3 ms·
>... simply acknowledging small communities curate the best content This is true for some things. But for reliability reviews, for example, there's a certain p
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
>... simply acknowledging small communities curate the best content
This is true for some things. But for reliability reviews, for example, there's a certain power in large numbers. I'd much rather see reviews for common appliances from 200k people (or more) than the same from a group of 2000 appliance-centric folk. That's true even though the 2k set will likely know and care a lot more than many of the people in the 200k set.
On the other hand, with large numbers of people, it's much harder to deal with "95% of reviews are complaints" problem, which tends not to be so much of a problem with "enthusiasts".
- Root_Denied 5y agoWhy not both? Rotten Tomatoes gives the critic score side by side with the audience score, as does Metacritic. There's arguably value not just in both scores, but also both being presented side by side.
- spronkey 5y agoRotten Tomatoes is the epitome of why trusting expert ratings on their own is a bad idea. The number of times that the tomatometer is wildly off the general perception is insane, enough to make the tomatometer largely useless for myself at lease. It certainly does seem, though, that a company with Google's prowess in search, NLP, ML, algorithms, categorisation and the like should be able to do a lot better, even if the problem is incredibly difficult. My only explanation is that it doesn't suit the business needs of Google to do so.