4 ms·
I think that's very much a hindsight kind of thing. I mean, yes, Nikola was a scam. But in "the beginning" the only people willing to say that it was a scam w
by ajross 5y ago
I think that's very much a hindsight kind of thing. I mean, yes, Nikola was a scam. But in "the beginning" the only people willing to say that it was a scam were ones who sounded exactly like the much louder, better funded, and media-accessible people screaming that Tesla was a scam. This very site was filled with $TSLAQ nonsense. And it was all wrong, much of it deliberately so.
The investment world is drowning in deliberate misinformation. There's no path for reasoned criticism to break through. Pick any stock and there's someone willing to tell you it's a scam. Or a gem.
Edit: and this subthread is a perfect, shining example. Just look at all the people jumping in to perpetuate and argument that somehow Tesla is, I guess, comparably fraudulent to Nikola, a company that got caught faking a vehicle that didn't exist. No one trusts you people, because you sound the same for everything.
- hef19898 5y agoIn all fairness there was a non-zero chance of Tesla running out of money at one point. At the final word on Tesla being worth what it is hasn't been spoken neither. I do have to give Musk credit for being able to maintain Tesla the way he does, under everyone else the company wouldn't exist anymore. Not that I think Tesla is particularly well run so, but Elon's ability to entertain the market and keep money flowing is impressive.
- Aperocky 5y agoThe ability to run pump and dumps in crypto with impunity definitely helps.
- nickik 5y agoNo it doesn't. Stop claiming this nonsense. It is totally irrelevant for Tesla financials.
- heavyset_go 5y agoTesla's Q1 operating profit of $594M was slightly less than the sum of their $101M Bitcoin profit and the $518M regulatory credits they received.
- cycrutchfield 5y agoMy goodness, the regulatory credits meme once again. How are those short shorts feeling by the way?
- heavyset_go 5y agoAh, yes, the meme that is Tesla's own quarterly financial report.
- nickik 5y agoFunny how people like you are so desperate, at this point you literally can't even use the current quarterly report anymore and must talk about the last one. And then string together a bunch of revenue that you can then somehow argue 'doesn't count' for #reasons. Who cares about unit margin or operational margin, as long as you can pick a bunch of revenue items and by removing them they didn't make any profit. And even if your argument was true and they didn't make #realprofit, who would even care as long as they keep having their current growth trend at the unit margin they have.
- cycrutchfield 5y agoThe meme that the number somehow matters at all while completely ignoring the massive growth
- nickik 5y agoAnd in Q2 the lost $24M on Bitcoin. They got $300somethingM in credits. So what? Who the fuck cares. And the regulatory credit thing is so fucking played out that people who still bring it up can only be described as haters. Are you seriously unable to look at a long term trend? Can you seriously not see how Bitcoin is totally irrelevant in their long term story?
- nickik 5y agoWhile it is true that Tesla might have gone bankrupt. There is a big difference between 'this is a risk company with growth potential, be careful' and 'this company is fraud'. Many TSLAQ people were far more extreme then saying 'they could go bankrupt, car industry is risky. > Not that I think Tesla is particularly well run so, but Elon's ability to entertain the market and keep money flowing is impressive. The haven't really need to raise that much money in a long time. They did some raises in the last couple years but that money is mostly in the cash balance now. Its not like they are just raising more cash all the time.
- RC_ITR 5y agoHey, you’re not going to like hearing this, and feel free to ignore, but $TSLA is c. 20% below it’s peak valuation and still is trading at 100x earnings on pretty mediocre growth. It’s still wildly overvalued, people don’t talk about it as much though since the price is flat, not up. Be careful of confirmation bias.
- jquery 5y agoI think you just proved his point. NKLA was an outright scam, and Tesla wasn’t, but the way many people talked about Tesla was as if it was a scam selling vapor ware. It took a very keen eye indeed to tease out fact from fiction. Tesla may have “mediocre growth” as you claim (I strongly disagree) but the number of Tesla cars I see on the road are a testament that the company is no scam.
- Pyramus 5y agoInterested how you define 'scam'. Would you say Wirecard was a scam (their payments network is still in use today), or Enron? My point is that the fact a company is producing a product does not necessarily disqualify them from being a 'scam'.
- habitue 5y agoA scam can't be defined by the mere legal definition of fraud. A true scam is all about the feeling of people on the internet. Somehow people always forget that.
- marvin 5y agoNot sure I'd classify 100% year-on-year growth to revenues of $12 billion as mediocre, during a year when the production lines of two of their three cars were shut down for almost an entire quarter and we also went through the worst pandemic since 1918. The valuation is still steep by earnings and compared to likely competitors, but it's not based on speculation devoid of observations.
- 5y ago
- cma 5y agohttps://www.cnbc.com/2020/11/03/musk-tesla-was-about-a-month-from-bankruptcy-during-model-3-ramp.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/11/03/musk-tesla-was-about-a-month... Tesla almost went bankrupt. They started shutting stores that were tied into commercial leases that hadn't expired and all kinds of stuff. At one point they said they would never need to capital raise again and then did one 3 days later or something. They made wild statements of autonomous taxis by the end of 2020 in a desperate bid to build hype before the capital raise. They survived and raised a lot of capital from shareholders and now seem in no danger of bankruptcy, but it was either a real threat or the CEO is lying about it to be theatrical.
- johnsimer 5y agoBest time to raise capital is when you don’t need it
- RC_ITR 5y agoYou can't make a claim like: >And it was all wrong, much of it deliberately so. then act like people calling you out for that are calling Tesla a scam. It's a real company, they make cars, but the short sellers weren't and aren't crackpots from a 'Tesla is overvalued' perspective.