9 ms·
The article itself argues that we consume music in a way that is fundamentally different from the way we consume television shows and movies, thus rendering the
by kstenerud 15y ago
The article itself argues that we consume music in a way that is fundamentally different from the way we consume television shows and movies, thus rendering the comparison invalid.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoRight, and I think that's unfair. Even if it's true, it doesn't warrant the implication that Spotify doesn't provide a value-based service, or that it's bait-and-switch, or that they have malicious intent, or that it can't be a supplement to buying music a traditional way. To look at it another way. I have, in my current library of music, listened to over 400 albums in the last 3 years. I'm not ashamed to admit that I've not paid for all of them. The heavily listened to favorites, I have, but not all. Even if Spotify quadrupled in cost... it would still be small compared to (400 * $5) or (400 * $10). Not to mention the value from offline playlist prefetching, sync-free mobile access, and access to the same library on all 3 computers and my mobile devices.
- ThomPete 15y agoThere is no such thing as we consume music in a way that is fundamentally different. Previous behaviors does not mean natural law. The entire argument only shows a lack of careful thinking on the matter. We consume music many different ways. Radio, pandora, on the tv, in the mall, in games, cd, gramophone on the disco, live music and so on. You could as easily argue that the spotify model shows that access beats ownership. If anything the way the music industry want us to consume music is what is fundamentally different and out of date. The article is so shallow and can only be on the front page of HN because spotify is is new in the US.
- zantzinger 15y agoAnd I think that that assumption/argument is invalid. I'm sure I've read somewhere about studies of user behaviour in, say, iTunes (your personal music) compared to on a subscription service like Spotify. The studies showed that people who had access to a limited amount of music of owned music would listen intensively (fewer songs, lots of times); whereas people with access to a subs service would listen extensively (more songs, fewer times). There was some stat about a favourite song being listened to far less frequently when there was more to explore.
- ThomPete 15y agoSpotify stats show that the majority of people using spotify listen to non-chart music. Humans are an explorative but economic species. When the cost of exploration goes down guess what goes up.