3 ms·
I don't see anything in that statement which admits to infringement, willful or otherwise. You may be reading a bit too far between the lines on this one. Not
by Natsu 15y ago
I don't see anything in that statement which admits to infringement, willful or otherwise. You may be reading a bit too far between the lines on this one.
Note that the alternative was to abandon "our work." That pretty solidly indicates that they believe that what they've made is their own.
But that's what I hate about software patents: it forces people to abandon their own work because someone thought of something that, when phrased in the broadest language legally possible, makes it sound like they've though of someone else's ideas, even when they've never actually created anything of the sort.
- PotatoChips 15y agoAndy's email, together with the fact that Google executives discussed obtaining a license for Java just weeks before Oracle filed a multibillion-dollar lawsuit is pretty damning. "documenting the discussion could make Google look bad to a jury, which might conclude that Google knew it was using Oracle's technology without permission." "I'm not saying there was willful infringement, but how are you going to answer this?" demanded U.S. District Judge William Alsup, as he grilled Google attorneys during a hearing in which he repeatedly probed for weakness in the arguments of both sides." At one point, Holtzman directed Alsup to an internal email sent to Google Android chief Andy Rubin from a Google engineer. Under the direction of Google co-founders Page and Sergey Brin, Google engineers explored alternatives to using Java technology, but ultimately concluded they "all suck," the email said. ========> Google should license Java technology, according to the email, which Alsup read aloud in court. SOURCES: http://www.siliconvalley.com/companies/ci_18525231?source=pkg http://www.siliconvalley.com/companies/ci_18525231?source=pk... http://newsandinsight.thomsonreuters.com/California/News/2011/07_-_July/Federal_judge_criticizes_Google_and_Oracle_at_hearing/ http://newsandinsight.thomsonreuters.com/California/News/201...
- Natsu 15y agoThat makes more sense, but that doesn't rule out the idea that they believed they had a legal right to do this in spite of Oracle's position. It's clear that they knew they'd be in hot water with Oracle, so if anything, I would say that they believed that they would be vindicated in court. In the end, I guess it boils down to whether or not one believes that they infringe on any valid patents or copyrights. I'm not sure that I do, but I have a hard time seeing any software patents as valid.