4 ms·
Elemental lead is nearly completely insoluble and very difficult to absorb. If entrained in dirt, even more so. Breathing vapors or aerosolized fine powders isn
by lazide 5y ago
Elemental lead is nearly completely insoluble and very difficult to absorb. If entrained in dirt, even more so. Breathing vapors or aerosolized fine powders isn’t great, but uptake even then isn’t high compared to many other toxic substances - that is usually the dominant form however. It usually requires some kind direct ingestion + acid exposure of a significant amount of lead, or breathing in a large quantity of lead vapor or fine dust to get notable exposure.
Which is exactly what you get when every car in a city was burning tetra ethyl lead in large quantities, and/or kids were eating sweet tasting lead paint chips.
Leaded AVgas is a concern, but dilution of the resulting lead from combustion gets diluted very widely very quickly resulting in actual low concentrations. And since it’s not ‘every car in the LA basin’, it just isn’t at the scope or scale of a problem you’re making it out to be. We’re probably having bigger issues from all the random new stuff companies put into tires (including carbon nanotubes now), which then gets ground up and dispersed as fine power at the million ton scale every day.
Lead is not mobile in typical soil or water environments, and as long as the water isn’t strongly acidic, it settles out and stays where it lands. There is naturally occurring trace lead in most soils - it’s a somewhat common element.
- henearkr 5y agoLead tetraethyl is not elemental lead. I think you are mixed up. Lead tetraethyl (the component found in lewded gas) is easily absorbed, it even diffuses through skin to the blood!
- sokoloff 5y agoOnce combusted, the exhaust contains primarily lead oxide (PbO), not TEL (C8H20Pb)
- henearkr 5y agoAlright, but it's still not elemental lead. I'll look up PbO, but I'm expecting to be horrified at its harmfulness, rather than be reassured. And neither PbO is "naturally occuring", it's anthropogenous. Naturally occuring Pb species are lead sulfide, sulfate, and carbonate.
- lazide 5y agoDid you find anything? I can't find any evidence it is significantly more toxic (hard to quantify, and most sources didn't seem to try - it all seemed within an order of magnitude or so). At least what I ran across seems to be that the organic lead compounds (aka tetra ethyl lead, among others) are super nasty. Similar to how mercury is not great (and has similar exposure routes), and the common compounds of mercury in soil, etc. are the same - but the organic mercury compounds that occur when mercury is in wetlands environments are super nasty (like 100000x) The EPA mentions on their lead site (albeit backhanded) that runoff, water contamination, etc. is usually not an issue even at heavily contaminated sites. Where you see lead poisoning around drinking water, it is always due to very acidic water conditions which leach/dissolve the lead. This can be from lead pipes pulling water from acidic sources (big no no), or heavily acidic mine runoff going through heavily contaminated sites. The only major concern ground contamination wise seemed to be at smelting sites, which is truly a unique situation - and well know and easy to test for. I did find some evidence that it is also a concern with fly ash, though apparently the other really nasty stuff (including radon, uranium, nasty active chemical species, etc.) overwhelms the lead concern. Places still have to do a ton of paperwork on it though. If you die from fly ash exposure, it isn't going to be due to lead poisoning.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoSomeone else just made a good point though. These planes run full rich a lot which means some of the fuel is not burnt but simply evaporated, cooling the engine. I still think the amount is so minor as to not cause concern but it's a point.
- nate_meurer 5y agoContaminated soils don't contain elemental lead. The dominant form is lead oxide, one of the two common additives in lead paint (along with the carbonate) and also the end point of the combustion of TEL in fuel. Lead from lead oxide is easily absorbed orally from soil, paint chips, and household dust, and it's also a serious inhalation hazard. > sweet tasting lead paint chips What makes you think lead paint tastes sweet? > Lead is not mobile in typical soil or water environments Which is exactly the reason lead-contaminated soils are such a long-lasting hazard. It's the reason little kids playing in the dirt around old houses can be poisoned decades after contamination was laid down. For example, here in Denver entire urban neighborhoods were built on the site of a smelter that was demolished a hundred years ago, and the contamination is still largely unchanged. Remediation requires completely replacing the top several feet of soil. > There is naturally occurring trace lead in most soils - it’s a somewhat common element. Significant deposits of lead in surface soil are rare, and are limited to sites with unique geology. The vast majority of distributed lead in surface soils is of human origin.
- sokoloff 5y ago> What makes you think lead paint tastes sweet? Lead acetate has a sweet taste. Lead paint flakes/dust contain lead acetate. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/sugar-of-lead-a-deadly-sweetener-89984487/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/sugar-of-lead-a-...
- nate_meurer 5y agoWhat makes you think lead acetate was ever used in paint?
- sokoloff 5y agoResearch. https://healthyindoors.com/2018/11/lead-paint-sweet-aint https://healthyindoors.com/2018/11/lead-paint-sweet-aint
- outworlder 5y ago