7 ms·
Pfizer backs down over ‘unreasonable’ terms in South Africa vaccine deal
- paulddraper 5y ago> During Covid-19 vaccine negotiations, the company sought indemnity against civil claims from citizens who had experienced adverse vaccine effects — meaning that the government would have to cover the costs instead. Aren't those "unreasonable" terms already the case in the U.S.? There's no liability, right?
- sschueller 5y agoI think the difference is that in the U.S. there is a law that protects Pfizer from lawsuits. In South Africa they wanted assets incase such a law isn't enforced or exists?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Dma54rhs 5y agoBut who foots the bill when you have problems with your heart afterwards? I mean in America where everything is private, is there some sort of fund for it?
- sschueller 5y agoyes, there is general fund [1] for all vaccination side affects but it pays out "very little". I don't know if the covid vaccine is part of that fund however [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Vaccine_Injury_Compensation_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Vaccine_Injury_Compen...
- realityking 5y agoFrom your link: > By 1999 the average claim took two years to resolve, and 42% of resolved claims were awarded compensation, as compared with 23% for medical malpractice claims through the tort system. That doesn’t seem like “very little”. Or do you mean the amount paid out for successful claims is lower than in regular court?
- sschueller 5y agoI'm referring to the cost of healthcare in the U.S. compared to the awarded amount. If serious health effects exist I assume the care will exceed the amount awarded.
- realityking 5y agoThe average awarded amount per case, depending on the year, is between $250k and $1m. Considering this is the average of hundreds of cases there must awards significantly above this for those who have serious health effects.
- jollybean 5y agoThe other difference is that US courts and other civil institutions have integrity. Outside of the civilized world it's a little bit 'no man's land' - SA's former leader is going to jail on corruption charges, and the country let lose with mass violence. If there ever was an interesting example of 'information suppression' (or avoidance), and there are many, it's the problems recently in SA. There's so little coverage of the insane violence. It's reasonable that a company is not going to want subject themselves to that system.
- mschuster91 5y ago> There's so little coverage of the insane violence. The tinfoil hat in me believes that media is not really interested in foreign violent demonstrations and reports as biased as possible about domestic protests turning violent (e.g. BLM), so that the domestic population doesn't even get the idea that violent protest can actually achieve something. Just look at French labor/social protests... immensely violent, and pretty effective when compared to Germany where the social net was pretty torn up during the last decades.
- jollybean 5y agoThere is definitely an aspect of fear contagion, but nobody is 'in charge' of the media so these things are harder to pinpoint.
- darwingr 5y agoThat's my interpretation as well. This is a situation where a dollar valuation of the trust in the justice systems is being made.
- unparagoned 5y agoWell Americans always explain why they pay more for drugs is that they subsidise the rest of the world(drug companies). One could say the US economy is based around the people(government) giving money(subsidising) to the rich(drug companies). So the terms may not seem unreasonable in the us but are in other countries. Since the condition is effectively the government covering the risk rather than the drug company paying for insurance like they should in a market economy
- pvaldes 5y ago>Americans always explain why they pay more for drugs is that they subsidize the rest of the world And receive talent from the rest of the world... Take in mind also that US patents and benefits economically also from lots of discoveries made from non American researchers out of US. People that were subsidized and educated with money of their own countries and emigrated later to US. Is more a symbiosis than a charity.
- tebbers 5y agoI’m pretty sure this is the case in the UK too - Pfizer basically immune from any claims resulting from side effects etc.
- pkaye 5y agoQuite a few countries have used vaccine injury compensation schemes over the years. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Countries-and-provinces-that-have-introduced-vaccine-injury-compensation-schemes_fig1_51111456 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Countries-and-provinces-...
- pvaldes 5y agoSo they can focus in continue saving millions of lives since December, providing a solution that works in a record short amount of time. It seems a fair deal for society
- darwingr 5y agoThat's sort of how I explained it to a friend. Manufacturers would not be willing (or allowed) to distribute without the full trials and recognition by the FDA. Where the government, on behalf of the sovereign, decides "no, we NEED it now" the full authority for the risks is declared not by the manufacturer but by the sovereign. Thus, in their great need and power, the sovereign gives them immunity in their actions in writing via the EUA. It's good to be the king...but who laid the crown?
- forcry 5y ago>So they can focus in continue saving millions of lives since December Not sure. Are the researchers working on the vaccine are the one handling the claims? I mean, whats this thing about "focusing on saving lives" got to do with being not responsible for the product? >It seems a fair deal for society Only if these companies act in good faith. Knowing what we know about Pharmaceutical companies, It is beyond me why anyone would think they would.. If you said that "we were desperate so we have to take the risk of them possibly behaving bad", then it would have made much more sense.
- 5y ago
- pkaye 5y agoYes you cannot go through a normal court. The US uses a vaccination compensation fund. If someone is harmed by vaccines, they can make a claim with evidence in a special court and the court will determine the compensation. Each dose sold has a 25 cent surcharge to fund these claims. For Covid I think they will do it differently since the government is paying directly. https://www.hrsa.gov/vaccine-compensation/index.html https://www.hrsa.gov/vaccine-compensation/index.html
- realityking 5y agoThe Vaccine Injury Compensation Program doesn’t seem to prevent you from going through a regular court. From your link > The special master's decision may be appealed and petitioners who reject the decision of the court (or withdraw their petitions within certain timelines) may file a claim in civil court against the vaccine company and/or the health care provider who administered the vaccine.
- refurb 5y agoThe FAQs make it seem like it's not as straightforward. "Most of the time, you must first file and have your claim processed with the VICP before a civil lawsuit can be filed against the vaccine company or the person who gave the vaccine"
- paulddraper 5y ago> The US uses a vaccination compensation fund So, the same terms as Pfizer was trying to negotiate in South Africa? Doesn't make it any more/less unreasonable, but the article should at least mention that millions of doses have been given under similar arrangements.
- pkaye 5y ago> demand that the South African government put up sovereign assets guaranteeing an indemnity against the cost of any future legal cases. The bigger issue was requiring to put up sovereign assets as a guarantee. That is not something Pfizer would ask of the US government.
- beebeepka 5y agoYou think it's reasonable to let companies rake huge profits without any responsibility? And that's how it should be... because it's the norm in America? I find this world view concerning
- cbg0 5y agoIt's not reasonable, but if you want that vaccine quickly for your citizens, you can be sure the company making it won't want to assume liability.
- pverghese 5y agoIf you dont expect quick vaccination then you can obviously deny the company from providing it. But alas, you cant have your cake and eat it too
- refurb 5y agoYes and the reason why vaccine injury funds were developed are: "It was created in the 1980s, after lawsuits against vaccine companies and health care providers threatened to cause vaccine shortages and reduce U.S. vaccination rates, which could have caused a resurgence of vaccine preventable diseases." https://www.hrsa.gov/vaccine-compensation/index.html https://www.hrsa.gov/vaccine-compensation/index.html
- vmception 5y agobased lol, these are our role models
- gameman144 5y agoNot sure what you mean here. Yes, these are great public health role models: the establishment of this indemnity was a brilliant public health move.
- forcry 5y ago>establishment of this indemnity was a brilliant public health move. That basically removed one of the fundamental checks and measures in a capitalistic system to ensure that consumers get a quality product, and replace it with regulation authorities that are corrupt to the bones..
- sschueller 5y agoWhat I would find interesting to know if people would trust more a vaccine from their government (for example the CDC) or a private vaccine maker that has immunity and wants to make a profit? Also how this differs from country to country.
- teh_infallible 5y agoThe CDC holds patents for vaccines.
- darwingr 5y agoI thought it was NIH, they are usually entitled to a percentage, if not half, of the royalties on all vaccines. https://www.axios.com/moderna-nih-coronavirus-vaccine-ownership-agreements-22051c42-2dee-4b19-938d-099afd71f6a0.html https://www.axios.com/moderna-nih-coronavirus-vaccine-owners...
- kderbyma 5y agoPfizer should be judged by the Morales of Mephistopheles.
- pkaye 5y agoI know WHO has been concerns about this and setting up a compensation fund for developing countries. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-who-vaccines-compe-idUSKBN2AM266 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-who-va...
- RikNieu 5y ago"This would apply even if the case were brought due to the company’s own acts of negligence, fraud or malice." Uh, yeah, no. I fully support my country's stance on this. We simply cannot afford to indemnify an multinational company from their own product.
- jollybean 5y agoThen they simply may not sell it. The potential liabilities are gigantic, and the risk calculation may put the equation under water. It's the problem with a lot of medical products, particularly vaccines which are hard for pharma companies to market. But it's made worse in regimes that are either litigious, have little in the way of caps over civil claims, or have Justice Systems which are compromised. South Africa is a very corrupt state, it's just too easy for that system to act in a way that does not have integrity. That's the real world risk/reward equation and it's unavoidable. It's for similar reasons that it's a lot harder to raise financing for building infrastructure in SA (or anything else) than otherwise - the interest rates charged are considerably more as there's greater risk of failure, or problems, and even addressing commercial concerns becomes difficult if the justice system is compromised. For this reason, the loans to SA would have those risks 'priced in' at much higher interest rates ... which by the way is the other way pharma companies would normally give on the indemnity issue negotiation - by raising prices, but price becomes a problem for other ethical reasons.
- RikNieu 5y agoThat argument might hold... but other commenters here suggested the same terms were put to first world countries, like the US and UK.
- davidhyde 5y ago> “South Africa is a very corrupt state, it's just too easy for that system to act in a way that does not have integrity.” Being a corrupt state does not imply a corrupt legal system. SA’s legal system is based very closely on the UK’s (with some Dutch law and African customary law tweaks thrown in) and is considered to be very good actually. Some legal systems around the world are weakened by lobbying and politically placed judges and there is lack of evidence that this is a problem in the SA legal system. A recent demonstration of this resilience to corruption is the fact that the courts recently put the ex-president Zuma in jail; someone with a lot of corrupt power. Besides, protecting yourself against a corrupt legal system with beneficial legal clauses just doesn’t make sense. Why even use a contract at all if you don’t believe in the legal system? They put those clauses in there precisely because the legal system is good and they will be held to account. No, Pfizer is just being a bully because they think they can get away with it. Same thing happens every day when individuals feel trapped into signing unfavourable employment contracts because they are too far along and feel that there are no reasonable alternatives. I think that it’s a good thing that this generated bad PR for Pfizer.
- sameer50kph 5y agoThere was twitter thread with leaked PFIZER MANUFACTURING AND SUPPLY AGREEMENT https://twitter.com/eh_den/status/1419653002818990085 https://twitter.com/eh_den/status/1419653002818990085 . the contents of the tweet details are now deleted but i found tweets backup at https://australianvoice.livejournal.com/54777.html https://australianvoice.livejournal.com/54777.html
- refurb 5y agoInteresting read, but the website author is a bit wacky and conspiratorial. "If you were wondering why Ivermectin was suppressed..." As someone who has a been party to a contract like this, not much of it is all that unusual.
- f6v 5y agoThat is such a fertile ground for anti-vaxxers. Number one argument I hear is “If vaccines are so safe, why does nobody take responsibility for the side-effects?”. And to some extent, they’re right, you know. I bet pharma execs are walking away with six-seven figure bonuses no matter what.
- deadalus 5y agoPfizer now sees $33.5 billion in 2021 vaccine sales, up from $26 billion, and says a third dose of its #COVID19 shot "strongly" boosts protection against the Delta variant.
- dataflow 5y ago> Number one argument I hear is “If vaccines are so safe, why does nobody take responsibility for the side-effects?”. And to some extent, they’re right, you know. Aren't people saying the government does compensate people who experience side effects? https://www.hrsa.gov/vaccine-compensation/index.html https://www.hrsa.gov/vaccine-compensation/index.html
- mikedilger 5y agoI clicked on "Covered Vaccines". The COVID-19 vaccines aren't on the list.
- f6v 5y agoThe government might compensate, but people don’t trust a vaccine if the manufacturer isn’t willing to accept the responsibility.
- ekianjo 5y agoLove the fact that a few years ago, Big Pharma, including Pfizer, was the devil for most people, but now that they are providing vaccines and asking for extraordinary measures to be protected from any kind of lawsuit, then everyone is quick to forget their past practices and "swallows the pill" as if nothing ever bad happened with this companies before.
- sergiomattei 5y agoCompanies can do good things and simultaneously be criticized for the bad shit they do. Nobody forgot about anything.
- ekianjo 5y agowhy give them a blank check?
- refurb 5y agoAt face value this doesn't seem unreasonable. Pfizer is offering to supply a vaccine that is generally being approved under emergency conditions, could cause harm to recipients (even a small number) which would put the company at risk of hundreds of civil lawsuits across the globe. Western countries generally have vaccine funds where the gov't promises to shoulder the burden of any vaccine injuries. This shields the manufactures from liability. When France or the UK say they will cover the costs you can count on their word. When developing countries say this, you may want some way to hold them to the promise.
- whoaisme 5y agoI really like how people are making comparisons to the US, as if South Africa is a real country rather than a failed state on a bad day and a typical African state on a good one. What's more likely? Pfizer is trying to take over South Africa with their miracle vaccine or a bunch of ANC goods are trying to shake them down because that's all they do in that country?