5 ms·
There's a real world version of this, the DePuy Quantified Judgement Method.[1] It's fairly simple - weapons have a weight value (sword=1.0), you add that up fo
by Animats 5y ago
There's a real world version of this, the DePuy Quantified Judgement Method.[1] It's fairly simple - weapons have a weight value (sword=1.0), you add that up for the forces committed,
there's a quality of troops multiplier for each side,
some adjustments for defensive preparations, and you get a measure of combat strength.
DePuy was a US. Army colonel, and the weights come from analysis of real-world battles. His observation is that the side with a 2x advantage almost always wins. If nobody has a 2x advantage, either side can win.
So, real-world war has a "hard counter".
- capableweb 5y agoExcept real-world doesn't have any counters at all but instead anything can happen at any time almost. The outcome of encounters in war is controlled by endless amount of parameters, just because someone has more swords than another doesn't mean they will almost always win. See Simo Häyhä, the Finnish sniper who killed ~500 Red Army soldiers during the Second World War as an example of this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simo_H%C3%A4yh%C3%A4 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simo_H%C3%A4yh%C3%A4
- AbrahamParangi 5y agoYour example of the most outlier sniper of all time doesn't really conflict with "advantaged side almost always wins".
- afrodc_ 5y agoThey also lost the war
- bcgraham 5y agoCan this line of reasoning be extended to poker?
- bawolff 5y agoI feel like nukes are a pretty hard counter.
- sofixa 5y agoThat smells like bullshit. Asymmetric warfare ( or guerilla warfare) has been successful time and again since the Napoleonic wars, regardless of how overwhelming the enemy was. And Napoleon himself won multiple times against the odds ( so much so the Coalition made a deal to only attack when he isn't in command). And there's the usual incompetence, bad luck, or tactical/strategic brilliance. Just in the last century we have the Russians ( in Russo-Japanese war, WWI, Winter war, WWII), Austro-Hungarians, Italians, Ottomans, Americans ( multiple times), Arabs ( against Israel) fail miserably against a theoretically inferior in terms of size and weaponry enemy.
- EamonnMR 5y agoA hard counter in RTS parlance is a unit or tactic that will win a fight even even if they are grossly outnumbered. A classic example would be a ground unit that cannot hit air units. Any number of those ground units will die to a single air unit.
- dsr_ 5y agoA phalanx armed with shields, swords and spears can't damage an A-10; the A-10 can shoot or bomb them into ineffectiveness. Hard counter. A submarine is a hard counter to an aircraft carrier -- that's why we put sub-hunters on carriers and surround them with anti-sub ships. A fusion-warhead ICBM is a hard counter to most things.
- dragontamer 5y ago> A submarine is a hard counter to an aircraft carrier -- that's why we put sub-hunters on carriers and surround them with anti-sub ships. In video games that's true. But aircraft carriers can have sonar-equipped helicopters take out submarines. Aircraft carriers are also faster than submarines, so in practice, I'm not sure if submarines can practically chase down an aircraft carrier and actually disable them. Honestly, I'm willing to bet that most of those Destroyers in a Carrier-strike group are there to shoot down cruise missiles (which are probably a modern, hard counter to Carriers. Cruise missiles are very expensive, but Carriers are even more expensive). ---------- "Hard Counters" exist in the real world, and they're far simpler than you think. A tank is the "Hard Counter" to small arms fire and even small-autocannon (30mm or less) fire. Modern tanks are immune to such weaponry. No matter how many AK-47s you send towards a tank, they will all die. You need to switch out your infantry loadout: you need to start sending RPGs / Missiles / IEDs if you want your infantry to have a chance vs tanks. -------- Historically, an A10 or Helicopter was the "Hard Counter" to a tank. Tank guns have extreme difficulty aiming that high (tanks are designed to take out ground targets), and a tank's 130mm cannons are powerful: but A10 / Helicopters will dodge most of those shots due to the low-rate of fire. ------- The concept of "Hard Counters" leads to the modern battlefield concept of "Combined Arms". You should never send a platoon of tanks by themselves to face an enemy (they'd just die against their helicopters). You instead, combine different arms together to form one group: send a tank with infantry + AA guns, so that you can face all sorts of different enemies as a team. With "combined arms", you negate your weaknesses somewhat.
- rcxdude 5y agoIn RTS terms this seems more like 'supply' or 'pop' count: a measure (often ingame) of the relative power (and cost) of each unit, such that equal supply counts of different units are in theory on the same footing (often with a hard cap to avoid game-breakingly large armies), absent any specific advantages or counters. Even small differences in supply can be extremely significant in most RTS: a 2x supply advantage is almost always overwhelming. Hard counters are exactly what would be a counterexample to that.