5 ms·
One has to believe at some point that liberty is worth a certain amount of risk. >Do you believe that someone's refusal to comply with basic sanitary precautio
by colechristensen 5y ago
One has to believe at some point that liberty is worth a certain amount of risk.
>Do you believe that someone's refusal to comply with basic sanitary precautions should take precedence over my and my family and loved one's desire to not die of a preventable disease?
Did you and your family get vaccinated? What unvaccinated people do does not affect your risk profile in any meaningful way. Are your kids too young to get vaccinated? The last flu season pre covid killed more under 18s than COVID-19 has.
Do we need government mandated vaccinations and mask mandates for every flu season now?
>And where do you draw the line in that refusal to comply with basic health and safety precautions? Do you also extend it to other viral diseases that are preventable by vaccination such as measles, or do you single out covid?
Do you get asked if you've had a measles vaccine before you get seated at a restaurant? Are you suggesting this is a reasonable action?
You draw the line where there is a real serious threat which passes a certain threshold.
But with COVID-19 like so many things, the people speaking loudly about promoting their cause in protecting us from it (not the professionals) have absolutely no conditions for victory and will endlessly move goalposts forward and endlessly try to do more regardless if risks change by orders of magnitude.
If you're vaccinated or too young to be vaccinated, COVID-19 is over for you. The risk went from 1 in 1000 people dying to no worse than the risk in any flu season, unless that very mild risk makes you think that we should reinvent what personal freedoms in society means, stop turning and ending pandemic into a catastrophe.
- rualca 5y ago> One has to believe at some point that liberty is worth a certain amount of risk. But you are not actually discussing anything related to freedom at all, right? You're just defending that your personal preferences should be unquestionably imposed onto everyone around you, aren't you? I mean, do you feel the measles or tetanus shots violate your freedom? I mean, if you really valued freedom then wouldn't you be doing your hardest to ensure that everyone around you should, say, not risk death by an easily preventable disease in spite of everyone except you taking basic precautions? > Do you get asked if you've had a measles vaccine before you get seated at a restaurant? Are you suggesting this is a reasonable action? You need to prove you are vaccinated when you travel internationally or enroll in a job or join a school. And this is an absolutely mundane thing for the entire world, because it's easily understood these are very basic precautions to not contract or risk transmitting diseases. There is no measles outbreak or even pandemic. There is however a covid pandemic. If you wish to get back to a normal life, the very least we can do is to mitigate the risk covid poses to society. This involves basic stuff like respecting social distancing, wearing a face mask, washing your hands, and get the vaccine. If a small but militant group insists in putting everyone at risk by intentionally and systematically violating basic health and safety precautions then the only hope society has is to mitigate this risk. So why yes, obviously yes. Don't you agree? Or do you actually believe that an individual's whims and irresponsiblr and reckless behavior should simply put everyone else's life at risk just because?
- colechristensen 5y ago>If a small but militant group insists in putting everyone at risk by intentionally and systematically violating basic health and safety precautions then the only hope society has is to mitigate this risk. Who is militant? And they aren't putting "everyone" at risk. They are putting themselves at risk surely, but the risk doesn't really spread to people who have been vaccinated. >You need to prove you are vaccinated when you travel internationally I also need permission from the government of the country I'm visiting to come at all. They can add conditions if they want and I can choose accordingly. >So why yes, obviously yes. Don't you agree? Or do you actually believe that an individual's whims and irresponsiblr and reckless behavior should simply put everyone else's life at risk just because? I don't agree. I think people have lost perspective and have very little idea what the risks of various situations are and can't tell the difference between a risk that could kill millions and a risk that could kill hundreds and are happy to charge forwards to try to prevent any risk regardless of how small because "doing something" has become as a religious mandate. >I mean, if you really valued freedom then wouldn't you be doing your hardest to ensure that everyone around you should, say, not risk death by an easily preventable disease in spite of everyone except you taking basic precautions? Freedom is not trying to force everyone around me to do what I determine is best for them. >do you feel the measles or tetanus shots violate your freedom? Tetanus basically only spreads through deep puncture wounds with soiled implements. I guess if I didn't seem like I was out of my mind I would want my doctor to accept refusing treatment for a painful and life threatening disease that could only ever effect myself... The question "do you think shot violates your freedom?" really shows that you don't understand my point at all and will continue arguing past and around whatever I have to say. I am opposed to de facto licensing of public activities based on a choice that should be mine to make. (I did indeed get vaccinated) When there was significant risk and incomplete vaccine access, different rules were acceptable, but only because of the large and temporary risk. Now that that risk is avoidable by anyone in the US who wants to avoid it, continuing to enable and enforce restrictions on everyday activities has gone too far, and normalizing the "papers please" activity does serious harm to our future freedoms.
- CogitoCogito 5y ago> They are putting themselves at risk surely, but the risk doesn't really spread to people who have been vaccinated. They _are_ putting those who have been vaccinated at risk since vaccinated people can still get sick. Also this ignores all of those who wish to, but can't be vaccinated for one reason or another.
- VBprogrammer 5y ago> If you're vaccinated or too young to be vaccinated, COVID-19 is over for you. The risk went from 1 in 1000 people dying to no worse than the risk in any flu season, unless that very mild risk makes you think that we should reinvent what personal freedoms in society means, stop turning and ending pandemic into a catastrophe. I'm not sure this is settled fact at the moment. There are known variants which have shown to reduce the efficacy of at least some of the available vaccines. The danger isn't from the individual unvaccinated person, it's from pockets of them creating a reservoir of the virus from which new variants can develop. Strong arming people into being vaccinated is the stick with which to try to limit these reservoirs. Personally, I'm comfortable with limiting peoples ability to attend mass events (which are elective and for entertainment value only) in the tail end of a pandemic without proof of vaccination, I'm less conformable about allowing employers (outside of perhaps those who work with people who are at risk) to do the same.
- colechristensen 5y agoSomething like five billion people have yet to have a single dose, I wouldn’t be too worried about “pockets” of holdouts yet. Yes, variants have shown to be less inhibited by vaccines… but that’s just it, less. Ever had a cold? Influenza? Variants make some vaccinated people sick, but almost none of them end up in the ICU, they’re full of unvaccinated people.
- A_non_e-moose 5y ago> Strong arming people into being vaccinated is the stick with which to try to limit these reservoirs. I suppose then that after every single person in more developed countries is vaccinated, we should start readying the troops for invasion into the less developed countries that, inevitably, will not be fully vaccinated? Otherwise, pockets > variants > travel > reinfection. Or is too inhumane to invade a country to force them to vaccinate fully? Maybe we should just isolate them economically and close borders with them until they do it themselves. How far should we go? I understood your personal thresholds, and thank you for sharing. For me only the government should make and enforce a decision on public health at scale, not any employer, that's my threshold. I have seen other thresholds being crossed in the last 2 years, but now mine has been crossed, and I don't see this slowing down. What's the next threshold to be crossed?
- ngc248 5y ago>>> One has to believe at some point that liberty is worth a certain amount of risk. Others will be taking a risk for your liberty, that is where it becomes unacceptable. We live in a society and individual freedoms must be balanced by the responsibilities towards your fellow man.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- colechristensen 5y agoThis misses the point. "Liberty" isn't the freedom to put yourself at risk with no consequences to anyone or anything else. It is recognizing that there must be, at some point, a prioritization of giving people choices that might impact others. >individual freedoms must be balanced by the responsibilities Must be balanced not obliterated by "responsibilities".
- ngc248 5y ago>>> "Liberty" isn't the freedom to put yourself at risk with no consequences to anyone or anything else. >>> It is recognizing that there must be, at some point, a prioritization of giving people choices that might impact others. There will always be a set of people who prioritize themselves over others and in the case of corona as we have seen it just takes 1 selfish person to start the snowballing effectt. We are seeing actual Zombie movie tropes playing out in real life coz of this corona pandemic. even if 98% of people get vaccinated, the holdout population maybe enough to incubate and spread new variants.
- throwaway_12_12 5y agoDo you really believe what you have written here? People who chose not to take a jab are zombies to you?
- detaro 5y agoThat's not what they wrote.