2 ms·
Yes, the original article is long, but it has some paragraphs where all the claims of the Meow authors are quoted precisely. They have indeed claimed some cryp
by adrian_b 5y ago
Yes, the original article is long, but it has some paragraphs where all the claims of the Meow authors are quoted precisely.
They have indeed claimed some cryptographic qualities for it, which have been shown now to be false.
In any case this article is interesting for anyone who enjoys cryptanalysis, because it describes in great detail how to break such a hash function or message authentication code.
Meow has serious weaknesses so breaking it is not a great achievement, but the very clear and well illustrated explanation of all steps is quite valuable.
This reminds me of FEAL, one of the earliest proposals (1987) for a cipher to be used as a replacement for DES.
FEAL was proposed by a Japanese company, but it was immediately broken. It was revised a few times, but all revisions were also broken easily.
While FEAL sucked as a real cipher, it was great as an example cipher for teaching cryptanalysis.
Meow belongs to the same class, it is easy to break, which makes it good for demonstrating how to do it.