4 ms·
Hi, I don't think "the war on drugs" is really germane to the stated subject of this site - hacking and startups. There are better places to discuss it on the
by davidw 15y ago
Hi,
I don't think "the war on drugs" is really germane to the stated subject of this site - hacking and startups. There are better places to discuss it on the internet.
- tomkinstinch 15y agoHacker News is for anything of interest to hackers, not just computers. The independence and individualism that home gardening affords is right in line with hacker ethos. This story of the epistomological challenges surrounding poppy cultivation could be seen as analogous to the perceptions toward possession of a password-cracking program. What one could use to audit security or for intellectual exercise could also be used with malicious intent. The role of authority in these matters is of interest to many hackers.
- davidw 15y agoThis is a game called "7 degrees of hacker news" where you try and "connect the dots". For instance, "This story of the epistomological challenges surrounding poppy cultivation could be seen as analogous to the perceptions toward possession of a password-cracking program." is certainly one of the more creative ones I've read here. When you start being that broad though, you really stop being able to exclude anything. Most of us are interested in a great variety of things, and, being intelligent, well read people, have opinions - sometimes strong ones - on things like politics too. Those topics, however, are not really hacker news.
- tomkinstinch 15y agoFair enough. For me at least, it was a nice and well-written diversion from coding.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- davidw 15y ago1) There's no guarantee that people voting this up are 'good hackers'. 2) The same guidelines indicate that politics are off-topic.
- GiraffeNecktie 15y agoThere's a big difference between "policies" and "politics". There wasn't really anything political in the article.
- sliverstorm 15y agoGiven the fame and popularity of Paul Erdos within the hacker-type groups I've known- perhaps opium is actually of very great interest to hackers?
- davidw 15y agoBreasts are of great interest to many hackers, yet that doesn't make pictures of them on topic.
- GiraffeNecktie 15y agoNo, but a provocative and thoughtful piece about the female breast in North American culture might be of interest.
- Mz 15y agoThere was actually a lively discussion about the engineering of bras or some such at one time that I participated in. I even volunteered "scientific" style info about my own personal history of bra sizes and most everyone was a perfect gentleman, with one tiny slip up by a guy who "generously" offered to help me carry them and then promptly removed the remark after I politely indicated it wasn't really appropriate. I don't recall any protests about it being "off topic" either.
- davidw 15y agoThat actually sounds much more obscure than something labeled "war on drugs", which is a good thing. I think genuinely "random" articles that treat some topic in depth can be fascinating and don't really harm the site. A classic example of this is the Neal Stephenson one about the guys who lay cables around the world. The "war on drugs" type articles, IMO, come from people who are really eager to share their particular point of view. I get that feeling too: "This guy's right! How can people possibly vote for Berlusconi?!", but I think articles posted due to that motivation are generally a Bad Idea, and I think if people are honest with themselves, they're not really posting them because they find them fascinating, but because of "dammit, that's wrong" or "this is spot-on! Everyone should read this!"