5 ms·
I like this idea, but once you build something with some given wildlife in mind... what happens to the rest of the wildlife? I live in an area where open areas
by duxup 5y ago
I like this idea, but once you build something with some given wildlife in mind... what happens to the rest of the wildlife?
I live in an area where open areas often have a lot of trees. That's great, lots of deer, people like deer ... problem is the deer have no predators. The deer don't have to move around and love to eat certain tree saplings in particular. Result? The forested areas simply don't have those trees or bushes that the deer like to eat anymore. Forested areas that would have thick underbrush are absolutely clear cut (as far as underbrush goes) by the deer. It's so complete you'd think humans went through and clear cut the brush, but it's the deer.
Worse, that impacts other animals who rely on those trees and bushes.
I feel like there's WAY more balance to be considered here and second order effects we don't understand.
We like to help animals we like to see / are easy to help (there are some rabbits outside my window now, I like them) but helping them might not be the best choice.
- Angostura 5y ago> I like this idea, but once you build something with some given wildlife in mind... what happens to the rest of the wildlife? You don't build for a particular species in mind. You build for biodiversity.
- duxup 5y agoBy it's nature you can only be so diverse when you've decided to build. The system is wonky to begin with, the opportunity to put wolves in my area is ... pretty much 0.
- Angostura 5y agoI'm not sure what you are saying. You plant a wide range of pollinator and native trees designed to offer roosting and nesting space for birds, bats and insects. etc. Wy jump straight to wolves?
- Schiendelman 5y agoThe concept of "building for wildlife" doesn't mean picking and choosing the cutest animals - it means trying to understand that balance and maintain it. The people who study ecosystems understand a lot of these second order effects well, and we're always learning more. The concept here is to start listening to those people.
- duxup 5y agoThe wildlife evolved to operate in an ecosystem with other wildlife that building alone makes impossible. I don't buy into the idea that they can just 'balance' it without many of the species. You can't tell deer to stop eating what they like, or raccoons to stop breeding / living in denser populations in suburban areas.
- user-the-name 5y agoWe're already messing up the balance massively by existing. The point here is to reduce the harm we are already doing.
- soperj 5y agoi live in an area with lots of deer. They don't shoot the cougars that come into town, they tranq them and relocate them. So there are no predators for the deer. What's the answer?
- anonAndOn 5y agoThe cougars don't just eat the deer, they also change the behavior of the deer (as one would if they were constantly worried about killers hiding in the bushes). The only way to restore balance is to bring back the keystone species.
- soperj 5y agoI know. I used to be able to walk right up to the deer when I moved here. I've chased them off the property enough times though now that as soon as they hear the front door, they run, and they actually go quicker through the yard then they used to.
- edgyquant 5y agoThis is a weird idea I’ve had but… would it be possible to e.g. breed domestic dogs who will eat the deer but won’t be aggressive to humans? I have a pitbull who is really nice to people, other dogs and even cats but absolutely goes crazy when it sees one of these city rats coming out of a bush. I raised her obviously she wasn’t a wild animal. Just a thought
- duxup 5y agoWould be interesting just to breed dogs to chase them ... a lot. Sounds like a lot of work, but interesting idea. Some studies have found that just "scaring" some prey animals reduces their breeding and encourages them to move around more.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoLol, you don't really need to selectively breed dogs to chase animals. All dogs have what's called a "prey drive," to an extent, which is essentially their inborn desire to hunt other animals. It's left over from when they were wolves. Different breeds have higher or lower prey drives, so it's not at all uniform from breed to breed or dog to dog.
- duxup 5y agoI'm thinking breed them to chase them... I'm thinking in a manageable way. Any dog will chase them, and then the dog will also run out into the road. We don't want dogs doing that ;)
- actually_a_dog 5y agoYou're talking about training, not breeding. Training is what makes a herding animal herd rather than run off in the woods and chase deer. :)
- duxup 5y ago
- jdavis703 5y agoThis really seems to be a problem of suburbanization (which also drives of natural predators). If cities had strong urban growth boundaries we could avoid a lot of this sort of human/animal conflict.
- duxup 5y agoIf there was no sub-urbanization ... there would be same issues on the edge of urbanization. It's a development thing, not a category I don't think.
- gerbilly 5y agoSounds like your area doesn't have a deer problem. It has a wolf problem. In other words there aren't any. You might like this essay on this very topic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thinking_like_a_mountain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thinking_like_a_mountain https://www.ecotoneinc.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/aldo-leopold-tlam.pdf https://www.ecotoneinc.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/aldo-l...
- asciimov 5y agoI live in one of these areas (Texas). Wolves were taken out by 1970. I do wish we would introduce them, but I'm not certain that my neighbors would be so happy about it. In my area, we have city deer. These are deer that live in the green belts and navigate through the city. I wonder what would happen if wolves were reintroduced. Wolves normally keep to the outskirts of human civilization, but would they drive more deer into the city. Or would smart wolves head to the city for the easy pickings.
- drewburg 5y agoDemonstrative example in practice of re-introduction of predators is the wolves in Yellowstone[0][1]. There are also studies which say that this instead destabilizes the ecosystem[2]. For what it's worth, I think more data from investigation is needed in more diverse ecosystems and including different scopes of time. [0]https://www.yellowstonepark.com/things-to-do/wildlife/wolf-reintroduction-changes-ecosystem/ https://www.yellowstonepark.com/things-to-do/wildlife/wolf-r... [1]https://www.nps.gov/yell/learn/nature/wolf-restoration.htm https://www.nps.gov/yell/learn/nature/wolf-restoration.htm [2]https://phys.org/news/2019-04-effects-reintroducing-predators.html https://phys.org/news/2019-04-effects-reintroducing-predator...
- mapster 5y agoGenerally speaking, ecosystems should be managed for ‘focal’ species, those with the largest requirements and pivotal role. In this case, deers natural predators. a re-introduction or deer culling may be paired with this approach.
- johnrob 5y agoChilling thought: Deer:Underbrush::Humans:Earth