4 ms·
My first thought is "why isn't this prohibited by the Fifth Amendment," and it seems that the court order actually answers that question already: "With respect
by jcranmer 5y ago
My first thought is "why isn't this prohibited by the Fifth Amendment," and it seems that the court order actually answers that question already:
"With respect to the Fifth Amendment, Reffitt's entering his password in to the Subject Device does not violate his privilege against self-incrimination, because his act of production would not be testimonial, since the only potentially testimonial component implicit in his act of producing the unlocked/unencrypted device is a foregone conclusion."
In somewhat more detail, this is permissible because the act of unlocking his laptop does nothing that can be seen as incriminating himself:
* The laptop is already known to exist, and known to be owned by the user.
* What is being sought on the laptop [a video the defendant recorded at the event] is already known and admitted to exist, and it is known that the files in question are (at least were at one point in the past) on the laptop.
* The video in question was prepared prior to the search warrant and investigation, so it's not a Fifth Amendment violation to produce it unless the production itself is potentially incriminating (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Hubbell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Hubbell). But as mentioned above, the ability to produce the information isn't protected anymore, since there's no question that the individual could produce it.
This feels like it ought to be a violation of the Fifth Amendment, but it seems that it's pretty long-standing precedent that there's really nothing here that would violate the Fifth Amendment. Were this password-protected, or even a locked box in a safe, there would similarly be no Fifth Amendment violation, and the biometric aspect of the request doesn't (nor should it) change the analysis meaningfully.
- Grieving 5y agoI'm curious, would it be a violation if they instead invoked the Fifth Amendment to protect other contents of the laptop not acknowledged to exist?
- ksaj 5y agoI was thinking along this lines, but then he would have to declare that there is something on that encrypted drive that is unrelated but still could be used to incriminate him. That seems like an unwise declaration to make.
- tzs 5y agoProsecutors can deal with that by giving immunity. They can either give "transactional immunity" or "use immunity". Transactional immunity, commonly known as total or blanket immunity, protects you from future prosecution for any crimes related to your testimony. Use immunity prevents the use of your testimony or any evidence derived from that testimony against you. You can still be prosecuted for the underlying crimes if they only use evidence that they got some other way. For example, suppose your testimony shows you are fencing stolen goods, and that comes as a complete surprise to prosecutors. With transactional immunity you could never be prosecuted for your past fencing. With use immunity they would essentially have to ignore that they now know you are a fence. But suppose later they catch a thief, and offer the thief a plea bargain if the thief tells them how the thief is getting the goods fenced--and that thief names you. Prosecutors can then come after you for that.
- infamia 5y agoBoth sides of any litigation are obligated to produce all relevant materials in response to subpeonas from each other. This is what the discovery phase is all about. The protection against unlocking someone's phone, laptop, etc. prevents the other side of the litigation from rifling through someone's device and going on a fishing expedition -- especially until the defendant can consult an attorney. Blatant fishing expeditions are not allowed. It does not allow people to hide evidence that is specifically requested as a part of a court ordered subpeona. Basically, if the other side requests a piece of information, you can't legally withold that evidence from the court. If the court discovers such behaivor they can sanction the non-compliant party (financial penalties for instance), issuing a negative inferrence (i.e. we'll just assume the worst about the material and make that a part of our decision), all the way up to issuing a default ruling (i.e. you lose). Trying to hide evidence is the quickest way to piss off a judge and you definitely don't want to do that. Judges do not take kindly to anyone who challenges the court's authority.