3 ms·
The problem is that most people spend most of their time on "Which Harry Potter character am I" and stuff like that and they're already Harry-Potter-saturated a
by renewiltord 5y ago
The problem is that most people spend most of their time on "Which Harry Potter character am I" and stuff like that and they're already Harry-Potter-saturated at that time. Contextual ads have their place, certainly, but chasing ROI ultimately does lead you to target segments based on other things.
For instance, if you were browsing high-end networking hardware and you decided to go browse chicken recipes, it's still better to show you network device ads simply because even if you have a 1/1000th chance of converting on them, you'll be worth more than buying chicken.
- WalterBright 5y agoNote that I'm willing to pay to browse relevant ads, as are a large number of people who buy specialty magazines. But there's no advertisement broker that provides such a service to web sites. They all follow the google/amazon model of serving irrelevant and annoying batman and travel agency ads, which motivate people to install ad blockers. Note that (before the intertoobs) there were other products where people were willing to buy ads to browse: 1. the yellow pages 2. newspaper classified ads 3. JC Whitney catalogs 4. Hemmings Motor News 5. all the computer/electronics/hobby magazines Another method is exemplified by the "Detroit Muscle" car show. It is ostensibly about how to soup up your car. But it's actually an ad platform, as they use various tools and supplies to do the work, and show how to use them. That's what pays for the show and it's why I watch the show. I like ones about how to bend metal and here's the tool that does it. There are shows on how to weld and here's the welder for the job.
- asdff 5y agoThose paper based ads works exceedingly well particularly if you don't know the area. For example, growing up my grandparents knew next to nothing at all about what toys kids were interested in. When they wanted to buy us toys for christmas or a birthday or something, they'd seek out relevant advertising in the form of the Sears catalog toy section, and browse through all popular toys on offer and their prices all in one place. We'd even circle the toys in particular we wanted from that catalog. I can't imagine what they'd do today if they were still around trying to buy things for grandchildren. You can't exactly get a catalog from Sears anymore. You have to go on a wild goose chase on the internet. Its a chore even for me having grown up with the internet.
- WalterBright 5y agoI ask people to send me Amazon links to their gift list :-)
- warkdarrior 5y agoWhat the Sears catalog provided, in addition to a way to choose items, was a curated list of items that were chosen to be good (or good enough) in they category. Amazon is more of an unregulated flea market.
- asdff 5y agoIf it was about chance of conversion and being worth a lot, why aren't I getting ads for learjets all the time instead of for paper towels? If the learjet ad converted 1/1000000 of times, I'd be worth probably an order of magnitude more buying a $50m jet than buying a $6 pack of scott towels even with the low conversion rate, but the scott towel ads are what follows me around the web after searching once for them, and these are ads I continue to ignore because what influences me with my paper towel choices isn't an idylic image of some smiling person wiping a table, but how much they cost at my grocery store. It just seems like conversion rates would improve no matter what you are selling if you just spend a little bit more time thinking about advertizing in relevant areas vs the firehose approach that is done now, banking on the large numbers of it all to overcome the small conversion rate. If Scott wants to sell more paper towels to me, they could almost guarentee my business if they stopped advertising via irrelevant ads, and advertised in relevant spaces such as if they included a coupon for their paper towels with my weekly grocery store mailer that made their offering cheaper than their competitors.
- mdoms 5y agoAll of the research I have seen (of which there is very little) shows that targeted advertising offers only a marginal benefit (low single digit percentages). Is it worth alienating your users and being generally creepy for such marginal gains? https://techcrunch.com/2019/05/31/targeted-ads-offer-little-extra-value-for-online-publishers-study-suggests/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/05/31/targeted-ads-offer-little-...