certainly bad tenants are always a risk, but not bad tenants that the government forces you to house for over a year. What you're doing is like telling businesses that get nationalized by corrupt regimes "hey, business comes with risk". But my whole point is, eventually, nobody can accept those risks, so people choose not do to business, which actually makes things worse for everyone.