4 ms·
So basically your line against tyranny lands in exactly the same place where 5 year old puts it when mom offers him a hat in cold autumn evening and refuses to
by scotty79 5y ago
So basically your line against tyranny lands in exactly the same place where 5 year old puts it when mom offers him a hat in cold autumn evening and refuses to give him desert later if he doesn't put it on.
Can't you choose a hill to die on to be something less dangerous? Like veganism or something?
- ghoward 5y agoWe are just finding out that vaccinated people still spread the virus, so getting vaccinated only protects the person who is vaccinated, which means that all of the arguments about how the unvaccinated are going to hurt people is only true if vaccinated people do too.
- scotty79 5y agoWe knew vaccinated people might spread the virus and official sources didn't make any claims that they don't until research was done that indicated that vaccinated people spread the virus way less than the uncaccinated. So basically what you wrote is false. Except that vaccinated people also might hurt people. It's just way less likely than dor unvaccinated. Same way as drunk driver has higher probability of hurting someone then sober driver, but sober driver might hurt someone too. Despite this we still have a strong stance against drunk driving. Which is reasonable.
- ghoward 5y agoWhether it is reasonable depends on how much more likely a drunk or unvaccinated person is likely to hurt people. We have good numbers on drunks. We do not yet have good numbers on unvaccinated people. Also, you may not have heard it, but I heard all over the place from "experts" that vaccinated people would not spread the virus.
- scotty79 5y agoAt least few times less, up to few dozen times less. Like you said we don't know precisely how much. Drunk driver is around 13 times more dangerous as sober one. [0] So what if some people are wrong? They are being corrected. Many places didn't allow vaccinated to ditch the masks. And I think nowhere they encouraged them to take unnecessary risk. [0] https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=http://pricetheory.uchicago.edu/levitt/Papers/LevittPorterHowDangerousAre2001.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjHgf_T9obyAhWRzYsKHbkPDYEQFjADegQIJxAF&usg=AOvVaw2tmcLN7A-APJzEd0wCnNWN https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=http://...
- ghoward 5y agoIt seems the CDC recently said that the viral load in vaccinated people is the same as unvaccinated [1] so... [1]: https://www.nbcnews.com/science/science-news/experts-back-cdc-change-masks-delta-variant-spreads-rcna1526 https://www.nbcnews.com/science/science-news/experts-back-cd...
- scotty79 5y agoEven if vaccinated people just as easily infect other people as unvaccinated they'd still spread the virus less because they themselves are less likely to get infected with the virus.
- Sloppy 5y agoThis is the kind of confused weak thinking that causes new infections to rise at 150% Of course vaccination radically reduces the ability of the vaccinated to spread Covid, 90% of them never get it. Sure of the other 10% that might get it some do and wow they can spread it. By the time you get past the IFs vaccination is astoundingly successful but the more vaccinated that are exposed to the unvaccinated the more of those 10% WILL get infected. This seems crystal clear to me and actually I'm surprised at how low the rate of "breakthrough" cases are (I think I heard < 1% but fact check).
- ghoward 5y agoIt is not necessarily correct that 90% of vaccinated people won't get the virus; they might be asymptomatic because that is what the vaccine is meant to do: help your body fight the virus. It doesn't stop them from catching it.
- ghoward 5y agoAlso, your comparison is bad. It's more like a mother giving her son a winter hat, and he refuses it because he knows he doesn't need it, and his mother does not give him dinner. Because that is where we seem to be headed: refusing to let people work so that they can have the basic necessities, just like dinner is for a child.
- scotty79 5y agoOf course he "knows". Kids who don't want a hat always "know" they don't need a hat. Even if that was dinner. They'll eventually get some dinner even if they adamantly refuse a hat. Or they can just wear a hat even if they "know" they don't need it. Sometimes cooperation is worth more than sticking to what you believe is true.
- ghoward 5y agoAnd sometimes, it is not. I am accepting the consequences of becoming a second-class citizen. If you still disagree with my choice, then what you desire is control, not cooperation.
- scotty79 5y agoOf course I disagree. Your decission puts other people health at risk for no benefit to you or anyone else. My desire is not control just education of people so they can avoid stupid decisions like the one you made. Somebody framed vaccine as a freedom issue and you happily agreed to accept this framework and internalize it. For me freedom of not taking a vaccine is same as freedom to avoid drinking unsweetened, unflavored water. I mean, sure, you can, but why in the world would you want to? The only result is increasing probability of harm for you, your loved ones and possibly other people. And even if you want it, why would you put it on your freedom banner? Why not something less harmful? Like freedom to avoid eating meat?
- ghoward 5y agoBecause once the freedom to make medical choices is taken away, a line has been crossed that can be easily crossed in the future in a far worse way. But at this point, you should know that your line of "no benefit" is absolutely false. Also, assuming the vaccines are all benefit is false. Every medical treatment has risks; failure to recognize that is the first thing that tells me someone did not actually think about vaccines. That goes for health officials too.