3 ms·
I agree. Definition is the same problem that has plagued other movements: feminism, gay rights, defund the police. The article cites "Critical Race Theory: The
by paulddraper 5y ago
I agree. Definition is the same problem that has plagued other movements: feminism, gay rights, defund the police.
The article cites "Critical Race Theory: The Key Writings That Formed the Movement," which is pro-critical race theory.
To cite Wikipedia:
> While critical race theorists do not all share the same beliefs, the basic tenets of CRT include that racism and disparate racial outcomes are the result of complex, changing and often subtle social and institutional dynamics rather than explicit and intentional prejudices on the part of individuals.
> CRT scholars also view race and white supremacy as an intersectional social construction which serves to uphold the interests of white people at the expense of marginalized communities. In the field of legal studies, CRT emphasizes that merely making laws colorblind on paper may not be enough to make the application of the laws colorblind; ostensibly colorblind laws can be applied in racially discriminatory ways.
> A key CRT concept is intersectionality, which emphasizes that race can intersect with other identities (such as gender and class) to produce complex combinations of power and disadvantage.
If you understood >90% of that, congrats; I'm still trying.
- _nicelaris_ 5y agoUltimately, it's just about assuming political power. Expect a similar level of intellectual and moral integrity from those propagating it that you would expect from an average politician.
- jfengel 5y agoCan you explain which parts are making it difficult? The sentences run a little long in that academic fashion, but the pieces are relatively straightforward. Some of the key bits: * Ostensibly colorblind laws can be applied in racially discriminatory ways Example: Prosecutors, police, and judges all act on their discretion. Both unconscious bias and explicit racism can cause some people to be charged, prosecuted, and sentenced differently, regardless of the law. * race can intersect with other identities (such as gender and class) to produce complex combinations of power and disadvantage Example: White women campaigning for the right to vote had a choice: include black people to expand their base, or exclude them to avoid scaring off a large contingent of racist white men. The movement as a whole chose the latter, and arguably it was the most effective choice for them. Similar pressures today put divisions between groups who could in theory band together. The sheer number of groups, and the differences in strategies they choose, tends to reinforce the status quo. * white supremacy as an intersectional social construction which serves to uphold the interests of white people "White supremacy" here is a confusing term, in that people tend to associate it with white robes and hoods. The term is accurate: many white people implicitly believe that the average white person is superior to the average black person. That holds even for people willing to vote for an extraordinary black man, have black friends, etc. It shows up clearly only in its aggregate effect, making it easy to dismiss any individual's contribution to it, but it's very clear when you're exposed to it every day. In some ways it's worse than the robes-and-hoods version of racism, because the latter is easy to reject and most people do, but that allows them to believe that they've done their part without having to closely consider their own beliefs and actions. And it leads to a catch-22. The people most likely to outright reject it are the ones defending their own egos. It's easy to dismiss any individual behavior and treat the aggregate effect as the fault of black people themselves. You'd basically have to live the life of a black person to disprove it, and that creates a No True Scotsman situation. What's clearer, though, is the way this is weaponized by the robes-and-hoods type racists to portray people honestly trying to get this across as a conspiracy. That this kind of out-and-out racism is still so prevalent should make it really easy to see why this entire question is still coming up. Does any of that help?
- paulddraper 5y ago> A key CRT concept is intersectionality, which emphasizes that race can intersect with other identities (such as gender and class) to produce complex combinations of power and disadvantage. I don't get it.
- jfengel 5y agoA minority can retain power by setting marginalized groups against each other. You can see it most clearly by looking at groups that are discriminated against for several reasons at once, like "gay black women". They often find themselves unable to make allies with other groups because even though they share one reason to ally, they'll still be separated by something else. That allows the dominant group to retain power despite not being a majority. They can form alliances with one group or another, who would rather gain the advantage of being second-class citizens rather than being third or fourth class citizens. The most visible example right now is "white women", who split 50-50 for Trump in both elections even though he has said quite terrible things about individual women and is certainly not doing anything to benefit them as women. But white men favor him by wide margins, and it's to the advantage of white women to be seen as good allies to white men. None of this calculus is necessarily conscious, on anybody's part. But if you ask individual white women why they voted for Trump over another white woman in 2016, you will probably find that the answer doesn't really justify it. Nor are individual white men gathering to concoct a dastardly plan to marginalize gay black women worse than gay women and black men. It just happens that history works out that way, and people who benefit from it are reluctant to change things. That makes it difficult to piece the full story together and figure out how to get around it. That's why "intersectionality" is an academic topic rather than a word that my browser recognizes (it's the only word I've written that's got a wavy red underline). The concept isn't fully understood and the picture is evolving. But it's a key component to critical race theory, which constructs this picture in terms of race first and other identities second. I'm not entirely sure that's the best way to construct it, but the case for it is much, much stronger than I first realized. There's a lot of history that gets omitted that shows a deliberate, conscious effort to use race as a way of separating people, on top of the gender discrimination that was already baked into European culture. So there's a ton more to learn about that, but that's a big unpacking of that sentence you quoted.